Discuss fanfiction, get writing advice, or get your story reviewed

Search /fic/ threads

Name  
Email  
Subject  
Message  
File     
Password  (for post and file deletion)

File 134593973598.jpg - (151.29KB , 894x894 , Twilight i_like_books_by_axian_art-d52j26v.jpg )
117432 No. 117432
#Discussion
In an attempt to give lesser known stories more attention, I thought we could start a /fic/ Book Club. Each week, we'll pick a Friendship is Magic fanfiction to read and discuss here.

Nominations:

>The Writing on the Wall
Synopsis: Daring Do can't believe her luck when she is asked to help explore the most ancient tomb known to ponykind. But terrible danger awaits her, for beneath the earth rests something beyond equine understanding.
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/42409/The-Writing-on-the-Wall

>Moments Worth Sharing
Synopsis: After a very stressful day visiting her prized student in Ponyville, Princess Celestia is left alone to contemplate and watch the sunset. From an outsider's perspective, she has everything she could ever want. But has she ever really had anything at all?
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/36141/Moments-Worth-Sharing

>Right
Synopsis: Twilight decides to go out for a friendly night of drinking with her two friends, Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy, to relieve the stress of planning her brother's wedding and defending Canterlot against the changeling invasion, but not all is as it seems.

A letter arrives in the middle of the night, informing the unicorn that one of her two friends has been replaced by a changeling.
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/32919/Right

>The Ship-off
Synopsis: What makes a good story? Is it delicate prose and captivating description, as Twilight Sparkle claims, or is it non-stop action and entertainment, as Rainbow Dash has been arguing? With a stalemate between them, they decide there's only one way to settle this once and for all - a write-off!
The prompt? "Romance".
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/44277/The-Ship-Off


If you would like to nominate another story to start with, here are some guidelines.
>Nothing that breaks Ponychan’s posting rules.
>Completed works only.
>It must have less than 10k views.
>No crossovers (Daring Do and Doctor Whooves don’t count.)
>Ideally it should take less than a week to read the whole thing.
Unspoiler all text  • Expand all images  • Reveal spoilers
>> No. 117434
File 134594103272.jpg - (19.89KB , 256x256 , 26189_256.jpg )
117434
>>117432
I won't add a nominee now as I'm more interested in seeing new to me works.

So based on synopsis my vote for first read goes to Right.
>> No. 117438
I suggest live readings. It gives a set time for everyone to sit down and join in. Then afterwards you can know everyone's read the story, and everyone's going to be there to discuss it.

Not to mention, live readings can be pretty fun. I think it'd give the event that extra bit to making participation enticing.
>> No. 117443
File 134594609263.png - (105.38KB , 440x599 , 134376697178.png )
117443
I wouldn't mind a /fic/ book club. I rarely read fanfiction, and what I do read is mostly on recommendation from people I know.

>>117438
The only problem I see with that, is it would require organizing people to meet at a certain time, which would not only be headache inducing, but also just not work out due to differing schedules.

I like the idea of discussing the fic in a thread, but I think we'd have to have a set date for discussion, and any discussion prior to that is either not allowed, or has to be spoiler tagged. (Preferably the former.)

Also, I'd like to cast my vote at 'The Writing on the Wall'
>> No. 117447
>>117443
>Times
I'd suggest Sunday 00:00 UTC.

That's midnight (or 1am) for Brits, Sat 5–8pm for Americans, and ~10am for Australians and East Asians.
>> No. 117465
But we already have Oprah's Book Club, what more could you ask for?
>> No. 117468
File 134597036959.jpg - (287.77KB , 700x1061 , 68427_-_Raoh_artist_blubhead_big_macintosh_cutie_mark_fist_of_the_north_star_hokuto_no_ken_human.jpg )
117468
>>117443
>I like the idea of discussing the fic in a thread, but I think we'd have to have a set date for discussion, and any discussion prior to that is either not allowed, or has to be spoiler tagged. (Preferably the former.)
I favor this over a live reading, both because of scheduling and because I have the technological skills of a deceased walrus.
>> No. 117484
>>117438
>>117447
The only problem with that for me is that I couldn't be there since it'd be 3 am, so my vote goes to discussing "moments worth sharing" in-thread.
>> No. 117495
I certainly like the idea, though it seems it could get a tad tricky to coordinate everyone that wants to participate. A thread would probably just work better, although it would be far less entertaining.

But I'll vote for "Right" and see where this goes.
>> No. 117497
>Dr. Whooves doesn't count as a crossover

wat
>> No. 117503
File 134599756047.png - (544.23KB , 436x600 , bloom78234662624ol0.png )
117503
Let's kick this off then, shall we?

I will be doing a live reading of a short story (~2k words) over Skype at 22:00 UTC today (in about 6 hours). If you want to participate or simply come listen, add me on Skype (details in the email field).

>>117468
You don't need a microphone or anything (unless you wanna talk), and it's a pretty simple program to install. If you can manage to post on a *chan, you can probably figure out how to get Skype working.
>> No. 117504
>>117503 Do you know when that is in good ol' british time? I'd love to listen whilst writing or drawing my own stuff.
>> No. 117506
>>117504
http://para.ms/time/2012-08-26T22:00:00
>> No. 117507
>>117506 Thanks. Now, how do I know what your email is? I'm not sure what the email field actually is.
>> No. 117508
>>117497
He's a canon character who's appeared on the show.
>> No. 117514
File 134600384730.gif - (499.81KB , 500x281 , Howstupidcanyoube.gif )
117514
>>117508
>> No. 117515
>>117514
I know, right? His name is Dr. Hooves! Silly W.
But he is "canon". Named collector's card is his claim to fame, I believe, although he hasn't been called it on the show yet.
>> No. 117516
>It must have less than 10k views.

Don't you mean Words?
>> No. 117517
>>117516
No, I meant views. The idea is to give lesser known fics attention, instead of just whining about whatever's currently featured on FimFic.
>> No. 117532
>>117517
I still think that 10 K views is too much. how about 5?
>> No. 117535
>>117532
Sure, that's probably better.
>> No. 117536
>>117507
Hover your cursor over my name.

Starts in approx 1 hr.
>> No. 117572
>>117532
>In an attempt to give lesser known stories more attention, I thought we. . .

I sort of dislike this whole part of the thread. While I think there should be a 10k limit to avoid having the reading material be something everyone has read, I want to read good stories. And frankly, a lot of the good stories have a lot of views.

That's just my two cents on the matter.
>> No. 117614
>>117572
Not entirely true.
>> No. 117619
>>117572
And there are a lot of good stories without lots of views as well. We'd only be giving more attention to stories that deserved it, presumably.
>> No. 117697
File 134612061729.png - (203.54KB , 442x531 , Twilight131324707073.png )
117697
Well, I had a lot of fun during yesterday's live reading. When should we schedule the next one?
>> No. 117698
I would highly recommend Administration is Magic, despite it going against the length and "completed" requirements. It's simply phenomenal, and that's coming from me.
Personally, I enjoy longer stories as opposed to short one-shots, so I don't mind a reading taking place over several meetings as long as it's good.
>> No. 117706
>>117698
The only length requirement is that it can be read in under a week. And at 75k, it shouldn't be too hard. Also, so long as the ending of the current chapter is satisfying, I think an exception can be made. I just worry that something will happen, and it'll never be finished.
>> No. 117718
File 134614200485.jpg - (50.38KB , 299x288 , 134025572335.jpg )
117718
>>117706
>75k word stories
>incomplete stories

Complete one-shots only, please.

Views shouldn't matter, though I'd rather more obscure stories for the sake of this being more "diamonds in the rough" than "read shit from the feature box, then bitch about how shit it was".

>>117697
I suggest doing the next one Friday 22:00 UTC.
>> No. 117727
File 134615933202.jpg - (173.23KB , 498x700 , 52604__safe_twilight-sparkle_cute_plushie_books.jpg )
117727
I probably won't be able to participate because of timezones, but I've been reading some one-shots lately, so have some suggestions.

>The Carnivore's Prayer
The gryphons were not always monsters. That came later.

In the earliest days, they were our friends. They flew alongside pegasi. They shared the land with earth ponies. They studied beside unicorns. There was no fear between us. That came later too.

Time drew our people apart, but it was not time that made them monsters. They made that choice themselves; they chose their fate. And it was the
greatest gryphon who sealed it.

He was born, many years ago, on a mountain far to the north...
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/37761/The-Carnivore's-Prayer
(how this is unviewed enough to fit the requirements I don't even want to think about)

>Home Is Where the Harp Is
Ever since Bon-Bon left for a new life in Manehatten, Lyra's life has lost its focus. She gets up, she goes to work, she eats, she goes to sleep. One day she knows she's going build up the courage to tell Bon-Bon how she really feels about her and they can live happily ever after.

That day will never come. Something terrible is happening in Equestria. Something that could be the end of the world.
The Smooze has arrived and no-one can stop it, not even Twilight Sparkle. What hope then does Lyra have?
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/32513/Home-Is-Where-The-Harp-Is
(delicious Blueshift)

>Who Makes the Wind Blow?
I've always wanted a cloud... and now the day is finally here.
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/30872/Who-Makes-the-Wind-Blow%3F
(most obscure Vault feature ever)

>Five Should Be Enough
When a tragic event befalls Applejack, she takes drastic measures in an effort to prevent it. But can a simple farm pony make a difference in the face of an inevitable end?

A story about the sacrifices we aren't willing to make, and those that we are.
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/32384/Five-Should-Be-Enough
(haven't read it, but /fic/ lurves timeloops)
>> No. 117731
>>117727
> The Carnivore's Prayer
That story in every way fits the description 'Diamond in the Rough', it's darn good.
>> No. 117741
>>117727
>(how this is unviewed enough to fit the requirements I don't even want to think about)
Off-the-cuff guess: "Eeew, griffons!" I had that phase myself, sad to say.
>> No. 117756
File 134617354958.png - (1.95MB , 1639x712 , the_flight_of_the_alicorn_by_wizardwannabe-d5b5q4i.png )
117756
>>117718
I think the current "end" chapter caps fairly well, all things considered.

>>117718
Wellll, it's not your thread...
We could always use the live-readings as a jumping-off point to get people interested in stories. So, for example, we could choose longfics to read the first two or three chapters before moving onto something else; if people found it interesting, they could always read the rest on their own time.
>> No. 118223
File 134644516804.jpg - (8.44KB , 320x240 , _4ey.jpg )
118223
>>117718
>Friday 22:00 UTC
Just a heads up, this is still happening! It's happening in less than 90 minutes, in fact.

Add me on Skype to join in.
>> No. 118681
Bump. Do we have another session planned, and does anyone have an idea for a story for someone (me) to read?
>> No. 118682
>>118681
You could read The Writing on the Wall, unless someone has another fic they'd like to have read.

http://www.fimfiction.net/story/42409/The-Writing-on-the-Wall
>> No. 118683
File 134696490991.png - (246.72KB , 750x720 , 282885_334867919922593_403332453_n.png )
118683
>>118681
Ion's reading? Sign me up!
>> No. 118753
File 134700262373.gif - (1.00MB , 314x195 , La2Sb.gif )
118753
>>118683
>Suddenly, second thoughts

>>118682
Looks decent. I think I can handle that.

>>118223
>Friday 22:00 UTC
I think I'll just be borrowing this...
>> No. 118769
>>118753
I'm busy Friday. Would Saturday be good?
>> No. 118770
>>118753
So, tonight or tomorrow?
>> No. 118771
>>118769
Works for me. Anyone have any objections to putting it off for a day?
>> No. 118872
Hey peeps, we doing this today? Just getting a headcount.
>> No. 118881
>>118872
sure
>> No. 118893
So how you join this thing?
>> No. 118895
File 134714493531.png - (122.46KB , 400x350 , Applejack131693212345.png )
118895
>>118893
Go in the #fic IRC and bug Roger to add you on Skype... that is when he wakes up.

I guess this isn't happening today.
>> No. 118904
I'm on now for anyone that wants to join.
[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts]


Delete post []
Password    
Report post
Reason