>>2525657
>>2525658
It only seems people are forgiven enough to be tolerated and nothing more beyond that. Which, I guess, is understandable. Especially if people felt offended before.

>>2525659
I dunno, I think we all genuinely like Shuckle now.

>>2525659
>>2525660
Yeah, Shuckles a cool guy.

Like, if you actually put in the effort to change and be a decent person Ponychan will like you. Half of us liked Manley just because he kinda tried sometimes.

>>2525660
Do we? I guess I haven't paid attention.

I probably don't spend enough time around here.

>>2525658
>>2525659
>>2525660
Honestly, I think part of that is because a lot of people here don't remember when I was the Manley before Manley was a thing.
>>2525662
P-Ponychan likes me, r-right?

How did this get onto the first page again?

>>2525664
>Admiral Tang Wenli
>Tang
Dat citrus flavour!

>>2525660
>>2525661
Agreed

>>2525664
>mod asking us inferior beings

>>2525661
I'm probably just remembering the negative things I see. The negatives always seems to stand out more in life.

>>2525663
M-maybe? I have no idea about all the various relationships that go on here.

>>2525664
Magic!

>>2525661
Yeah, this.

>>2525662
I haven't run across anypony who doesn't in a long time, at any rate. And pretty much nobody brings up the before times except to make examples like this.

>>2525663
I dunno. I remember. I'm sure Audrey here remembers. A lot of the people still here are old timers.

>>2525664
Did it get bumped off?

>>2525665
It stands for... uh... tangled?

>>2525668
Audrey is an old fig? I thought she came here around late 2012?

>>2525670
...that's a pretty long time ago, shuckle!

>>2525669
Are you going to start expression viewering Disney grils too?

>>2525670
E-e-early 2012

>tfw eternal newfig

>>2525670
Audrizen? She's pretty old, isn't she?

Am I mixing up my times? I don't remember exactly when I first met her.

>>2525671
Everypony's always older than me! It's like there's this whole secret ponychan history I don't know!

Congrats on the publishing, Raven!
Are they going to keep the poems unnamed or are you going to go with the "To Samantha" and "To Rachel" titles? I didn't even know the poems had names.

Make you you cut out the article and keep the clippings in a safe place. It's always good to be able to have something physical to look back on. Especially if it has to do with the first steps towards becoming successful in something you love!
Keep it up!

>>2525671
That's only about a year ago. Still new pony material if you ask me.
>>2525672
Yeah that was about after I left for efchan, or just before. But wait, you actually remember when I was a retard? How? I thought you came to efchan after I left?
>tfw eternal newfig
Give it about a year.
>>2525675
>Congrats on the publishing, Raven!
Oh yeah, the original purpose of the thread. Congrats Raven!

>>2525674
>tfw late 2011 is still considered a newfig by the tru old timers
I-I-I'm old, I swear!

>>2525677
Nah, I'd consider anything 2011 old pony material now. Next year 2012 will be old pony. Then in two more years, 2013 will be old pony. I have a whole system for this.
>tfw next year 2012 will be old pony
Where has the time gone?

>this thread has over 500 posts
Is that the record for a non sticky non serial? It has to be close.

>>2525678
>tfw oldpony by Shuckle standards

>>2525676
I remember when you were at the top of /ef/s official autism rankings. That was long time ago.

>>2525676
Nah I don't remember, I'm j-just s-saying you're c-cool n-now

>>2525679
I know! This is amazing! /arch/ this shit! We had a Star Wars party in the middle of it! And Orng got drunk!

>>2525679
I remember your "Smile Smile Smile is objectively terrible" thread reaching past 550.

>>2525681
Yeah, this was actually a pretty fucking epic thread.

>>2525680
>tfw oldpony by Shuckle standards
There are some people who would still consider me a new pony, at least compared to the REALLY old eggheads.
I remember when you were at the top of /ef/s official autism rankings.
Funny how things change right?
>>2525681
Oh. Well thank you!
>>2525682
The funny part is, I don't actually hate Smile Smile Smile anymore, in fact I think it's kind of catchy. I just dislike it because of the fandoms treatment of it and the missed potential in the music
>>2525683
Are we toasting in an epic bread?

>>2525681
>>2525682
I think /arch/ing a thread comprised of about 50% making fun of one user would be in poor taste.

>>2525684
Yeah, you said you'd changed a lot, and I believe you.

Smile Smile Smile came out after I stopped paying attention to the fandom's music cadre.

>>2525685
I have to agree with this.

>>2525684
>Funny how things change right?
Iknorite?

>Are we toasting in an epic bread?
We are become the epic bread toast.

>>2525685
Awww, killing our fun with your responsibility and junk.

>>2525663
i just remember one thing you did back in 2011 that made me dislike you
then i just sorta ignored you for a long long time

>>2525679
manley threads back on /chat/ sometimes reached over 1000 posts...or something near that

>>2525687
Hey, at least it wasn't locked and/or deleted. And I don't think Raven's discovered that he can delete his threads yet.

>>2525689
He knows I think?

Sometimes he'll bump a dead thread to say he's "Burying it" and then delete it. It's weird, especially cause half the time he doesn't delete it.

>>2525685
Yeah this is not /arch/ worthy, though I think the suggestions to /arch/ it were in jest.
>>2525688
I never saw one that was that large.
>>2525689
>And I don't think Raven's discovered that he can delete his threads yet.
No, he can't, then we'll never reach the 1000 post mark!

Holy shit, this thread still exists on the front page?

>>2525689
Shhh, don't tell him.

>>2525690
...wut. That's the strangest thing ever.

>>2525689
>>2525690
he deleted the thread he made with the flaming swastika he drew
so he does know how

>>2525691
yeah... manley, kmate, raura and some others, probably citizen would sit and talk about SEXUAL THINGS

>>2525692
it was on page two before...somepony did something to it

>>2525694
You were there too, eggheadlord, don't lie!

I just realized who you were... I am dum

>>2525694
I blame Astra. Always blame Astra.

>>2525695
rarely
and only to pop in and say dumb things like "kmate is a girl and we just did strip poker over skype and it was sooooo hot!!!!!!!!!!!!"

i was always really uncomfortable with you peoples talkin bout yo sexshul hapninz
so i made a point to avoid his threads when you were all talking about that


haha

>>2525697
What did we even talk about? All I remember is the telling shit to Manley and then I think I posted once or twice about how the weirdest girls would always hit on me.

Jesus fucking titty christ slap me with with a bag of dicks.

What. The. Fuck?

>>2525698
Those threads just seemed like a little bit of everything
The OP never mattered

>>2525698
all i remember is "ugh...more sex tawkz" and hiding the thread

you could go ask kate or something


>>2525700
"Great news!"
seeing how everything happened really makes me feel bad, even with how he acts

>>2525699
That about sums it up. Somewhere in there we watched the Star Wars Holiday Special. Thread's all over the place.

>>2525698
>>2525700
I remember those kinda vaguely.

>>2525697
Oh shit, you're Caterpillars. That took me a while.

>>2525702
gosh
what non-anon people even post scootapoo?
ignore ornj, he a but

>>2525702
>Oh shit, you're Caterpillars. That took me a while.
>not memorizing the tripcode

>>2525703
>>2525704
Check your paying attention privilege.

>>2525705
[ ] Privilege

>>2525705
D-don't tell me what to do, cis scum!

What a great thread