Discuss fanfiction, get writing advice, or get your story reviewed

Search /fic/ threads

Name  
Email  
Subject  
Message  
File     
Password  (for post and file deletion)

File 138118883936.png - (53.62KB , 250x223 , 100260_r.png )
128841 No. 128841
#Author #Shipping

So I'm writing this fic (http://www.fimfiction.net/story/100260/lunas-dawn) and shorty before writing it, I came across the headcannon known as Herd Theory. The way it's presented in the Leroverse and "Fireflies" is really interesting and cool and justifies the stallion-to-mare ratio in a compelling, complex way.

But it's kinda fetishy.

And I don't intend for my fic to be a clopfic.

So, in your opinion, is it -too fetishy- for a non-clopfic? Am I going to turn a lot of people off from the story if I include it?
Unspoiler all text  • Expand all images  • Reveal spoilers
>> No. 128842
File 138118971297.png - (353.58KB , 973x550 , Why.png )
128842
>>128841
>The hell is "Herd Theory?"

In all seriousness, I don't know what "Herd Theory" means, which is something that might add to the discussion of whether or not it is "too fetishy" for a fic premise.

So, blinded as to what "Herd Theory" is, I'll mention that it's possible to write a story about sex, with sex as the main premise, without being porn. Obviously, it's possible to write a story about sex with sex as the main premise that is porn (I believe that's the point of The Romance Reports); so the difference really lies in what you're showing / displaying to the reader.

Are you talking about a romantic evening together between Applejack and Rarity, where the two end up in bed together? That's a lot different from describing the way Rarity arches her back into the mattress as Applejack's tongue plunges deeper inside her.

So really, you can write about how ponies handle the drama around their sexual encounters, or whatever you want to do with "Herd Theory". As long as you don't include any explicit, graphic sex, you're probably not going to cross the threshold into "porn, erotica, and all the weird places in between".
>> No. 128844
File 138119020326.jpg - (17.58KB , 427x391 , trixie.jpg )
128844
What is Herd Theory?
>> No. 128846
Essentially:

Equestria is strongly matriarchal because mares vastly outnumber stallions.

Gender roles are reversed because mares vastly outnumber stallions.

Mares have a lot of inconvenient, protective instincts towards stallions because there are so few of them.

Basic social unit in Equestria is a "herd", a polygamous grouping of a handful of mares and usually 1-2 stallions.
>> No. 128848
File 138119070074.png - (48.87KB , 500x422 , tumblr_inline_mptvpw506Q1qz4rgp.png )
128848
Ask Star Sparkle is a tumblr blog that explores this pretty well.

http://askstarsparkle.tumblr.com/
>> No. 128849
File 138119282027.jpg - (34.04KB , 500x281 , aj-s1e15-small.jpg )
128849
>>128846

This does not seem fetishy. It's just like the system wild horses already have with reversed genders.
>> No. 128851
>>128849

... er, i mean it is the system wild horses have, with the same genders.
>> No. 128853
>>128846
Yeah, that's not really fetishy; that's just a story about polyamory.
[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts] [First 100 posts]


Delete post []
Password    
Report post
Reason