Front Page

Search /ooc/ threads
Name  
Email  
Subject  
Message  
File     
Password  (for post and file deletion)

File 133919818470.jpg - (245.36KB , 1488x1805 , HiRes Doomsayer.jpg )
194052 No. 194052
ITT: We post our OCs. We rate other OCs. We give helpful tips and pointers for the betterment of OCs that have fallen into the category 'below-average'. Be nice.

Old thread (Just in case you forgot something):
>>670897

I hope to see a lot of creativity from you, the brony community.

NOW GO!
Unspoiler all text  • Expand all images  • Reveal spoilers
>> No. 194053
File 133919839173.jpg - (102.05KB , 845x927 , I lost it_ It's gone_.jpg )
194053
Now that Doomsayer has graced this thread with his FUCKING ADORABLE face, this thread can now be properly cursed.
>> No. 194054
File 133920048013.png - (229.44KB , 3320x2600 , Mellowbrook.png )
194054
If I had a scanner and some colored pencils, I'd probably draw mine, or at least attempt to, but no scanner, so not much use.

Too much like Braeburn?
>> No. 194055
File 133920293063.png - (189.13KB , 900x1152 , 1331167931827.png )
194055
>>194054
Absolutely NOTHING like Braeburn.

Unless he's lyra.

Why does the fandom insist on making all of the male ponies in this fucking show lyra?
>> No. 194056
File 133920322220.gif - (243.19KB , 470x413 , Rave_CT.gif )
194056
Let's get this OC party started!
>> No. 194057
File 133920435296.gif - (277.48KB , 294x266 , 132321554957.gif )
194057
>>194056
I shall provide the music.

>>194055
Why does homoaerosol can always wordfilter to lyra?
THAT'S OFFENSIVE.

I WILL SUE YOUR BALLS TO THE WALL!
>> No. 194058
File 133920458098.png - (128.62KB , 409x401 , what was in that wiskey.png )
194058
>>194057
dose tripps
>> No. 194059
File 133920589682.png - (132.52KB , 671x1000 , 131379028054.png )
194059
I make no promises on being explicitly nice. I will not be vindictive, however, and give honest critique.
>> No. 194060
File 133920784956.png - (92.29KB , 800x530 , firebloom touch.png )
194060
OoooOoOohhh~ What's this? Can I touch it?

Here's everypony's favorite pyromantic pony OC, Firebloom. Not like anypony remembers him, I'm sure. I showed up in the early stages of that thread, stayed there for a while, and then I kinda got bored (it was actually more like my WT derped and then I forgot about it). Which was, like, six months ago, or something. Damn, that thread's old.
>> No. 194061
File 133920993347.jpg - (45.67KB , 176x213 , Herro, my eye is yerro.jpg )
194061
>>194059
That's 100% okay with me,
>> No. 194062
>>194057
I just got completely owned...
I just now saw the wordfilter...
>> No. 194063
File 133921005470.gif - (77.94KB , 802x900 , firebloom rave.gif )
194063
>>194056
>>194057
>> No. 194064
File 133921129492.png - (805.42KB , 3320x2600 , TirekandCherry.png )
194064
WHOO! NEW THREAD!

I'm ready to dish out all kinds of advice you don't even KNOW, man!
>> No. 194065
File 133921144091.jpg - (39.74KB , 554x567 , 485735_3932366274600_1443073526_3667244_1154066999_n.jpg )
194065
aw teah time for ocs
>> No. 194066
File 133921326844.png - (30.08KB , 296x372 , AA lores.png )
194066
this is Arcturus, i play him in the broniesaustralia forum RP
unicorn, CM for combat magic (preferred spells are fireball and magic missile).
He's a (disgraced) night guard, sent to ponyville for rehab after being court-marshalled for one too many cases of 'fireball first, ask questions later.'

the only pics i have of him are from pony creators... except this: http://i.imgur.com/wLB3R.png
(events from our RP).
>> No. 194067
File 133922022573.png - (97.21KB , 506x506 , Swag.png )
194067
For this new thread, I shall try to have a new picture for every post I make!

Like a boss.
>> No. 194068
File 133922075687.jpg - (46.14KB , 193x214 , dude that\'s fucked up.jpg )
194068
>>194067
I MIGHT do reaction pics for Doomsayer, too.


Dis gunna take a while.

Fuck the pony code, i have Photoshop!
>> No. 194069
File 133922235285.png - (24.60KB , 685x436 , Kalros, GriffonWings.png )
194069
Psssh, ponies are overrated :P

My oc Kalros the griffon
>> No. 194070
File 133922314343.jpg - (26.84KB , 400x533 , hariy-man-wearing-speedos-or-budgee.jpg )
194070
>>194069
I think i found Karlos humanized...
>> No. 194071
>>194070
Who da heck is Karlos? :P
>> No. 194072
File 133922590181.png - (141.74KB , 1090x675 , 131329360971.png )
194072
>>194068
I should get more reaction pics for Six...
>> No. 194073
File 133922684090.jpg - (197.22KB , 2000x1500 , iDino\'s color2.jpg )
194073
Is this where I put this thingy?

It's not the best. I wish I could improve it, but I don't have a tablet.
>> No. 194074
File 133922756723.png - (39.77KB , 531x684 , 5zDsV.png )
194074
me ponyfied "oc"
>> No. 194075
>>194073

I do believe you said that this was partly inspired by P&Sw/G, no? 'Tis a good show.

It's rather well done, if it's hand drawn. In fact, I 'd go as far as saying it would be well done if it WASN'T hand drawn. The red and white transition to black mane confuses me, though.

>>194074

His coat clashes with his mane, and not in a good way. His non coat-covered hoof clashes with his coat. His eye color doesn't really fit anywhere in there either. I'd work on your entire color scheme a bit more.
>> No. 194076
File 133922971415.jpg - (47.44KB , 194x223 , There we go.jpg )
194076
>>194072
Definitely.
>> No. 194077
File 133923008897.png - (131.78KB , 800x929 , firebloom kitteh.png )
194077
>>194072
Yep, I always liked that OC x3
>> No. 194078
what is an OC?
>> No. 194079
File 133924535869.jpg - (32.39KB , 636x414 , 533474_3932343314026_1443073526_3667236_609632984_n.jpg )
194079
>>194078
original character
>> No. 194080
>>194078
it's one of the main criteria of being a faqqot
>> No. 194081
File 133925565287.gif - (125.69KB , 500x519 , 132614654043.gif )
194081
>>194080
>> No. 194082
File 133925591644.png - (436.83KB , 1200x656 , firebloom req1.png )
194082
>>194080
Is that an Arabic word?

Don't worry, we don't think you're that just for not having an OC.
>> No. 194083
File 133925620101.png - (47.15KB , 945x945 , 132615090427.png )
194083
>>194082
well he is nothing more than an anon
>> No. 194084
File 133925966224.jpg - (9.44KB , 211x200 , 133913512021.jpg )
194084
>>194080
>>194083
Now it's two anons

meh. as long as you keep it in one thread that I can hide/ignore
>> No. 194085
File 133926012729.png - (76.39KB , 640x350 , 133048830730.png )
194085
>>194084
BUCK THE ANONS
>> No. 194086
File 133926145400.png - (144.85KB , 901x839 , happysix.png )
194086
>>194077
Yay
>> No. 194087
File 133926222451.png - (100.66KB , 800x800 , firebloom look up.png )
194087
>>194084
>one thread
>OCs all over the internet
Er... might have a problem.
>> No. 194088
File 133926328486.jpg - (35.44KB , 680x692 , 133499162933.jpg )
194088
>>194087
>might have a problem
>OCs all over the internet
>problem
>OCs
>> No. 194089
File 133926444683.png - (73.17KB , 466x517 , Classy CT.png )
194089
Anons hating on all OCs are like haters hating on all bronies.

All their reasons are stereotypical from the certain OCs/bronies that take things way too far and too serious, and end up being pushed on to the OCs/bronies who are just trying to have fun.

Learn which side we're on before you judge us.
>> No. 194090
File 133926471103.jpg - (11.67KB , 231x219 , 132721334760.jpg )
194090
>>194089
>> No. 194091
File 133926581107.png - (268.80KB , 905x1000 , gweat_and_powafull_twixie_by_stardustxiii-d4tr8zo.png )
194091
>>194089
This is bullshit, but it's not really nice that they do it.
>> No. 194092
File 133926747214.png - (917.96KB , 811x851 , treeponies or something.png )
194092
>>194089
>All their reasons are stereotypical
>all anons are the same
uh huh. guess that makes you a generic anon-hater
do I need a name before my opinion matters to you? or maybe even a pony-me?

and I DO like some OCs. its the hundreds of recolors, pony-creator-abominations and lets-put-my-face-on-something (>>194090 !) that annoy the hell outta me

>Learn which side we're on before you judge us.
you're on the OC-roleplay side or is that incorrect?
>> No. 194093
File 133926792603.gif - (2.53MB , 400x225 , 132121517245.gif )
194093
forget it
I'll leave you alone
enjoy your thread
>> No. 194094
File 133927337653.png - (102.78KB , 1074x846 , are you kidding me.png )
194094
Glad to see we're only a few posts in before the thread has fallen into arguing.

Someponies like OCs.
Some don't.
That's all fine.
Just don't be a dick about it.
>> No. 194095
File 133927353463.png - (54.04KB , 825x716 , CherryFace6.png )
194095
>>194094

Meh, retaliation only makes it worse. All of that could have been avoided if you had just, y'know, not cared.
>> No. 194096
>>194092
Might wanna read properly before accusing somepony of something.
He specifically said "anons hating on all OCs". He didn't say just "anons".

And by the way, the "let's-put-my-face-on-something"s aren't OCs. They are just what you named em. It's been done with both OCs and canon characters. The OC in question has nothing to do with it.

>>194094
>Some people don't like OCs
>They intentionally enter an OC thread
I just cannot see any hint of intelligence in somepony who does that.
>> No. 194097
File 133927375972.jpg - (35.86KB , 258x289 , Oh_____ my______.jpg )
194097
>>194094
It's the curse, man...

Did i not call it, or what?
>> No. 194098
File 133927419621.png - (795.37KB , 3000x3000 , such a six by nettles.png )
194098
>>194095
I neither started nor continued the argument. I merely stated an opinion.

>>194097
Curse of the OCs. I hear ya.
>> No. 194099
>>194098

I didn't mean to address that to you. I was furthering your point.

>>194096

Stop that! Now!
>> No. 194100
File 133927792568.png - (33.90KB , 550x400 , 131518520328.png )
194100
>>194094
It's funny to look on roleplayers sometimes, you know?
Taking people seriously, making oc's that just look bad, you know the type?

>>194095
Running away from problems isn't the way to do it neither.

>>194096
That's still bullshit, because most of bronies don't care/don't have an oc.
Get it straight first, bronies aren't only here, it's about 7-8 mln on tumblr, dA, and whole much more on the internet.

>>194099
Chiiiill
>> No. 194101
File 133928036460.png - (132.27KB , 800x842 , firebloom wut.png )
194101
>>194100
I said a lot of things in that post, and I'm not quite sure which are you replying to.

I know most bronies don't have an OC, I don't see the relevance in that. I know they aren't only here, might wanna refer to >>194087 where I sorta said that myself.
>> No. 194102
File 133928065404.png - (203.85KB , 1000x1000 , 131518802611.png )
194102
>>194101
I think I durrd while writing a response to your post somehow.
Nm
>> No. 194103
File 133929313425.png - (333.04KB , 680x765 , OC Pony Shrug.png )
194103
Aw, but I'm always up for a nice debate. Oh wellz, if you guys don't want "arguing", I won't respond anymore on the topic. Though I don't believe it's the right way to treat this situation...oh well, beliefs are like privates of the body, keep 'em to yourself unless somepony asks for them.

Now if you'll excuse me, I have more pictures to make.
>> No. 194104
File 133931881462.png - (101.62KB , 800x913 , firebloom mane on face3.png )
194104
>>194103
...
...
...
Can't help but feel it'd be really painful if I had that guy nod vigorously right in front of me xD
>> No. 194105
File 133936814381.png - (80.91KB , 640x510 , CT Blademane.png )
194105
>>194104 I can assure you he's quite fluffy.
>> No. 194106
File 133936865534.jpg - (20.85KB , 311x417 , Her OC.jpg )
194106
Just uploading my friend's OC as well. She made it just for fun, and I just only need it here for a reference on a different website, so criticisms will be ignored, good or bad. Just saiyan.
>> No. 194107
File 133936890105.png - (800.21KB , 2585x1923 , Six Mon scheming cutiemark by Archer.png )
194107
Just showing a new pic off.
>> No. 194108
File 133937166507.png - (34.37KB , 830x650 , myPony.png )
194108
Yea, ponymaker
I have zero artistic ability.
>> No. 194109
>>194108
Aw yeah. Command and Conquer pony. ♥
>> No. 194110
File 133937224243.png - (142.53KB , 1200x662 , firebloom wind.png )
194110
>>194107
He looks quite smaller than usual.
>> No. 194111
File 133937437559.png - (278.15KB , 2263x2666 , six mon flying by choco.png )
194111
>>194110

I had a Fluttershy base used for him, so his proportions are a little off.
>> No. 194112
File 133937481323.png - (177.37KB , 742x786 , randomdoodle143.png )
194112
This is Twilight Panda, and Twilight Panda as seen from backgroundponycreator.

She lives in the mspaintponies tumblr and hates her life.
>> No. 194113
File 133937601214.png - (1.17KB , 106x96 , PixelCherryFalls.png )
194113
I like pixel art.
>> No. 194114
File 133937978820.jpg - (35.66KB , 138x121 , YOU DIDNT.jpg )
194114
>>194112
Jesus Christ why that dude?
>> No. 194115
File 133938107754.jpg - (167.73KB , 841x1140 , 131131268579.jpg )
194115
>>194113

That's really cute. I wish I had pixel art talents... Then again, Six would probably be a royal pain with his wings and all.
>> No. 194116
File 133938118365.png - (158.82KB , 1084x1160 , 131572828514.png )
194116
Not my OC, but I did help design him.

He's a Necromorph-pony.
>> No. 194117
File 133938243009.png - (238.60KB , 500x372 , tumblr_m50o2rHPv01rxz1u8o1_500.png )
194117
This was not drawn by me, but this is my OC, Revelatia
>> No. 194118
File 133938259424.png - (28.05KB , 1500x1000 , blog_pony_by_braang-d4i2xra.png )
194118
>> No. 194119
File 133938261695.gif - (2.60KB , 106x96 , revelatia_desktop_pony__stand_left__by_cottoncandyyo-d4xoq0w.gif )
194119
>> No. 194120
File 133938264536.jpg - (96.48KB , 500x406 , tumblr_lyt18tvIrA1ql9uxxo1_500.jpg )
194120
>> No. 194121
File 133938268556.png - (259.46KB , 500x500 , tumblr_m1b0w9CjtA1r5l1lqo1_500.png )
194121
>> No. 194122
File 133938272031.png - (93.54KB , 500x250 , tumblr_m1iuwltCTz1ro9vc6o1_500.png )
194122
>> No. 194123
File 133938284257.jpg - (114.09KB , 500x500 , tumblr_m5430d6a3F1ql9uxxo1_500.jpg )
194123
>> No. 194124
File 133938290646.jpg - (23.66KB , 500x500 , tumblr_m545299RAb1r2tfbgo1_500.jpg )
194124
Actually, I should have said that none of these were made by me. :P
>> No. 194125
Here's mine. Do what ever you want with him.
His name is my alias near the title.
>> No. 194126
File 133938358161.png - (34.53KB , 830x650 , myPony.png )
194126
>>194125
Oops. Sorry. Here's the pic. Didn't mean for that to happen.
>> No. 194127
File 133938391623.gif - (19.43KB , 222x249 , CT-Claps-For-You.gif )
194127
Hooray for all the OC ponies!
>> No. 194128
File 133938413667.gif - (19.07KB , 222x249 , CT-Claps-For-You-FIXED.gif )
194128
Whoopsie daisy. Forgot you shouldn't save gifs in Photoshop with clear backgrounds. It leaves an overlapping effect.
>> No. 194129
File 133938641465.gif - (44.62KB , 400x400 , firebloom smile anim.gif )
194129
>>194119
AAHHHHHHHH PIXEL ANIMATION!! I love those x_x I've been wanting somepony to make one of Firebloom forever, but I just can't find somepony who does those and takes requests.

>>194124
Well, it's quite noticeable, what with all the different styles in each one and all xP

>pic
This is the only animation I ever did xD And also one of the first pony drawings.
>> No. 194130
File 133938690588.gif - (398.29KB , 368x369 , CT-Walk-Animation.gif )
194130
>841715 Out of animations, I've done three. The first being the little rave near the beginning of this thread, which only took like an hour or so. The third, the clapping one above just did today in about ten minutes. THIS ONE, with this post, took about two or three days to complete.
>> No. 194131
File 133938707113.png - (67.15KB , 510x536 , Sad CT.png )
194131
Man I just can't stop screwing up today when posting. I'm taking the rest of the day off.
>> No. 194132
File 133938734189.png - (61.21KB , 442x706 , tiniest six.png )
194132
>>194129
>>194130

I have no animation talent, but I desperately want some Six animations
>> No. 194133
File 133938801959.png - (141.68KB , 1500x617 , firebloom lens2.png )
194133
>>194130
Well, I also did this >>194063 if you consider that an animation xD I mean, it is technically an animation, but really just two pics in four frames with alternating backgrounds. Your "rave" one is actually a proper animation :P
>> No. 194134
File 133938831741.png - (118.03KB , 417x800 , 315.png )
194134
so many good ocs
this pleases Ticket
>> No. 194135
File 133939864472.png - (148.29KB , 727x900 , firebloom surprised.png )
194135
Woah! I was just googling something to find a drawing I saw before (Pinkie Pie and Loki xD) and suddenly I see a somewhat familiar looking OC. SO I go and check back here, and surely enough, I just randomly found this >>194118 picture in Google images, by searching "pinkie pie loki".

That just goes to show the the reaches of the fandom in the internet xD
>> No. 194136
File 133939918595.png - (329.11KB , 1465x1110 , oc#1.png )
194136
le working on my oc, cutie mark is a burning fish lol

im not that great/dont have the patience to vector so i was just sorta scribbling away

and pirate skullcap is what that is cuz ive never seen one in ponies and i wear one all the time (to keep my long flank hair outta my face)
>> No. 194137
File 133943349310.png - (229.45KB , 1200x1103 , firebloom mane on face.png )
194137
>>194136
>keep my long flank hair outta my face
I assume you don't want this to happen, then?
>> No. 194138
File 133946292080.png - (83.34KB , 600x465 , CT Is Depressed.png )
194138
>>194133
>compliments easy "Rave" animation that took an hour to make
>ignores difficult walking animation that took days to make

G-g-g-glad ya liked it...*sniffle*
>> No. 194139
File 133947446637.png - (6.64KB , 120x120 , Untitled.png )
194139
OC, Cutie Mark is a mouse.
Name: Silicon Mane
>> No. 194140
File 133947454485.png - (88.92KB , 800x878 , firebloom closeup.png )
194140
>>194138
Well, I was just comparing those two. Cause they're both simple and on the same theme. But there's no comparison with the walking one you did. That's just a different level :P
>> No. 194141
>>194139
Oh yay. A grey and black OC. That hasn't been done a million times.
>> No. 194142
File 133951434838.png - (32.50KB , 224x160 , 132755833053.png )
194142
Burningham. Dragon. Servant to some master in Canterlot/Ponychan.
>> No. 194144
File 133952743803.png - (61.21KB , 442x706 , tiniest six.png )
194144
>>194138

I like the walking animation...
>> No. 194145
File 133953205352.png - (64.31KB , 466x517 , OC Pony is happy.png )
194145
Would anypony be interested in hearing I now have a Tumblr? I made it to get me drawing even more, and I'll gladly follow back anypony interested. http://ask-ct-blademane.tumblr.com/

>>194144 Do you have/know how to use Photoshop? That's how I made mine.
>> No. 194146
>>194145
Ur work is a typical paint-noob work, don't tell me it's photoshop or gtfo
>> No. 194147
File 133953398666.gif - (3.73MB , 400x167 , trolls are coming.gif )
194147
>>194146
put up or shut up
>> No. 194148
File 133955379369.png - (1.52MB , 1600x1200 , fallout_equestria_Firestorm.png )
194148
The characters to my FO;E side-story.

From left to right:

Summer Winds, Snowbell and Firecracker Burst.

The first two are my OC's Firecracker is technically an official MLP character.
>> No. 194153
File 133955949789.png - (101.40KB , 624x441 , CT Doesn't Care About Your Post.png )
194153
>Pic related
>> No. 194154
File 133956303863.jpg - (14.23KB , 256x256 , 35290_256.jpg )
194154
Skyward. de lis cutie mark.
First oc
reduced image size, now i cant find the original so im stuck with mediocre image size.
Creativity also to a minimum but i like em'
>> No. 194157
File 133957236934.png - (72.70KB , 302x270 , 131518579047.png )
194157
Also, it's funny to see how in op there's a part about
>We give helpful tips and pointers for the betterment of OCs that have fallen into the category 'below-average'.
When 79% of OC's here are below-average.
>dead ponies are not okay
>recolors are not okay
>strange manes that look totally freaky like the supposted-to-be-blade are not okay
There are like 2-3 good oc's here, just sayin'
"Hurr durr what do you know about oc's"
I have one and am an artist.
You wanted criticism you got it.
>> No. 194158
File 133957245498.jpg - (20.91KB , 337x348 , 131518599672.jpg )
194158
>>194157
Also shitload of accessories doesn't help much.
Stick to one, max 2 if you count earrings
>> No. 194159
File 133957911430.png - (53.10KB , 378x409 , firebloom srs.png )
194159
>>194157
>Having an OC
>Being an artist
>Instantly having God-tier factual knowledge on OCs
Lolno.

It's true, there's some OCs that can be kinda annoying to the eye, clashing colors, weird shapes. But that doesn't make something "bad". Heck, nothing makes something bad. Bad is such a relative term it's stupid to apply it to anything.
Heck, go check the show. There's more and more weird-looking background and secondary characters appearing lately.

If you wanna give constructive criticism, it's cool, but saying "79% of OC's here are below-average" isn't really constructive, since it doesn't say a thing about how to improve.

Besides, you talk like somepony said all OCs in here are awesome or something. Most barely got any mention as to being good or bad.

I'm not trying to attack you or anything here, you're actually much nicer than a lot of others I had the disgrace to read x_x But being the case, I think you might actually want to help, so that's why I'm saying this.
>> No. 194160
File 133958048669.png - (112.47KB , 858x870 , Vanilla Vectored.png )
194160
I don't even do anything with her, I just like how she looks, and every now and then if somepony's looking for OCs to draw, I toss her up.
>> No. 194161
File 133958055127.png - (202.21KB , 607x834 , Vanilla Coloured.png )
194161
>>194160
>> No. 194162
File 133958272595.png - (122.01KB , 397x351 , Gibson.png )
194162
Here is my guitar playing mare OC, Gibson.

P.S. her mark is a guitar.
>> No. 194163
File 133958582135.png - (64.20KB , 439x398 , Eva (DuckeySquid).png )
194163
Well, why not?

Here's my OC Earth Pony, Desktop Evangelion (who mostly goes by 'Eva'.) She's from a future Equestria setting that's closer to modern society than the currently Equestria. She's a history student at university.

Her special talent is that she's amazing with computers and she's a complete tech nerd.
>> No. 194165
File 133959904717.png - (74.94KB , 649x732 , 131518160243.png )
194165
>>194159
You missed one thing, I spend like a year on /art/ and saw about 300 OC's.
Beat that.

>Isn't construscive criticsm
Well, what else besides telling you what's good and what's not eye-pleasing you want me to tell you?
Colors?
And yes, I see that you're being more less flankhurted because somepony might actually tell you that your character might suck.
>> No. 194166
File 133960453248.png - (8.84KB , 169x161 , Chaos Star.png )
194166
>>194157
>strange manes that look totally freaky like the supposted-to-be-blade are not okay

I hope you're not talking about my OC. What's wrong with a different style mane anyway? When most of the OCs here are made with that Pony Maker and many end up using the same style template, wouldn't creativity such as that be rewarded instead of being called not ok?
>> No. 194167
>>194165
dude, they're self-loving faqs. Don't expect them to be reasonable.
>> No. 194168
File 133960714966.png - (86.30KB , 291x292 , 131518157308.png )
194168
>>194166
To be honest I didn't saw any else mane-blade ponies, it just doesn't.... fit the style of this show.
That thing could work on tail if made correctly, not as it's mane.
It just looks....
Bad.

Of course it's creative, yes, that's not a too bad idea, just made the wrong way, it doesn't look really good.
>most OC's here
Well, actually I hate words like always, most, etc because you're assuming too much.
While I hate Pony creators with a passion, they could be an inspiration (if used correctly), also I think that the first one was made by that guy for two purposes: To learn action script AND to allow people to make their ponies, in this pattern.

>>194167
You're rude, everypony deserves respect, don't be like that
>> No. 194169
File 133960749049.png - (102.51KB , 359x343 , 131518230661.png )
194169
>>194168
nm the name change, I was screwing around with somepony
>> No. 194170
>>194168
Truth isn't nice and polite.
>> No. 194171
File 133960839387.png - (136.04KB , 622x900 , firebloom foal.png )
194171
>>194165
I don't need to "beat that", lol. It's not a contest. But even if I saw a million OCs I still wouldn't claim to have the absolute truth on em. Besides, you talk of /art/ like it had every OC in the internet. I saw plenty around other places that never saw Ponychan.

About constructive criticism... maybe try telling each particular one what the problems are? Cause it's hard to fix something if you don't know what the problem is, AND you don't even know if your particular OC is considered "bad".

On a side note, I'm not here for criticism. I already worked on my OC before, now it's what it is and I don't really care of somepony dislikes it. So well, this isn't personal or anything.
>> No. 194172
File 133960851210.jpg - (44.41KB , 304x380 , 172101.jpg )
194172
>>194157
>recolors are not okay

That about eliminates half of the so-called OCs on here.

Thank you for that, by the way, Few art-related things piss me off more than somepony coloring something differently and then claiming it as their own.
>> No. 194173
File 133960852065.png - (239.02KB , 755x795 , firebloom psycho.png )
194173
>>194170
Truth is relative.
>> No. 194174
File 133960915810.png - (67.53KB , 640x510 , CT Blademane LineArt.png )
194174
>>194168 I'm not sure that in a show where one pony's mane is able to deflate and inflate like a balloon, or become a trailing rainbow, anything can really be outside the status norm (if you can call it that.) Plus, they're not actually blades, it's just a look.

Thing is man, we're not all that different. I've been in the OC community for quite a few years now, I too know what it means to have a bad OC. I'm sure some others here know too, but not all. That's the point of our constructive criticism, to help them learn what's good and what's bad. If they don't want to learn, oh well, no use beating a dead horse (no pun intended...ok maybe a little.) But just, try to be more sincere about it, like not assuming we're going to attack at you for having an opinion.

At least you're being respectable about all this unlike some obviousparasprite.
>> No. 194175
File 133960998177.png - (88.92KB , 800x878 , firebloom closeup.png )
194175
>>194174
So... I was wondering... Sonic the Hedgehog influences? Cause even more than the mane, the tail looks like so.
>> No. 194176
File 133961044715.png - (116.35KB , 588x817 , CT OC Pony.png )
194176
>>194175
My first OC ever was a Sonic OC. And while getting into MLP: FIM, one day I just decided "Wonder how he would look at a pony?" Which is how I got this first drawing included with this post.

Of course, I got rid of the split hair in the tail. Now THAT looked too out of place. So now I just have the OC you see in the pictures today.
>> No. 194177
*AS a pony, dumb typo
>> No. 194178
File 133961127094.gif - (5.99KB , 158x130 , 131518645465.gif )
194178
>>194170
It isn't nice, it can be passed with gentle moves though, you're trying to make them angry.

>>194171
Yeah, that part was silly, sorry for that.
Also tumblr, dA, and OC list site which I can't remember.

If anypony will ask for it.

>>194172
That's annoying as fuck, I know the feeling.

>>194174
Your OC is classified something in between of 2/3 for 10 max as the best.
I've seen much better manes, if only I had examples.
It's just that it's the show style, it does allow some free space for your randomness, but you can't go too hard on it.
In your case it's the thing that your pony has a one-spot mane, it's too specified to have it only on front of his face, look around, none of the bg-mane-whatever ponies have that, it looks unusual.
Also, if you want to stick to the blademane so hard, I'd suggest making it a little smaller and actually making a part that'll hide the neck.
Also, colors, these are hard.
You can usually get a good effect with mono-colors, look for Mellowbloom OC for example (Google, she has a tumblr, orange pony), if the colors aren't picked too bad, of course.
Color wheels could help, but I never used em, I just like to go crazy myself.
>> No. 194179
File 133961247686.png - (201.06KB , 1200x764 , firebloom wind3.png )
194179
>>194176
Hah! I knew it! xP

>>194178
Personally, I find manes to be a pain. And actually, his looks more realistic than mine. Like, it's manes, after all, not human-like hair. And manes go to one side, just like his. In his case, he simply shaved the lower part of it, the one that goes all along the neck :P

Now MY mane is a pain. I like how it looks from the front and sides, but it's really hard to imagine how it'd be from the back. I'm really not a good artist, and lack that "3-dimentional eyesight" they do, where they just imagine something and can see it all around, with volume, etc. So basically when I created it, it was simply from the front/side.
Not to mention, even if I do come up with a way, it's still not really a mane, cause it falls all over, not just to one side.
But well, not like these are real ponies, anyways, and there are some weird "manecuts" in some canon characters here and there.
>> No. 194180
File 133961419443.png - (138.12KB , 687x695 , Picture of Little Colt CT.png )
194180
>>194178
>>194179
Actually, you can't argue whether it's supposed to be or not be mane like or human like, cause there's been instances of both. Sure the majority have manes styled like real manes, but some have had human like qualities (look up the Big Lebowski references.)

Also, I've used this style of hair for a long time. You don't know HOW long it took me to finally get it to look like that, to how I like it. It's become a little trademark image of mine, so there's no why I could outright change it. And as for the shortening of the front, extending the back, I just think it wouldn't look right. The shortening appears fine on a younger body, see pic, but to me not on the older body. And the short hair on the back, I could extend it a "little", but too much that it looks girly.
>> No. 194181
>no *WAY I could outright change it
>but *NOT too much that it looks girly

Man, I just cannot type right today. I'm taking a break.
>> No. 194182
>>194179
Manes from behind are easy if you can think in 3D. I already can, thank Celestia for that, if you want too, draw spheres.

>>194180
>Afraid of OC looking girly
>Pony
>Not girly
>Pony
wat
You can't make that work, it'll came out as the one in OP
>> No. 194183
File 133961877934.png - (55.50KB , 748x808 , 04-Face6.png )
194183
>>194124

>This one and all the others of that OC

Very nice. Just having one, single accessory is a very good example. Blue and pink go together well, and the coat complements the mane. Well done.

>>194126

Skunk mane? Not inherently bad, but the coat should match it. You have too many accessories.

>>194136

Good, original. Interesting way to draw it, but excellent nonetheless.

>>194139

Grey and black OC's can be pulled off well SOMETIMES, but you have to do something creative with them. The whole emo straight mane thing is overused. Quite frankly, if you're attached that mane style, you might as well pick a different color scheme.

>>194142

Dragons! Spike uses two colors in his entire design and you use a few more than that. If I could suggest one thing, it would be to lessen the amount of colors you're using.

>>194148

I do believe we had this discussion in the last thread.

>pic.
>name.

They both have good designs, but I'm afraid they may have too many accessories. I beg your pardon, but ponies don't normally wear clothes, and you're wearing full outfit-jumpsuits. I'm also not a fan of the torn ear thing, but that's your choice.

>>194154

No offense, but that's a really bad pose for me to judge your OC with. He has a neck goatee. *Ahem*

>>194160
>>194161

I like her very muchly. Not much else I can say. The general well done comments. Mane and coat complements, etc.

>>194162

Besides cutie marks, I don't think ponies can have tattoos. Cutie marks are part of the coat itself, so...
Earrings. Not a fan of that either. But it's limited to one accessory for the punk rock look or whatever. I never really got the point of that. The coat is a strange color of green to use with the mane, but it's not inherently bad. Just odd.

>>194163

Do I know you from somewhere? I think that the blue mane and blue coat theme is beginning to be overused, but it looks nice. I'd like to see a few more pictures though. What about her cutie mark? Could you explain that?

>done.

WA-BAM. All of the people who actually came to this thread for advice and good times, I'm sorry you had to be pushed aside by these little arguments popping up everywhere.
>> No. 194184
>>194183
Could you judge mine, too?
>>194054
>> No. 194185
>>194054

An interesting cutie mark, but the whole scheme seems too monochrome. A darker shade of brown for your mane, maybe?
>> No. 194186
File 133962199803.png - (100.66KB , 800x800 , firebloom look up.png )
194186
>>194185
I'm gonna have to disagree with that. Having little contrast isn't necessarily a bad thing. Yeah sure, if it's almost the same identical color it is, but it's not the case. And that's much better than having super bright and clashing colors already.
But I mean, heck, just look at the Braeburn picture right after that. It's barely any more contrast.

If anything, I'd say the cutie mark is a bit too complex (and a bit big, too). But meh, people tend to go even crazier in the cutie mark than the OC design in general. It's common to find things that wouldn't fit in the show.
>> No. 194187
File 133967703909.png - (39.49KB , 439x403 , 132147616269.png )
194187
>>194183
>I'm sorry you had to be pushed aside by these little arguments popping up everywhere.
Says the person with OC with snake eyes.
That's a paradox, eyes other than the normal ones are the worst ones.
>> No. 194188
>>194185
Yeah, I felt like I may have been a bit too safe with the colors, but I couldn't find anything else I liked without changing everything, do I decided to leave it. Simplicity is key, after all.
>>194186
Yeah, I noticed that the cutie mark was a bit big after I looked at it a couple times. Never got around to fixing it, though.

Thanks, you two!
>> No. 194189
File 133969929196.png - (49.43KB , 703x726 , 04-Face3.png )
194189
>>194187

The quote you took from my post and what you've said afterwards are completely irrelevant. Are you trying to spite me? Baiting me into an argument? Seriously? You make me sadface.

>>194188

I don't know how worthwhile my help is, but you are most certainly welcome anyway.
>> No. 194190
File 133970123762.png - (69.89KB , 232x284 , 131950962416.png )
194190
>>194183
thank you good sir, for doing what this thread is supposed to be doing lol

though i was thinking of adding a little bit to mine (>>194136 ) like some strands of hair hanging out the front or some random dyed in color in the mane

with the tattoo remark though id disagree - the cutie mark is in the coat right? well they can dye another part of their coat too if they want to, thus giving a tattoo-ish-ness
>> No. 194191
File 133970419116.png - (57.04KB , 493x402 , 132147541035.png )
194191
>>194189
Of course I do, I'm the fucking horrible person here, deal with it.
Stupid questions need stupid answers, seriously.
Stop trying to bitch about me now, I'm not the bad person here, you're trying to make me look like one.
I'm only sceptical and that's it.

Learn to read between the lines: "I don't think you can judge oc's really good because your oc is having something I call a "i can click buttonz" disease, which hits the creators of oc's sometimes when they soo too much buttons for generationg oc's and use strange things like weird eyes,dark blue skin colors (which are the most sucky ever, that's why you don't see them often, there was a plague of oc's that were that color)"
Easy enough for you to understand?
Don't try to tell me I'm rude, I'm just expecting a bit of actually on-topic conversation.
>> No. 194192
File 133970744360.jpg - (96.84KB , 373x418 , Star.jpg )
194192
Ugh, I don't think I should even bother at this point. I'll just let you all settle this out.
>> No. 194193
File 133970781412.png - (83.76KB , 456x541 , firebloom foal2.png )
194193
>>194192
You! Do you have DA or someplace else where I could contact you? Besides Tumblr cause I rather not go OOC in there xD
>> No. 194194
>>194193
I rarely go on deviantArt anymore, sorta, but here: http://c-tyler-prower.deviantart.com/
>> No. 194195
File 133970937953.gif - (364.89KB , 320x240 , tZOS8.gif )
194195
>>194191
hold up... im confused... why are you in this thread in the first place? cuz it seems like all you've done is qq about how bad other oc's are and pointlessly argue...
>> No. 194196
File 133971412862.png - (56.20KB , 694x782 , ArticNice.png )
194196
>>194191

Augh. I don't like doing this. I'll say this one more time: I don't like arguing.

>Of course I do, I'm the fucking horrible person here, deal with it.
>Stop trying to bitch about me now, I'm not the bad person here, you're trying to make me look like one.

>I'm only sceptical and that's it.
I don't know what you're trying to convey through this sentence. Skeptical, the word I believe you're trying to use, still doesn't fit in this context. I mean, sure, it's a coherent sentence, but it seems totally unrelated to everything else you've said.

>I don't think you can judge oc's really goodvery well because your oc is havinghas something I call a 'i can click buttonz' disease, which hits? the creators of oc's sometimes when they soosee too muchmany buttons for generating oc's and use strange things like weird eyes,dark blue skin colors
>(which are the most sucky ever, that's why you don't see them often, there was a plague of oc's that were that color)
>most sucky ever
>Don't try to tell me I'm rude...

>I'm just expecting a bit of actually on-topic conversation.

Original Post:

>...We give helpful tips and pointers for the betterment of OCs that have fallen into the category 'below-average'. Be nice.

You're a walking mass of contradictionsParaspriting isn't a very nice thing to do. I've given you a chance to be nice, but since you seem so opposed to it, I suppose this is the last thing I'll be giving to you. I hope you're having fun today.

*Ahem* Sorry Everypony. Where was I?

>>194190

>though i was thinking of adding a little bit to mine (>>194136 ) like some strands of hair hanging out the front or some random dyed in color in the mane

That could be cool, I'm looking forward to seeing any improvements you make.

>with the tattoo remark though id disagree - the cutie mark is in the coat right? well they can dye another part of their coat too if they want to, thus giving a tattoo-ish-ness

I suppose you're correct, although I still don't like the idea. To each his own, I guess.

>>194192

I'm sorry, my friend. I try not to argue so, honestly sincerely.
>> No. 194197
File 133971597941.png - (129.35KB , 1332x1787 , Jack.png )
194197
Name testing, and picture showing. Please stand by.
>> No. 194198
File 133971605296.png - (154.90KB , 3320x2600 , 01.png )
194198
I have 6 more.
>> No. 194199
File 133971609554.png - (159.36KB , 3320x2600 , 04.png )
194199
>> No. 194200
File 133971613002.png - (207.21KB , 3320x2600 , 02.png )
194200
>> No. 194201
File 133971619295.png - (247.21KB , 3320x2600 , 04.png )
194201
I don't think I really need to test this one, but I'll try it out anyway.
>> No. 194202
File 133971625976.png - (264.08KB , 3320x2600 , 05.png )
194202
I don't think I need to test this one either.
>> No. 194203
File 133971635045.png - (234.91KB , 3320x2600 , 06.png )
194203
Look, she even has a bow!

One more, then I'm done.
>> No. 194204
File 133971644352.png - (225.79KB , 3320x2600 , CherryFalls.png )
194204
There. All the full-body pictures, and I have names.
Sorry for taking up so much room.
>> No. 194205
File 133972107370.png - (10.70KB , 331x377 , 132244273318.png )
194205
Just posting this because yes.
>> No. 194206
File 133978144812.png - (179.39KB , 3320x2600 , hiResPony.png )
194206
Alright, this guy's Sound Mind. He's the initial villian in my fangame, which I should hopefully have some members on board in a week or two. He's got a backstory; mom died blah blah blah dad's corrupt and rich blah blah dad dies blah inherits wealth blah. He ends up finding a buch of magic in a cave and hires a drilling crew to get it out so he can help the world by absorbing the magic. Celestia tells him to not do that and he takes it personally. Elements of Harmony are too late to stop drilling crew. He ends up releasing the game's real villian, who tortures him until he learns his lesson, apologises to the Elements, and uses his funds to help the world for real. Feel free to punish my cliched mess of a filler villain.
>> No. 194207
File 133978180786.jpg - (8.47KB , 232x217 , GentleHoovy.jpg )
194207
Also, would one of you fine chaps mind explaining who this 'Ticket' lass is?
>> No. 194208
File 133978229139.jpg - (43.75KB , 800x600 , 150115_420809921283302_110563525641278_1285893_1970722756_n.jpg )
194208
>>194207
there is a thread for that
>>711613
>> No. 194209
>>194207
nothing more than a recolor
see >>194096
>the "let's-put-my-face-on-something"s aren't OCs. They are just what you named em.
>> No. 194210
File 133978456525.png - (360.46KB , 485x557 , 44.png )
194210
>>194195
>>194196

I only said that I don't like them, and few of them are okay, what not to do and what's good.
No, that's not helping.
Screw you.
>awdjnawldna rage
No, that's not raging, that's seeing how you try to be an idiot.
Also, that's called sarcasm, the thing I used I mean, because I am a sceptical person and I will clear this up for you because you are apparently too stupid to notice that.
Thank you, good bye.
>> No. 194211
File 133980264371.png - (63.23KB , 495x588 , firebloom mane on face2.png )
194211
>>194209
Nope. It actually has an original design. Unless you wanna argue it's similar to others, in which case I'll tell you 99.95% of the canon ponies are similar to each other. Identical body structure, etc.
Not to mention that's not anypony's face in there, nor is it a "ponysona". Just an "audio accident" from what I gather.

>>194210
Unintelligible post is unintelligible.

So, anypony wanna put this thread back on the rails? Anypony? Nopony? Yes? No?
...
Yes?
>> No. 194212
File 133980441210.jpg - (175.63KB , 550x479 , Comic 1 Part 3.jpg )
194212
>>194211 Nose booping, courtesy of CT Blademane.
>> No. 194213
File 133980450064.jpg - (124.31KB , 460x276 , Hurricane Ike.jpg )
194213
>>194211
>It actually has an original design
wow... you're serious, aren't you

>>711709
>>711823
>>711833
>>711843 (4/5)
>>711872
>>711894
>>712102
>>712125
>>715994
>>716600
>>716625
>>718042
>>720835
>>728015
>>730013
>>730428
>>736191
>>737239
>>737989
>>742972
>>743536
>>743735
>>744853
>>745897
>>745928
>>754751
>>756026
>>763463
>>764799
>>770700
>>774799
>>776482
>>781062
>>786104
>>794664
>>794810
>>803638
>>806059
>>806071
>>822601
>>823443
>>823632
>>825708
>>825927
>>826669
>>831910
>>837974
>>842847
>>844048
and that's only from the surviving pics because of the server-crash.
AND most of the others (that I didn't list here) are one of two copypaste-faces planted on a recolored body.

>Unless you wanna argue it's similar to others
it's similar to ~10 ponies from coloring them yellow
>> No. 194214
File 133981223001.png - (100.66KB , 800x800 , firebloom look up.png )
194214
>>194212
Yush, saw it in the Tumblr. Might as well take the opportunity to reply here. FQU3GYEFKQ3WEFD PINKIE PIE!!!ONEONE
Lol. The dialogue was perfect, btw. I could read it all in her voice xD

>>194213
Just because somepony takes a character and changes its colours to make it look like another character, doesn't mean that it's actually its real design. I could color Rarity with Pinkie Pie's color scheme, and that doesn't mean it'd be Pinkie Pie's real design.
Ticket has an original design. A bunch of people deciding to take other pics and color em yellow doesn't change that fact.
>> No. 194216
File 133983329850.jpg - (35.42KB , 720x342 , 540304_3936664422051_1443073526_3668735_531958113_n.jpg )
194216
>>194214
indeed Ticket does have an original design but art is hard to come by so we have editors
>> No. 194217
File 133985555238.png - (19.52KB , 566x564 , wut.png )
194217
>>194216
I have only seen 2 Ticket editors. Are there others?
>> No. 194218
File 133985591265.jpg - (32.39KB , 636x414 , 533474_3932343314026_1443073526_3667236_609632984_n.jpg )
194218
>>194217
i know of six editors and two artists(artist do not focus on ticket)
>> No. 194219
File 133986622881.png - (150.71KB , 720x800 , ZZALGO DRAGOON.png )
194219
Thou may suck upon my magnificent artist skills
>> No. 194220
File 133986693596.jpg - (68.61KB , 329x387 , 132669964262.jpg )
194220
>>194219
aw man
>> No. 194221
Just finished looking at all OC's in this thread.... I regret I didn't use my time on something more constructive instead, like scraping my skin with a melon baller.

I would give my POV on some design ideas that some ponies used, but apparently people here don't take kindly to constructive criticism (regardless if it was told in a nice or rude way).
>> No. 194222
File 133993656169.png - (59.96KB , 310x400 , 132657458094.png )
194222
>>194221
so what do you think could be done to improve some of these ocs
>> No. 194224
File 133994068990.jpg - (123.51KB , 304x437 , spoiler.jpg )
194224
>>194222
To ticket, nothing, her design is good overall and has come far from her spontaneous roots.

But most of these OC's remind me of the oh-so-many Sonic OC's that people made (And still make even today). Very, very few of them are designed well and the rest of them are just cries for attention with their exaggerated hair style or their totally unique body parts that are from another animal.

Take a look at Cteno, she is a weird as[b][/b] sh*t OC and freaks me out, but her design has actual work behind of it and it's not simply a randomized selection of parts. Also, the artistic skills behind her are noticeable, but then again, an actual artist is behind her design and not just somepony who relies on edits or a creator to make his/her OC. And by that I don't mean to imply that editing or using a pony creator is necessarily a bad thing, but if you're doing just that, and the only thing you can think of to make your OC "unique" is to put the most out of place body parts/eyes/hair style/whatever regardless if it goes with the general design of your OC or not, then you are just kidding yourself and making people go "ugh" in front of their screens by showing them your OC.

I'm very sorry for the image I've posted and spoilered, but this is a prime example of what I'm talking about, and I'll bet you the virginity of my first child that whoever created this Sonic OC has friends that tell him they simply LOOOVE his character and congratulate him on a job well done, while ignoring all outside criticism or missing the point of the criticism and labeling those outside critics as "parasprites". There's being nice for the sake of being nice, and there's being a dick for the sake of wanting to help somepony improve their work.

But yeah, take this with a bucket of salt, put your ego aside and ponder to yourself "Is there something wrong with my OC?".
>> No. 194226
File 133994163480.png - (129.43KB , 725x900 , firebloom wat.png )
194226
>>194221
>apparently people here don't take kindly to constructive criticism
Bashing =/= constructive criticism. If you really think people here don't take kindly to constructive criticism, maybe you should try to actually read the thread...

>>194224
>There's being nice for the sake of being nice, and there's being a dick for the sake of wanting to help somepony improve their work
And there's also being nice for the sake of wanting to help somepony improve their work. It's not that hard, really...

But I'll give you something, you do speak the truth when you talk about having an OC with a million random accessories and parts. And that pic is terrifying ಠ_ಠ
>> No. 194227
File 133994168823.png - (140.93KB , 400x400 , 9.png )
194227
>>194225
>Bashing =/= constructive criticism
Constructive Criticism =/= Bashing.
Learn how to take harsh words, then cry.
>> No. 194228
>>194226
One of the best people I can think of that bash the hell out of somepony when they criticize them is my man Simon Cowell, he may be harsh, he may be a dick, but he is like that because a lot of people are full of themselves and think they have talent. Out of all 3 of the original American Idol judges, he was the harshest but the most sincere.

It really is hard to be nice towards somepony work when they think that their work is of the highest quality.
>> No. 194229
File 133994492666.jpg - (27.18KB , 500x650 , tumblr_m4waj2oWVn1r7xc5po1_500.jpg )
194229
I look back and see the new people. and compare it to the old thread. God dam this SEEMS to have more angry people then the last thread per capita then the other, but it is still a new thread and i don't blame some people form bashing OC's but I honestly think that more people should look at the OP.
>> No. 194230
File 133994696312.jpg - (199.83KB , 830x650 , Heat Streak + BG.jpg )
194230
>> No. 194231
File 133994699432.jpg - (204.01KB , 830x650 , heat streak transformation 1 bg.jpg )
194231
>>194230
>> No. 194232
File 133994702144.jpg - (214.46KB , 830x650 , heat streak transformation 2 bg.jpg )
194232
>>194231
>> No. 194233
File 133994704408.jpg - (244.11KB , 830x650 , heat streak transformation 3 bg.jpg )
194233
>>194232
>> No. 194234
File 133994707479.jpg - (240.62KB , 830x650 , heat streak possessed bg.jpg )
194234
>>194233
His name is Heat Streak by the way.
>> No. 194235
>>194234
hmm. So that's his name huh? Demonic OC's can make some people think that he's a sue. Add a story-line behind it and some people will look at it another way.
>> No. 194236
File 133994792980.png - (184.15KB , 3320x2600 , hiResPony.png )
194236
>>194052
no name, no talent, what do?
>> No. 194237
>>194235
Actually he's just supposed to be a Ghost Rider hommage/parody. Pony Creator doesn't have skulls :'(
>> No. 194238
>>194237
oh so just a ponified ghost-rider. well that raisews some questions but still better then a spawn pony.
>> No. 194239
File 133995003700.png - (19.64KB , 258x292 , Sun_Shade_Avatar.png )
194239
Name: Sun Shade (r63 Star Shadow)
>> No. 194240
File 133996189491.png - (24.94KB , 450x400 , my little OC.png )
194240
name: sour grass
cutie-mark:ffffffffffffffffffffffffuuuuuuuuuuuuu rage guy
special tallent: rage
enjoys/loves: video games (yes they have video games in equestria, watch hearts and hooves day again), music, Rarity.
dislikes/hates: bananas (he relly does)
place he lives: Canterlot but got vacations house in ponyville.
>> No. 194241
>>194240
sorry for blank flank and bad english

):
>> No. 194242
File 133996225622.jpg - (192.21KB , 550x479 , Comic 1 Part 4.jpg )
194242
>>194228 You also have to remember that the reason Simon Cowell can do that is cause he's respected, widely known, and highly regarded. We're all strangers here, we don't know anypony, so we don't respect anypony til we get to know them, so the "I'm a harsh strict judge" act is going to get you nowhere.

Think of it this way. You're on the street waiting for a bus, and you're singing to yourself. The guy next to you says one out of two things: "Hey, that was pretty ok singing, you really hit the right keys here, but you missed a note at this and that part, keep trying though," or "You suck, you're singing is wrong, and you should stop." Which would you take seriously from somepony you don't know and take to heart as true words?

When you're rude or mean to a stranger, any respect or truth to your words you could had recieved will be gone in an instant. But if you have a friendly approach, you'll go much further. That's my take on this whole argument, and I'm done with it.
>> No. 194243
>>194242
you don't expect anypony to take u seriously with that faqqy canon/shi+fanon picture, rite?
RITE
>> No. 194244
File 133996313723.png - (46.03KB , 347x402 , firebloom scowl2.png )
194244
>>194227
So... you repeat what I just said, and then say something completely irrelevant. Seems legit.

Nopony's crying here. And, personally, I don't need to take any harsh words. Which, by the way, are also different from bashing. I didn't take any of it as directed to me. And even if I did, I'm confident enough to be completely oblivious to such words, which are only product of a weak (and ironically, insecure) mind.

If it's so hard to understand that there's no need to be a jerk to say anything, I guess I'll give up here. I just don't have enough patience to repeat myself over and over in a thousand different ways, just so I'll be understood.
>> No. 194245
File 133996320821.gif - (753.16KB , 200x86 , 2402758291_79f8d5045c_o.gif )
194245
this flankhurt is so glorious
>> No. 194246
File 133996346794.png - (47.15KB , 945x945 , 132615090427.png )
194246
>>194245
for once the anon is right
>> No. 194247
File 133996362332.png - (555.06KB , 800x3552 , 131294160716-awesome_oc_guide.png )
194247
I usually go by this pic to grade OCs
>> No. 194248
File 133996398446.png - (78.48KB , 500x519 , 132614325010.png )
194248
>>194247
this guy gets it
>> No. 194249
>>194246
>for once the anon is right
>for once
more anon-hate
Schadenfreude
>> No. 194250
File 133996409674.gif - (421.38KB , 470x413 , Made-it-just-for-you.gif )
194250
>>194243 I refer you to this picture: >>194153

Thank you for proving my point though. You come out as rude or mean, or even as aparasprite, no one's going to take you seriously, just like I'm not taking anything you say seriously because you're an obviousparasprite.

It has now been scientifically proven. I except my Nobel Prize in the mail by tomorrow.
>> No. 194251
File 133996424523.png - (369.61KB , 720x720 , M A C (411).png )
194251
>>194244
You people never get anything, do you

>>194245
It's not that, they're just being stupid on purpose sometimes, I belive
>> No. 194252
File 133996437475.png - (162.66KB , 800x662 , 132674277835.png )
194252
>>194249
oh anon
your flankhurt is showing
>> No. 194253
File 133996446642.gif - (19.07KB , 222x249 , CT-Claps-For-You-FIXED.gif )
194253
>>194247 THIS pic. Lol, it's amazing. I applaud you for posting it. Even though my OC has a fox tail appearance...

Oh well, at least I did take away the original twin-tails idea. Even if it was my Sonic OC ponified, it was for the better.
>> No. 194254
File 133996449256.png - (415.47KB , 720x720 , M A C (412).png )
194254
>>194250
And you, you don't get it either.
About 5 people here, me + this anon told you that something's wrong.
You still don't care.

And yet, anypony tries to put this "back on rails", strange because it never fell off of them, only you saying "I don't give a fuck" were spreading flankhurt.
Like the guy with that oc with lizard eyes, pure walking love machine, everything is amazing as always.

>>194252
And you, you're still trying too hard to be funny, like you did before I quit /ooc/
It doesn't work
>> No. 194255
File 133996485105.png - (157.11KB , 835x956 , 132236981612.png )
194255
>>194253
I recommend avoiding the foxtail and make it more "fox-like."
>> No. 194256
File 133996516327.jpg - (68.61KB , 329x387 , 132669964262.jpg )
194256
>>194254
my feels
you have hurt them
>> No. 194257
File 133996525316.png - (397.50KB , 720x720 , M A C (326).png )
194257
>>194256
Well, long time ago, you were first, so I don't really care now
>> No. 194258
File 133996532449.png - (29.17KB , 300x340 , 131398756408.png )
194258
Allow me to critque/grade them.

I will grade out of 5.
>5 Being Excellent.
>3 Being average.
>1 Being Unacceptable.

I will be using the pic from my post here >>194247
The Main points

>Simplicity
>Consistency
>Creativity

Let us begin shall we?

>>Disclaimer
I do not have an OC and I probably won't make one. I do draw though.
>> No. 194259
>>194254 Lol, seriously lighten up. I'm not shooting for making the perfect OC pony here. In fact that's the problem of trying to get the perfect OC, you either make it too good that it's Sue quality, or make it so bland that it's boring.

I haven't been asking for constructive criticism on my OC since the last thread. I'll listen to any given, but it's not going to make me instantly open up Photoshop and add the changes or make me rethink my life or anything. I'm happy with how my OC is now, so I'm likely to not change it anymore unless I make an older or younger version, or unless I want to change it, not because somepony said they didn't like it's mane or colors, or whatever, no matter how many say it.

So go ahead and tell me what's wrong with my OC if you still want to. I'll respect your opinion as long as it isn't hateful. But just don't expect me to take your words to heart and do as you say.
>> No. 194260
File 133996567197.png - (33.79KB , 210x220 , 5K002S3000942828FFC49D0200000FECCRM1837213000002P10000003D07090T107F3FCC004CB2.png )
194260
>>194257
i'm stupid
could explain what you said better
>> No. 194261
File 133996591099.jpg - (30.41KB , 500x416 , It Begins.jpg )
194261
>>194258
___

#1 >>194052
Score : 1
>Simplicity
Complex - Dividing Line
>Consistency
Multi-colored parts. Skeletal structure exposed.
>Creativity
Alicorn. Undead. Multiple Eye Colors. Too creative?

#2 >>194054

Score : 3
>Simplicity
Simple Color Scheme
>Consistency
Colors do not clash. Same throughout.
>Creativity
Resemblance to Braeburn.

#3 >>194059
Score : 3
>Simplicity
Coloration is perfect.
>Consistency
Different Eye variations. Distraction/Possible Sue characteristics.
>Creativity
Strange mechanical wing accessories detract from the OC. Not new. Wings do not appear to be able to provide uplift nor help fly. Therefore lumped into Unnecessary Accessories catagories.
>> No. 194262
File 133996600421.png - (495.81KB , 507x667 , 73.png )
194262
>>194259
I already told you that, about your OC, I won't repeat myself.
I'm not hating here, geez, chill.
I'm the funpolice.

>>194260
You remember a person with name "Lyra, the one in love with !BonBon" ?
That's me.
I still remember what you said to me when I told you that I don't like idea of Ticket.
If you don't remeber, well, it was something like "gtfo out of pic youpony, I was in millitary, you have no idea how war looks like".

Also, please, work on your grammar, you're hurting my eyes.
>> No. 194263
File 133996641828.png - (110.86KB , 1000x342 , Tumblr Header 2.png )
194263
>>194262 That last sentence was more to be focused on everypony out here, not just you sorry. Seems tricky to point out that you've stopped responding to just one person and you're now talking to everypony.


>Ignore the picture. Didn't want to make another post without a pic, and I just went with something I haven't used yet.
>> No. 194264
File 133996643508.png - (31.55KB , 281x280 , 132849535935.png )
194264
>>194262
i remember and i apologies for that
it was a bad day
...
like really bad
>> No. 194265
File 133996645371.png - (133.84KB , 932x993 , 179838 - applejack.png )
194265
>>194261
____

#4 >>194064
Score : 3
>Simplicity
Three Colors. Two is generally more acceptabled however they are used minimally so it doesn't penalize too much.
>Consistency
Similar throughout. Mane is slightly distracting due to the color clash. The eyes are werid.
>Creativity
An overall decent OC. The eyes along with the clashing mane took it from a 4 to a 3.

#5 >>194065
Score : 4
>Simplicity
Gold/Yellow Scheme. Flowing locks. Simple messy hair.
>Consistency
Fairly standard
>Creativity
The coloration between the gold and yellow is too similar therefore removing it from the 5 catagory.

#6 >>194066
Score : 4
>Simplicity
Simple Colors. Nothing too flashy except Cutie Mark.
>Consistency
Mane and tail match. No clashing colors in main body. Hair, eyes, and cutie mark are all different colors and distracts from the whole.
>Creativity
Average. Nothing too outlandish.
>> No. 194266
File 133996673199.png - (397.50KB , 720x720 , M A C (326).png )
194266
>>194265
#5 here is actually a relocor instead of being an actual oc.
Just sayin'
>> No. 194267
>>194266
incorrect
that is not a recolor
that is original ticket art
>> No. 194269
File 133996701766.png - (128.01KB , 438x422 , 131982776347.png )
194269
This has become quite sad. All the people that so claim to be giving "constructive criticism" haven't said a single specific point about any specific OC here. They just make general remarks about every OC in general. That barely helps. The ones who actually gave specific and helpful critique, never tried to glorify themselves over doing so, nor hate on anypony about not accepting it.

I can conclude this:

General guidelines to this thread
-Those who claim to give constructive criticism, don't.
-Those who do, don't make any special mention to it.

Meh.
>> No. 194270
File 133996706032.png - (104.41KB , 333x333 , 131803166913.png )
194270
>>194265

____

#7 >>194073
Score : 2
>Simplicity
Conflicting mane patterns/colorations/designs
>Consistency
Variance throughout the design
>Creativity
Earrings/stripes/markings/multi-colored sence hair. Sue qualities.

#8 >>194074
Score : 2
>Simplicity
5 colors.
>Consistency
Blue/Light Blue Hair/mane/tail. Gold body? Green Eyes? Purple hooves? too much clashing colors.
>Creativity
Standard OC. Very subpar. Work on coloration.

#9 >>194087 - >>194060 - >>194179
Score : 5
>Simplicity
2 Colors.
>Consistency
Mane and Tail are the same
>Creativity
Nothing outrageous. Nothing exotic. Simple. Pure.
>> No. 194271
File 133996728787.png - (8.84KB , 169x161 , Chaos Star.png )
194271
>>194268 Hey don't count yer chickens until they all hatched. We're only about 200 posts in about a, what, 2000 limit? This thread still has a long way to go til it's over and done, so let's not call it a failure just yet.
>> No. 194272
>>194268
>I wish the old thread would be back.
oh, right. the old thread where one of the last things were a literal "fuck you" for stating that it's on autosage. sure was a nice one

it's safe to say you have your little round-table discussion here, not letting anypony elses opinion count, that's simply pissing people off and it shows

>>194267
ticket is still 90% recolor of many many other ponies, making its appearance very inconsistent
>> No. 194273
File 133996751416.png - (141.77KB , 612x598 , good_morning__dear_by_humana58-d538ewg.png )
194273
>>194272
indeed truth in said statement
but Ticket has artists now
and they maintain the consistent look
>> No. 194274
>>194273
are you aware that you will never redeem from your parasprite-status with your recolor?
it's a spam-tool
>> No. 194275
File 133996775280.png - (16.77KB , 100x100 , 131801760329.png )
194275
>>194270

___

#10 >>194103 - >>194067 - >>194130

Score : 2
>Simplicity
Coloration is fine. 2 Colors. Tail/Tails are distracting. Not a pony tail. Violates rule "Parts from Other Animals". Tail could be made to look "fox-like" instead. Hair is outrageously complicated.
>Consistency
Except for tail, it is consistant throughout.
>Creativity
Uncreative. The tail is a rip-off from sonic. You can do better. Mane(scalp/head) to impractical and perhaps gravationally challenged - IE requires a copuous amount of gel to stick that way.

#11 >>194117 - >>194120 - >>194124
Score: 4
>Simplicity
Headband is not distracting.
>Consistency
Tail/Mane are similar colors. Nothing too clasing. I am indiffernt on coat color.
>Creativity
Reminds me of the G1 coloration sort of. The cutie mark does not belong and is the only thing preventing this from being a 5.
>> No. 194276
File 133996783352.png - (38.99KB , 313x347 , what is this ticket.png )
194276
>>194274
i assume you mean the ponibooru incident
and that will probably never be lived down
shame how oneparasprite can do that
>> No. 194277
File 133996798975.png - (136.07KB , 469x900 , firebloom lie.png )
194277
>>194271
Hah, yeah, that's why I got that out in the end. Seems somepony's actually giving useful feedback, for a change. Guess it might get better.

>>194272
Beats me. I wasn't there through the whole thing. But I was there for a good thousand-something posts, and those stupid enough to hate were quickly expelled. We had a very nice and constructive thread in general.
I don't think "one of the last things" is any proof as to what the whole thread really was.

And if I'm pissing off people who only come to hate and argue, then I couldn't care less. I know I'm not pissing off those who actually care about this thread being useful.
>> No. 194278
File 133996799516.png - (144.88KB , 929x860 , 132753337800.png )
194278
I will be back later.

I took my homework break to grade them.
>> No. 194279
File 133996800304.png - (9.66KB , 108x127 , 133996751416.png )
194279
>>194273
>Commission for Krager
did you really pay for that?

>>194276
>ponibooru incident
lol, no.
I'm talking about everywhere since the creation
>shame how oneparasprite can do that
...
you are the greatest parasprite of them all, you know
>> No. 194280
File 133996825998.png - (234.70KB , 797x1073 , 132669971648.png )
194280
>>194279
first, if you call the points system on deviant art paying

second, what do you mean everywhere? i only know of the ponibooru time
when was she spammed again?

third, i am aparasprite but i didn't want that for ticket
>> No. 194281
>>194279
bonus question why the zoom on star sparkler?
>> No. 194282
>>194277
>people who only come to hate and argue
some just come to piss others off
some actually come to give opinions and criticism, only to be ignored ("lol idgaf")
as far as I can tell these guys aren't very welcome.

>>194280
>first, if you call the points system on deviant art paying
see? again. I can't even ask a question without getting this kind of tone. okay MAYBE I could've rephrased that to "how much did you pay?" but shit I didn't think of it this way, geez.
>when was she spammed again?
/ooc/
and you know that
you're still not missing a chance to post a recolor in a relevant thread
>third, i am aparasprite
and have pictures to go with it. now you remind me of jack
too bad you're not ban-on-sight yet
>>194281
the horn
>> No. 194283
File 133996866226.jpg - (5.87KB , 244x206 , 133675706040.jpg )
194283
>>194275

>>194278

____

#12 >>194160 - >>194161

Score : 5
>Simplicity
Simple Colors. Nothing clashes.
>Consistency
Mane and tail are similar.
>Creativity
Plain. Simple. Pure. Well done.

_______________________________________

SCORE : 1

The following OC's need to review >>194247 the picture seen in this post.

They contain the following;
>Clashing Colors
>Distracting Patterns/Accessories
>Sue Qualities
>Uncreative/Copy

Do not take this personally. I hope you may read and review this and create that super awesome OC for the future.

>>194106
>>194108
>>194126
>>194136
>>194116
>>194139
>>194162
>>194279
>>194236
>>194233
>>194232
>>194217
>>194183
>>194202
>>194199
>>194163
>> No. 194284
>>194275 Know ya got homework to do, so when ya come back, I have a question.

How exactly can you make a tail "fox-like" without it being a fox tail? If you can tell/show me how to do so, that might be worth looking into for my OC.

>tail is a rip-off from sonic
I'm sorry, but I lol everytime I see a comment like this, because this OC pony, was just original a Sonic OC ponified. That's why the original design had two tails, and why the tail and mane are like that.

>Hair is outrageously complicated.
I get a loooooot of comments about the mane, lol. I see it more as a hook than anything, it draws attention, which is funny to see how people react with "whoa, how the heck does he have hair like that?" (The answer is magic *snort snort*)
>> No. 194285
File 133996881473.png - (294.43KB , 744x778 , problemtheresugarcube.png )
194285
If you feel your OC was reviewed inaccurately please let me know. I can give you my thought process for each.

>Pic Related
>MINE COUNTENANCE WHEREUPON
><3
>> No. 194286
File 133996891688.png - (97.49KB , 402x400 , 132729272225.png )
194286
>>194282
first whoa there ponyta i meant nothing by it

second one pic hardly warrents spamming and /ooc/ is mine and ticket's board of origin

third who is jack?
>> No. 194287
File 133996906893.png - (137.20KB , 800x945 , firebloom kitteh5.png )
194287
>>194283
Just thought I'd say this. Thanks for doing what you just did. I think you might have just saved this thread.
Also, it's you seem to have very similar ideas to mine, with regards to OC grading :P There's a few here or there I'd give a point more or a point less, but in general, quite similar.
>> No. 194288
File 133996921296.png - (335.37KB , 789x837 , 179794 - applejack artist firepainter65.png )
194288
>>194284
>I'm sorry, but I lol everytime I see a comment like this, because this OC pony, was just original a Sonic OC ponified. That's why the original design had two tails, and why the tail and mane are like that.

You may need to move on with the design then.

>(The answer is magic *snort snort*)
This is within the realms of backstory. The hair in some of the pictures was larger than your head. Almost double at times. I had the strange impression that it resembled banannas or blades.

>How exactly can you make a tail "fox-like" without it being a fox tail? If you can tell/show me how to do so, that might be worth looking into for my OC.

This is hard because you can easily violate the rules seen in >>194247.

I would suggest making it a normal pony tail with a stained blotch of white or a single band of white. Perhaps a band similar to AJ's at the end?
>> No. 194289
File 133996947947.jpg - (75.86KB , 400x458 , Jack_Spicer[1].jpg )
194289
>>194286
of course you didn't...

I know all about ticket and where it came from, I assure you. but if you want to post in-character-recolor this just isn't the place... no matter where it came from
imagine everypony'd do it in every related thread, we'd suffer OC-recolor-spam like nothing else.

and here I thought you're around long enough to know him
pic is jack
>> No. 194290
>>194286
She doesn't have a board, you came up with her on a stream. Ergo /ooc/ doesn't have anything to do with her, only you, people on stream. If you don't agree, think again.
>> No. 194291
File 133996951562.jpg - (33.58KB , 500x486 , 181031 - applejack.jpg )
194291
>>194287

No problems!

I saw this thread on /all/ and decided to investigate.
>> No. 194292
File 133996961711.png - (427.41KB , 749x584 , whatsgoingonhere.png )
194292
>>194291

I read the entire thread and I still don't know what these posters are arguing about haha.
>> No. 194293
>>194292
oc-ponys not taking criticism is one thing (I think) and if bladehair takes your advice... >>194259
>I haven't been asking for constructive criticism on my OC since the last thread. I'll listen to any given, but it's not going to make me instantly open up Photoshop and add the changes or make me rethink my life or anything. I'm happy with how my OC is now, so I'm likely to not change it anymore unless I make an older or younger version, or unless I want to change it, not because somepony said they didn't like it's mane or colors, or whatever, no matter how many say it.

contradiction
>> No. 194294
File 133997002012.png - (97.21KB , 506x506 , Swag.png )
194294
>>194288
>I had the strange impression that it resembled banannas or blades
That's actually how people helped me come up with a name. One person saw my OC and suggested the name "Blademane." I loved it, and made it the last name.

>normal pony tail with a stained blotch of white or a single band of white. Perhaps a band similar to AJ's at the end?
Maybe the stained blotch idea. I'll try it out and see how it looks.

And you know, through your grading of my OC, I'm surprised the cutie mark didn't throw up a red flag for you.
>> No. 194295
File 133997014531.png - (297.92KB , 470x471 , hmmm.png )
194295
>>194293

Well...advice is simply that.

You don't have to listen to it.

No sense gettin' worked up about it.

But I see where you are coming from.
>> No. 194296
>>194295
it's a whole "we are right, everypony against us is wrong" kind of situation.
example - I'm ignored by both ran and bladehair >>194282
>only to be ignored
'my views and opinions do not matter because I'm not praising their creation' <- this is how it looks like guys, seriously
>> No. 194297
File 133997032141.png - (273.18KB , 286x325 , 131994469627.png )
194297
>>194294

The Cutie Mark is complicated. Cutie Marks should not be that complicated. Try for one with less spikey projections?

I do not know what it represents. I can't even guess to its purpose. Remember to keep it simple.
>> No. 194298
>>194296
>how it is
fix'd
>> No. 194299
File 133997046812.png - (459.85KB , 3087x3797 , imallears.png )
194299
>>194296

People are defensive of their creations.

It happens.

Just be calm, rational, and persuasive.

It is sometimes taken the wrong way as an attack on the person when it is simply a critque of their art.
>> No. 194300
>>194293
>I'll listen to any "real criticism" given
>not because somepony said they didn't like it's mane or colors, or whatever, no matter how many say it.

Here's the difference. This guy didn't just say "the tail is wrong," and that's all folks. He's offering to way to change it, while still keeping it as close to the original design as possible, aka, HELPING.

And this doesn't mean I'm just going to make the tail with a white blotch, instantly add it on and call it done. I'm going to try it a few ways, see if I can get it to a way I like. If I can't, like I said, I'm not going to change it if I don't want to.
>> No. 194301
>>194299
>People are defensive of their creations.
I can understand that
>It happens.
all the time
>Just be calm, rational, and persuasive.
trying
>>194300
"somthing bugging me about this and that, but can't put my finger on it. maybe you wanny try something else"
maybe you had that before.
just because somepony can't give you a better example (or maybe doesn't want to, who knows) doesn't mean he doesn't want to HELP
>> No. 194302
File 133997123652.png - (159.08KB , 853x823 , cgbdfg2.png )
194302
I'd love some critique, I'm terrible at OCs
No name yet, suggestions?
>> No. 194303
File 133997126783.jpg - (96.84KB , 373x418 , Star.jpg )
194303
>>194296 I'd suggest maybe at least making up a name for yourself to use here

It's kinda hard to take anons seriously and not as parasprites when there's been some that start calling us "self loving faqs" as one put it. It might not had been you, but who knows, no one can really tell except for you.

Plus, you gotta be like this guy: >>194299 You can't just point out the flaws and that's it. Give tips, pointers, options, something to help out. And you gotta realize your critiques will be heard, but not always listened to. Just because we're not changing our OCs in accordance to your critique, doesn't mean we're ignoring it.
>> No. 194304
File 133997147743.png - (368.53KB , 720x720 , 132243023687.png )
194304
#13 >>194302

Score : 4
>Simplicity
Simple Colors. Nothing clashes. Flows well. Eyes do stand out.
>Consistency
Mane and tail are similar color and pattern
>Creativity
Eyes and Cutie Mark match. Interesting factor. Nothing too clashing or standing out. I would go as far as to say it is "girly" but that would be an opinion of mine and not an objective fact.
>> No. 194305
>>194303
>name
>hard to take anons seriously and not as parasprites
>you gotta be like this guy
lol

>You can't just point out the flaws and that's it
I did that earlier with some art and everything was fine between the two of us, while I still didn't have an idea how to improve it.
I just said something like "it kinda rubs me the wrong way, not sure what", it went on like "maybe it's this and that" "yea could be, work on that"
it was fine and done.
>doesn't mean we're ignoring it.
basically all I'm seeing is "anons be paraspritin' gtfo"-stuff, and nameponys who are unable to give the perfect review like Amar are looked down upon (You can't just point out the flaws and that's it) - of course they are going to leave the thread with a sour note regarding OCs

lolwhatamiwriting
>> No. 194306
File 133998289867.png - (131.78KB , 800x929 , firebloom kitteh.png )
194306
>>194296
No. I don't feel anypony's against me. Like I said before, I'm only standing up for those who get bashed on. I don't see this whole business as any kind of personal thing.

No. I didn't ignore you. There was simply nothing to say. You simply stated facts you believe true. Some just come to piss others off? Okay, that's nice. I dunno, really, not like I have an internet mind reader to know what others are really thinking.
Some are ignored? I dunno, give an example, maybe? Can you even know if somepony's ignored, half of the time? If somepony gives critique, he might not get an answer, but the one who it was intended for might actually see and use it.
These guys aren't very welcome? Which guys? Why would you say they aren't welcome? This part just didn't make any sense to me without further explanation.

I just didn't feel like writing a bunch of pointless stuff. Cause it's pretty obvious I'm not gonna change your mind. So why even bother? Think what you may.

And by the way, for about a fifth time since I'm in this thread, I'm not actually looking for critique on my own OC. You obviously didn't read any of the many other times where I said so, cause otherwise you wouldn't be saying I want praise.

Well, I think that's explained thoroughly enough. Now then.

>>194302
Might as well start doing what I came here to do. I'm not gonna do like Amar and analyze every aspect of it, cause honestly, if something is okay, then it probably won't be changed xD So I'm just gonna say what, to my view, could be improved.

In this case, I'd say the mane colors might be a bit too bright. It could end up being annoying to the eye. Just a little, but well, it's a pretty nice OC all around, don't have much to criticize :P

As for the name, it should also be about personality/talents rather than just her looks, so... you have any of those already planned?
>> No. 194307
File 133998356682.png - (48.61KB , 1000x1000 , Filly Hero1.png )
194307
and now...... Hero Borealis... as a filly.
>> No. 194309
File 133998588691.png - (52.82KB , 694x782 , 04-Face4.png )
194309
>>194254

COME BACK HERE, MAN. I LOOOOOVE YOU. ACCEPT THE LOVE, MAN.

>>194283

I'm very glad you gave those three low scores.
>> No. 194310
File 133998679645.png - (68.10KB , 846x781 , 02-Face6.png )
194310
New name. Whatcha' think, guys?

I think I missed a few OC's during the arguing, so sorry if I don't get to you.

>>194302
Mane isn't too shabby. It's hand-drawn. However, the green clashes with the cream coat. Eyes and cutie mark are fine, and are the same color! Everypony loves pink, right?

>>194307

Good, hand-drawn. Is that a cross tattoo above his eye? Tattoo's aren't that great, no matter if they're viable in the pony world or not.The speckled mane isn't that great either. If you want mane variation, try stripes, or maybe even swirls. White and black color combinations are a bit overused, unfortunately. I'd recommend you pick a new color scheme, unless you're absolutely attached to it.
>> No. 194311
File 133998731423.png - (307.98KB , 746x1035 , Hero is surprised.png )
194311
>>194310
Actually! That's a scar not a tattoo. he just has less of them when he's young. And those are stars. (see picture)
>> No. 194312
>>194311

Stars, eh? Yeah, that's not a normal trait. It's just about as bad as Mr. CT Blademane's mane. I mean, it's not that it's bad. It's just that people aren't going to generally like it. :/

Also, scars, you say? I think you may be suffering from the same disease Smith has. Do you two need to go to a meeting?
>> No. 194313
File 133998828679.png - (38.04KB , 640x480 , Giz base.png )
194313
>>194312
I dunno, a lot of people seem to like it so far. He's a story based character anyway. My normal OC is Gizmo Gearthrottle. I've posted him before.
>> No. 194314
File 133998870119.jpg - (537.57KB , 3507x2480 , oh hai there by silver dust.jpg )
194314
>>194261

The more feedback I can get on Six the better. Everypony is free to critique him. I will provide no backstory on him, as I want his design to solely be under consideration, not his history.
>> No. 194315
File 133999042053.gif - (243.19KB , 470x413 , Rave_CT.gif )
194315
>>194312 Is it wierd that the only people that have said they didn't like the mane were just the few here, while some others here and a lot more elsewhere have shown no disapprovement or the opposite to it?
>> No. 194316
File 133999115620.png - (95.77KB , 885x800 , firebloom wind2.png )
194316
>>194307
>>194311
I'm not sure... I think the mane could work either getting rid of all the "texture" or the complex shape. Both together are kinda too much. Same for the tail, but I think even without the white parts it'd still be too much for a tail. It just looks weird like that. Some saw-like shape seems more acceptable in a mane than a tail, I guess.

>>194313
I see one and potentially two problems with that one. The mane/tail outline. It just jumps straight to the eye when an outline is lighter color than the filling, unless the filling is an extremely dark color, and even so, it somewhat does. And also it *might* have too little contrast between body and mane, but that could be just seem so because of the light outline of the mane.

>>194314
Well, it's hard for me cause you're kinda a special case. He has a lot of weird stuff, but that OC has so much story, it can be considered original. Some sort of precursor to most OCs now with weird wings xD And to whoever said how those wings weren't logical for flying, think again. Canon pegasi wings are way too small as is, not to mention we're talking about a universe with talking ponies and magic.

Although the eyes... those do bug me. I mean, first weird thing you notice is a black eye. Okay, that could be worked with. But the "shines" don't look like shines at all. And the big white oval, is it supposed to be the iris? The pupil? Another shine? It gets really confusing.
And also the other one. White iris? That's also really confusing. If you add an outline, it looks weird. if you don't, it looks like he doesn't have an iris. Or that the black part is actually the iris. Or the iris and the pupil together. I dunno. Like I said, it's confusing.

But anyways, I doubt you're gonna change him at this point, eh? :P
>> No. 194317
File 133999139898.png - (66.66KB , 900x609 , Mirage.png )
194317
>>194316
I don't care too much. I like being excessive. And I'm rather unsatisfied with how I made gizmo. I've been thinking about remaking him anyway.

Well this is Mirage.
>> No. 194318
File 133999173900.png - (121.74KB , 662x900 , firebloom sit.png )
194318
>>194315
Well, I never criticized it because I mainly talk about things that plain look bad. I don't go looking for things that would fit or not in the show. Cause really, do we know? They are always adding new things in new episodes. For all we know, anything with their art style could fit if they use it themselves.

That is to say, it doesn't really look like belonging in the show, but it doesn't look bad, to me. If anything, I'd try simplifying it a bit. The part where all the "saws" start is too cluttered with lines. And the pointy curve they take, also in that part, doesn't help with that.

>>194317
Welp, it's all up to you, take what you want.

That one looks better. The yellow is too bright, specially the outline one. Maybe only that one, can't really be sure. Colors have that annoying thing where they affect and are affected by all the other colors surrounding em, lol. And the green fits nicely with the yellow, but not too much with the pink...
The cutie mark is pretty cool :P
>> No. 194319
File 133999210687.png - (168.87KB , 417x306 , Ponified John.png )
194319
>>194318
Thanks. I need to make more of her but I never seem to get around to it. The cutie mark is a custom design of my own.

This one isn't really my OC, so much as a ponified me.
>> No. 194320
File 133999495458.png - (47.17KB , 830x650 , myPony.png )
194320
>>194304
you seemed to have missed somepony in the near begining
>> No. 194321
File 133999509371.png - (90.63KB , 480x600 , firebloom oh you.png )
194321
>>194320
This'll be fun, lol.
>> No. 194322
File 133999516825.jpg - (27.18KB , 500x650 , tumblr_m4waj2oWVn1r7xc5po1_500.jpg )
194322
>>194321
most likely.
>editing pics in the meanwhile.
>> No. 194323
File 133999552228.png - (278.15KB , 2263x2666 , six mon flying by choco.png )
194323
>>194316
His eyes are sort of a special signature that I use with personal characters. The black and white heterochromia has been a personal flair I've put on my 'netsona' for years.

The black eye has a black iris/sclera with a white pupil. The other eye has a white iris/sclera with a black pupil. Sue ish? Maybe, it's just a personal design signature I've used.
>> No. 194324
File 133999574081.png - (121.74KB , 662x900 , firebloom sit.png )
194324
>>194323
Well, I'm not saying it's bad. Just... impossible to figure out without an explanation. Maybe it works better with other art styles, iono. But the FiM-style shines, and the fact that the rest of the eye is also white... How do you normally tell the iris apart from everything else without an outline?
>> No. 194325
File 133999623814.png - (141.74KB , 1090x675 , 131329360971.png )
194325
>>194324

There normally is an outline for the white eye, the black one is just.. black. It's a little weirdy-creepy, but I think I kind of like it that way.

But thank you so much for the feedback :3
>> No. 194326
File 133999741008.png - (141.83KB , 749x900 , firebloom kitteh2.png )
194326
>>194325
No prob. I don't really find most things creepy, anyways xD I actually like the idea, just that it's hard to execute, I guess. Well, now that I know the black one is pure black, it looks okay, all the white was just shine, then. But the white iris still seems hard to pull off. The outline just makes it look all weird. Maybe with a really really thin outline...

Oh, and the Mary Sue part, I honestly don't think so. People seem to forget what that really means. Being out of the ordinary isn't really a Mary Sue trait. It's just about a character being excessively good/lucky or excessively bad/unlucky at everything, or being too powerful/helpless, in a more combat-oriented context. Looks could factor in that, if you're talking about being super attractive/horrible. But that's really not the point, in your case.
>> No. 194327
File 134002250189.jpg - (116.08KB , 800x695 , 133658302893.jpg )
194327
>>194309
I couldn't care less about your love.
I do care about people I like and respect though.
>> No. 194328
File 134002831408.jpg - (45.01KB , 195x230 , I C___.jpg )
194328
>>194261
Wait, now it's a crime to be too creative?

Not like you'll take the time to read the backstory anyway, so...
>> No. 194329
>>194328
Scratch the backstory part. It's mainly to rid the hellspawn of Sue-like qualities.

To be frank, I did a damn good job making him look like one.
>> No. 194330
Also, /ooc/ is dead.

>>194328
>>194329
>>194330
See?
Chain posts.
>> No. 194331
File 134003659546.png - (128.85KB , 856x835 , purplehair.png )
194331
>>194310
>>194306
>>194304
Thank you all! I think you're right about the mane being too bright/clashy. Bright and crazy doesn't really fit her personality anyway. Is this any better?
As for talents, I was leaning towards having her be a dog trainer or something along those lines. (Kind of a silly idea, as we've only seen one dog in the show, but...)
>> No. 194332
File 134003773171.png - (223.29KB , 311x406 , 162.png )
194332
>>194328
Actually, dead alicorn ponies made in pony creators isn't called creativity.
It's called boredom.

>>194330
Then why do you come here, /ooc/ is always running the same speed, not like /rp/, /gala/, /chat/, or anything.
It's not a fast board.
It's just the way it is.
>> No. 194333
>>194327

You're the one who called me a love machine.

EMBRACE MY LOVE.

>>194331

I like it much better. Purple goes with pink, and doesn't clash with the coat. As for talents, I don't think training would be something to consider. Animals are kind of iffy in the show. Fluttershy takes care of otters, but feeds them fish. Applejack keeps cows on the farm, but they're apparently intelligent to the same level as ponies. It's all odd. Not to say that training is a bad thing, just that compared with the show, it's good to be vague when you're using talents that involve animals.
>> No. 194334
File 134004071379.png - (363.55KB , 720x720 , M A C (345).png )
194334
>>194333
You /rp/ people take everything this seriously?
Also, if you could actually think for one second, I meant that as you're all /rp/ ponies making a circle of love here, if you want a discussion about which oc is/isn't good, and don't care about what other say to you or if it doesn't fit your needs you discard it, just go back to /rp/ or /ooc/ and have this discussion there.
>> No. 194335
File 134004073937.png - (95.77KB , 885x800 , firebloom wind2.png )
194335
>>194331
MUCH better. I'd say it's just perfect like that.

>>194332
Yes, cause we all know all other OCs were made by extremely busy persons who put all their duties aside just to create their character. Obviously bored people can't draw and only make em in the creator. Surely they only do alicorns, and more than evidently they always make em dead.
Or maybe he just had some crazy ideas and decided to go with that.

Considering not those legs nor those mane spikes are in the creator to begin with, it had some thought process to it, it wasn't just going through the preset options and choosing. Thus, creativity.
>> No. 194336
File 134004119668.png - (362.93KB , 720x720 , M A C (419).png )
194336
>>194335
Let me say that for like 9001th time, if you don't care about others opinion about your pony, go to place where everypony will love you like that lizardpony did.
Everything is awesome, everypony is great, just few minor fixes and you can rule the world.

I never said it have to be hand drawn (btw, most of hand drawn oc's suck as bad as the creator ones), I'm just saying that even with creating a "bad" character (as the personality in this case, which I belive is bad for this example), you can make the character look fucking amazing.
Or he can't, or he simple didn't for some reason.

While pony creator is an awesome thing, a lot of things there were added because the guy making it wanted to learn. Get it?
Learning how to make flash apps isn't easy from what I've heard, and making everything yourself is a great learning experience.
He probably added them to try out how to scale layers acording to the body.

Thus boredom.
I can write shittons of text easily.
>> No. 194337
>>194334
they won't and they don't want to understand that
>> No. 194338
File 134004154969.png - (51.66KB , 808x720 , CherryFace2.png )
194338
>>194334

When did I ever discard constructive criticism? I'm just trying to have fun, man. i know some things are bad. You're the one who's taking everything so seriously. Why don't you let us see your OC? Do you have an OC? If you're so determined to judge our OC's, why don't you follow >>194261 's example? Picking out a single trait from one of my characters, telling me it's bad, and then blaming it on the use of the pony creator is not constructive.
>> No. 194339
File 134004166548.gif - (1.03MB , 500x442 , Pinkie_lol.gif )
194339
>>194337
>>194338
lol, see?
>> No. 194340
File 134004181205.png - (132.27KB , 800x842 , firebloom wut.png )
194340
>>194336
You can also dodge the topic at hand easily.

Boredom has nothing to do with all you said in the post, nor it has anything to do with creating an OC. Boredom might turn into creating a million OCs, for example. Making one OC, good bad or however, doesn't reflect boredom at all.

You also dodged the "creativity" subject quite slily.

And furthermore, you keep talking about people not accepting critique when:
1- It's not the topic at hand. Are you so frustrated on that you gotta mention it in every post?
2- Like I said "9001" times before, nopony did. You can't expect people to react to generalized comments not directed to anypony in specific, which are the ones that didn't get a reaction. The ones who actually did it right and posted specific critique nicely, weren't ignored. Are you even reading the thread anymore? Didn't you see that one person just post a new design thanks to the feedback given in here? Cause you sure talk like you didn't.
>> No. 194341
>>194333
That's true. Maybe just a dog caretaker? Or is that too Fluttershy-ish?
>> No. 194342
File 134004224186.png - (88.92KB , 800x878 , firebloom closeup.png )
194342
>>194341
Hmm... it all depends on the execution, really. Story or pics you do of it, etc. Fluttershy takes care of all kinds of animals, but that doesn't mean there can't be a more specialized pony. Only one kind of animal, but perhaps to an even deeper level? Further relationship with em? Being 24/7 with em? Cause we only see Fluttershy with animals in the secondary scenes, honestly. Only important part about that was the Manticore. Maybe the dragon, but that wasn't really her talent.
>> No. 194343
>>The ones who actually did it right and posted specific critique nicely
"yeah it lacks in some parts, but overall it's great"

mods need to understand that this kind of filth belongs to /rp/ or /ooc/, because it spoils fun for people just lurking for high quality pics.
>> No. 194344
File 134004259052.png - (565.91KB , 690x676 , 62.png )
194344
>>194338

>>194157
>>194158
>>194168
>>194178
>>194182

These are my posts with constructive tips and criticism on CT's pony.
So don't tell me I'm not doing anything.
And learn to read, if you'd actually read the thread, not just skipping through it you'd know answers for both your questions.

>>194340
>Boredom has nothing to do with all you said in the post, nor it has anything to do with creating an OC
Alright, live in this lie

>Making one OC, good bad or however, doesn't reflect boredom at all.
It does

>Dodged "creativity"
I moved it in my posts about tips, linked above.

1.Because I'm not talking about my critique, I don't know even how did you got to this conclusion, silly.
2.Yes, yes they were ignored posts aswell,besides the lizardpony and Amar (I belive his name was Amar, not checking), almost every single post actually saying something was ignored.

>>194075
>>194092 (saying his two cents is also an opinion in this case)
>>194099
>>194146 (opinion)
>>194153 (CT saying I don't care)
>>194158
>>194182
>>194213 (list)
>>194221
>>194224
>>194290
>>194301
>>194300
>>194305

If there are more, I missed then because I'm tired of people who don't actually care.
>> No. 194345
File 134004267609.jpg - (35.13KB , 313x362 , 132918336789.jpg )
194345
>this thread
>> No. 194346
File 134004274501.png - (499.43KB , 730x625 , 14.png )
194346
>>194345
And then, suddenly, banhammers everywhere!
Can I get a /ooc/ only ban if even, pretty please?
I like to go on /gala/....
>> No. 194347
>>194342
Perhaps she could run a center where she cares for dogs when their owners are busy/on vacation, etc.? I imagine she'd have a deeper bond and understanding with dogs than most.
Also, I'd just like to say that Firebloom is adorable.

But the way, thanks again for the help everypony! I've never made an OC before, bouncing ideas off you guys and the critiques you've given really are helpful.
>> No. 194348
File 134004333321.jpg - (14.64KB , 268x265 , 133178557979.jpg )
194348
I think my OC IS the best. Doomsayer has cursed this thread, as well as anything he's posted in.

It's like, he has an aura where whatever he touches, it falls into chaos and pointless arguing.

It's almost to the point where it's awesome to watch.
>> No. 194349
File 134004337948.png - (140.93KB , 400x400 , 9.png )
194349
>>194348
Can you please stop rp-ing?
It's not the board you're looking for right now.
>> No. 194350
File 134004365107.png - (229.45KB , 1200x1103 , firebloom mane on face.png )
194350
>>194344
1- I never said you were talking about your critique. But it wasn't the topic at hand, and yet you felt the need to bring it up again.

2- I think you missed the part where I said specific and nice. Both requirements have to be met. I don't see much of that in all those posts you linked. Hell, I barely see any critique of any sort in most of em. The first one matches, and ironically enough it's from somepony with which you've been arguing. The one from Companion Cube Pony about accessories could work, except he didn't address anypony in particular, and that's part of the whole problem here.

So all in all, everything you linked is either somepony being a jerk, generalized critique not specifically aimed to anypony, or not critique at all. Except the very first one.

>>194347
That might work. Like I said, it's all in the execution. We didn't see many dogs in the show, but it could be in another city or something like that.

Also d'aww thanks x3 And you're welcome. This part of the thread is actually nice to do.
>> No. 194351
File 134004379661.png - (273.31KB , 538x468 , 136.png )
194351
>>194350
It's funny how I already asked about 4 people about this and somehow they agreed with me.
Nah, won't let them post here, too much faqotness.

Anyway, I'll check this later, I'm curious what will mods do
>> No. 194352
File 134004391831.jpg - (30.43KB , 500x375 , 132040114451.jpg )
194352
>>194349
I'm not roleplaying, i'm dead fucking serious.

I wonder what would happen if you go to /ef/chan and ask for Doomsayer. I managed to make a couple people hate me.

I don't post much on /mlp/, but i know Spinach doesn't like me.

Huh.
>> No. 194353
File 134004406623.png - (223.29KB , 311x406 , 162.png )
194353
>>194352
You seriously should stop now, it's bullcrap.
>> No. 194354
>>194353
1. This is my thread that I am ever so reluctantly sharing with you.

2. Stop what? This is the last time i'm going to say "I'm serious".

*Ahem*

I'm serious.
>> No. 194355
File 134004457283.png - (369.90KB , 551x600 , Opps.png )
194355
>>194320

I'm sorry if I did. Please forgive me.
>> No. 194358
File 134004549911.png - (381.22KB , 585x556 , 15.png )
194358
What did I told ya?
Anyway, have fun with your love circle.
>> No. 194361
File 134004556438.png - (102.75KB , 266x358 )
194361
Seeing how this thread has gone into full-on OC discussion, I've moved this thread to /ooc/.
>> No. 194366
File 134004597548.png - (100.66KB , 800x800 , firebloom look up.png )
194366
>>194361
Uhm... not to mean ay disrespect but... it was all about OCs from the start. And not all OCs are about roleplaying.

If anything, I think this kinda thing should go in /art/, seeing how it's about people's creations and critique. I dunno why it's always been in /pic/, really...
>> No. 194370
File 134004622533.jpg - (45.72KB , 188x204 , HOLYSHITLOLOLOLOLOL.jpg )
194370
>>194361
Called it.
>> No. 194374
>>194358
Also,
>Lose an argument
>Try to continue it without any real point
>Bitch to the mods and get it moved so nobody else can see your fail.

Real mature, asswipe. Real mature.
>> No. 194378
File 134004653267.png - (131.78KB , 800x929 , firebloom kitteh.png )
194378
>>194358
Alas, it is now proven that the only thing you wanted was to get us out of "your" board.
Good work, you're an exceptional troll.
>> No. 194396
File 134004706807.jpg - (27.59KB , 500x285 , tumblr_m3yu8nngr81rnb1vk.jpg )
194396
>>194374
>>194378

Also, being totally honest, this thread on /art/ will fail on about 70%, good artists won't give a crap, bad ones will go on how awesome oc's you have
Also, Ran, I remember you from art
>> No. 194397
File 134004709121.gif - (202.02KB , 497x320 , 131352366784.gif )
194397
Yes, we won.

I'm back to pic now, I had to make sure it landed in this miserable pit. Have fun now with urselves.
>> No. 194399
>>194374
hey, you gotta give me some credit there too >>194345
>> No. 194404
File 134004735913.png - (136.07KB , 469x900 , firebloom lie.png )
194404
>>194396
Eh, /art/ is horribly slow to begin with, but it's the proper place for this. I got some nice feedback in there, some time ago, so I don't really feel it's all that bad...

And no, I'm not mad, why would I? This is not my thread, I only came here to help others improve their OCs. If anything, I'm sad. Sad that some had to go and ruin it for those who could actually use it. But well, that's life, that's the world, hard to find nice people, I'm used to it, moving on.
>> No. 194439
Hmm...

If i delete this one and make another, that's a one-way ticket to a ban.

Though, if the mods allow it to stay, you fucking faggots will ruin it for the rest of us.
Seriously, if you like ruining fun for people, there are plenty of school playgrounds that you can destroy.
>> No. 194514
File 134005203506.png - (189.78KB , 631x555 , 132175430279.png )
194514
>>194397

Your board nationalism is adorable.
>> No. 194584
File 134005928679.jpg - (15.55KB , 250x250 , Now let me me tell you something.jpg )
194584
You are all discussing the importance and creative legitimacy of characters based off of My Little Pony, a show about cartoon ponies.

Chill pills are in order, yes?
>> No. 194587
File 134005965342.png - (133.30KB , 760x900 , firebloom disaproval.png )
194587
>>194584
So one can't discuss fanart without being enraged?

Not to mention "discussing" is not exactly the point, here. This is just for people who actually want help improving their OCs.
>> No. 194656
File 134006449265.png - (333.04KB , 680x765 , OC Pony Shrug.png )
194656
Not to mention that the original thread was more focused on just posting pictures of OCs, which was why it was in /pic/. While this thread at the very start included the idea of discussing OCs for improvement, it was still mainly just posting pictures. Sometimes people would help out, but it wasn't all that often.

It didn't turn out to be flat out discussions and arguing until the parasprites started showed up, some plain trolling, others "claiming" to help when in the end they're just causing more trouble than they're worth. Now the thread's in the Roleplaying Lounge where it doesn't belong. If anything, it should at least be in /art/ where it does say "show off your work and get critiques" if you truely believe it to be just that kind of thread.

Meh, whatever. Wherever this thread is now, or going to be, I'll just be using it for posting pics. Not even going to bother with any parasprites that show up anymore, they're not worth it as it seems everyone but them ends up on the punishment side of the mods' judgement.
>> No. 194728
File 134006782517.png - (83.15KB , 764x768 , 37624 - Dieto applejack crossover daieto diet panty_&_stocking_with_garterbelt.png )
194728
Oh this will be my first post in OOC!

The excitement!
>> No. 194765
File 134007007440.png - (130.01KB , 1500x938 , spinny top pretty with armor.png )
194765
...well, looks like the usual silliness for an oc thread. Just gona leave this pic in here, as I'm honestly just curious of what people think..not really looking for help or anything, just curious of feedback.
>> No. 194872
>>194765

Too many accessories. WAY too many. You're pushing it with the full outfit/cloak, much less with the earrings and such. The mane is too similar to your coat color, and there is no distinct outline to distinguish between them. You have strange markings (Tiger stripes?) on your legs. I find that's only good if it's some sort of tigrapony. Ooshy is a zebracorn. If it's just a regular pony with those markings, however, you better have a good explanation for 'em.
>> No. 194898
>>194872
Alien actually, which is kinda what's up with all the accessories as well. He doesn't want his full identity known yet, which I'm playing through in character over in the TGTN threads.

Ok, was just curious what people would think.
>> No. 195151
File 134009003182.jpg - (315.11KB , 1000x1000 , 1296448566330.jpg )
195151
Check out my OC guise
>> No. 195161
File 134009042902.png - (137.20KB , 800x945 , firebloom kitteh5.png )
195161
>>195151
Best OC. Period.

But silliness aside, that actually looks awesome, lol. In a super hyper extreme anime-like kind of way. And it's also a cool drawing style :P
>> No. 195197
File 134009241396.jpg - (46.59KB , 249x498 , 133806045804.jpg )
195197
>>195151
>> No. 195482
File 134012689792.png - (35.76KB , 510x480 , Smile.png )
195482
Derped alot and posted my OC in the /oat/.
Didn't even knew about this board.
Okay then...

Name: Simon
Talent: Drawing hilarous comics and parodies.
Likes: Spaghetti, looking at things burn(he's a slight pyromaniac), apple juice.
Dislikes: Being in the center of attention, loud noise.
Fears: Tracy.
Hobbies: Plaiyng video games, browsing the internet.
Flaws: Barely controls himself while in rage. Sometimes is too aggresive and mean. Can't dance, forgetful and lazy.
Personality: Mean and aggresive, when annoyed, and lazy, as mentioned. But he's actually funny and loyal.
When he has a good day, he can also be nice.
Listens to rock, metal and orchestra. He only takes his glasses off when he goes to sleep, and no one's near him. Why he never takes his glasses off near anypony, it's a secret to this day.
>> No. 195491
File 134012753920.png - (26.30KB , 222x232 , Well 2.png )
195491
>>195151
You win.
>> No. 195495
>>195482
Oh, and disliking the loud noise may contradict with listening to rock and metal, but I had machine sound in mind. Something like the driller.
>> No. 195515
File 134013041531.png - (58.77KB , 567x540 , happeh Archer.png )
195515
>>194107

>mfw you use my pic
>> No. 195520
File 134013066212.png - (419.65KB , 1467x1475 , Archer Battle Armor no helmet calm.png )
195520
Screw it. I'll post him for the lolz.

This is a direct copy paste from the AoS wiki. I want to improve the description of him on there as this was a quick write up, so this is pre-revision.

Archer Castellus is one of the crew of the Outrider, a frigate-class vessel captained by Gold Rush. Archer is a member of the Revolution, but he became so due to the circumstances of his arrival on the TGTN scene.
Archer is an alien ponyoid from the world of Novus, born to his father, Castellus, whose name he carries after his own as a matter of custom. Noverians are a very war-like people. They believe in honor through combat, much like the culture of the Ancient Vikings. This is partially due to the fact that Noverians evolved from predators rather than herbivores, blood runs deeper with them than with Equestrians. Noverians are different from Equestrians in several noticable ways. First and foremost, their size. Archer is even tall for his people, and he stands at a monstrous 7 feet six inches tall, 8 feet when he is wearing his armor. The second most noticable difference is that Noverians are omnivores. Archer sports long canine teeth that he uses to devour flesh, and he is known to actually use them as weapons when fighting hoof-to-hoof, he is not above tearing somepony's throat out with his massive bite. He can eat meat raw too, but he chooses not to. Also, he doesn't usually partake of any sentient races if he can help it. The last difference between Noverians and Equestrians is in their cutie marks. While Equestrians have talents, Noverians do not. A Noverian receives its cutie mark when it discovers its true name, which it goes by for the rest of its life. Until they discover that name, they are simply known as the son or daughter of their parents. Archer discovered his name during a meteor shower, when he thought the firey meteors looked a lot like a volley of flaming arrows.

Archer was a mercenary before the events of his introduction in There Goes the Neighborhood. His father before him was also a mercenary, and when he died, the family business was passed down to him. As such, Archer is a very good soldier, but also a genius at tactics. He is the go-to guy for all things violent, and as such he was made a Staff Sergeant upon his introduction into the Revolution, and he serves as security officer on the Outrider.

Archer was introduced when Preddi, the VIP if you will aboard the Outrider, was captured by mercenaries attacking the Outrider. The mercenaries dumped Preddi in their brig, but she realized she was not alone. The mercenaries were revealed to have captured Archer after they stabbed his own mercenary crew in the back because of a deal gone south. They killed all of Archer's crew, including his, at that point, invalid widowed mother. Archer felt a hate towards them that could only be described as demonic, and when Preddi came onto the scene, he felt the time to strike back was nigh. So, when they forced him to help steer the ship into landing, he flipped the ship 90 degrees the wrong way, and crashed it. He then led Preddi out, in a five hour trek through blistering winds, subzero temperatures, and chest-deep snow drifts. Even then, he was shot through the shoulder when they tried to board the Outrider, and had to be dragged on board.
>> No. 195522
>>195520

Sorry... the Space and Madness Wiki
>> No. 207711
File 134089870453.jpg - (441.65KB , 1024x640 , Megapone.jpg )
207711
Now I decided to upload this here.
>> No. 207752
File 134090228339.png - (751.48KB , 1024x640 , megapone v2.png )
207752
But this one is about 20% cooler.
>> No. 207771
>>207752
Personally, I prefer the simpler one. The second one looks good but it's a little over done.
>> No. 207774
>>207771
oh, hey. I posted exactly one hour after you!
>> No. 207795
File 134091020136.png - (281.89KB , 1200x1900 , Badger the hippogriff 1.png )
207795
Badger, the Hippogriff
>> No. 207826
File 134091212744.png - (731.32KB , 1024x640 , Megapone v3.png )
207826
I think this one is the best of the three.
>> No. 207827
>>207826
I still need to make him a cutie mark. Suggestions anyone?
>> No. 212194
So... I killed this thread?
Btw. I gave my oc new mane, new tail and a mare.
>> No. 212199
File 134126328256.jpg - (431.30KB , 1024x640 , Megapone Feat Chickpone copy copy.jpg )
212199
>>212194
Forgot to upload a pic...
>> No. 212205
File 134126347566.jpg - (36.71KB , 560x375 , 25_obama_lg.jpg )
212205
>>212199

Red and black is a color combination that has been done to death.
>> No. 212615
File 134128845951.png - (203.35KB , 908x390 , spoiler.png )
212615
>>212205
>pic related
>spoiler because DAMN THESE ERRORS
>> No. 212620
File 134128874753.png - (208.77KB , 717x566 , Venusaur.png )
212620
>>212615
>Mfw
>> No. 212628
File 134128896727.png - (56.97KB , 996x556 , abomination.png )
212628
>>212620
But wait! There's more!
>> No. 212707
File 134130391669.png - (313.82KB , 1300x1450 , MrShining.png )
212707
>>212628

And then there's this guy...
>> No. 212710
File 134130416646.jpg - (78.75KB , 600x600 , ___mlp_fim_luna_icon_2____by_joakaha-d4bj1ip.jpg )
212710
>>212628
I was so unnerved by that last one because there might have actually been someone bad enough to write that.

This one's obviously a parody.
>> No. 212715
File 134130507581.png - (246.23KB , 600x520 , 1dash faiiiiice.png )
212715
>>212710

I present to you a menagerie of horror: http://bronies.wikia.com/wiki/Midnight_Flare
>> No. 212732
File 134130766091.png - (1.72MB , 800x4950 , what not to do - even more of it.png )
212732
More bad OC horror here!
>pic

>>212715
Oh god burn it!

>>212710
Indeed it is.

>>212707
Oh you. He's not an OC. =P
>> No. 212734
File 134130783454.jpg - (183.90KB , 1680x1000 , Derpakiin9.jpg )
212734
>>212732

Most of the OC's on the 11th panel actually are on the Bronies wiki. Beware...
>> No. 212736
File 134130806694.png - (134.61KB , 585x653 , rarity\'s ponytail.png )
212736
>>212734
Why god?! Why?!
>> No. 212739
File 134130846596.jpg - (9.60KB , 308x296 , despair.jpg )
212739
>>212736

To punish us for our sins...
>> No. 212814
File 134133001819.png - (271.89KB , 3320x2600 , hiResPony copy.png )
212814
Okay. It seems that I have driven most people here insane, but if someone still reads this thread I am back... In green! Hair color is still the same.
>> No. 212913
>>212732

He did a comic with like, 4 of my OC's. Justly deserved, of course. Worst designs I've ever made. Let me find it.

Ah, here it is.

http://mixermike622.deviantart.com/gallery/31555481#/d4nw3i2

Two in seventh panel, two in ninth panel.
>> No. 213060
File 134134600533.jpg - (32.38KB , 335x450 , Barack-Obama.jpg )
213060
>>212814

What's his cutie mark supposed to represent?
>> No. 213070
>>212814

Ponies don't normally wear clothes. I'd pick the glasses or the jacket, but not both.

Torn ear, broken horn. Both of these are bad. I'm not a fan of the whole broken horn in general, but if you're attached to it, I'd fix his ear. If you're attached to the torn ear, fix his horn. He can be a battle-worn warrior, or whatever you're going for, without having all his limbs torn off.
>> No. 213078
>>213060
Maybe just plain bad-assery. I haven't really thought of it yet. I added current cutie mark mostly because it looked cool.
>> No. 213084
>>213070
I agree with the jacket, but I personally think that the broken horn and torn ear is a good combination.
>> No. 213114
File 134134880100.png - (302.46KB , 3320x2600 , althiResPony (2).png )
213114
Newest one.
Starting to think abput losing the horn and making him an earth pony. Or maybe pegasus/pegasi/something-like-that pony.
>> No. 214691
File 134146281490.png - (111.36KB , 1024x906 , buck yeah by bluelolz.png )
214691
Man... I completely missed the move to /ooc/

And I missed all this drama too! Damn. Oh well. Returning with new pic! Because of reasons!


>>195515
I like your pic...
>> No. 214927
File 134146978707.png - (219.71KB , 1024x576 , 131610178011.png )
214927
Hey guys! Um, I'm a character-designer-hopeful, and I run a few Tumblrs where I rate fancharacters from different series, and offer tips like you guys are in this thread. I recently opened up a MLP one- would anypony be interested in submitting their characters? It's a little slow getting off the ground.
>> No. 215348
File 134151228730.jpg - (133.93KB , 1366x830 , Pony Simms.jpg )
215348
Not sure if mine counts as on OC since it's the Master from Dr. Who/Whoof Regenerated into an Equestrian form. XP
>> No. 215407
File 134151595784.png - (0.96MB , 3000x3000 , sOLAR.png )
215407
>>214927
um.. ok sure?
Solar Eclipse
>> No. 215408
File 134151602141.jpg - (36.26KB , 311x417 , possesed flare is eclipse.jpg )
215408
>>214927
another pic
>> No. 215426
File 134151778082.png - (346.24KB , 516x497 , ponyoccolored1 copy.png )
215426
>>214927
I think you might get more luck on /art/, but here's my OC. If you need more pictures, just yell. Her name is Cinders, and her cutie mark is a ruby.

Good luck with the tumblr!
>> No. 215452
File 134151990081.jpg - (120.56KB , 1440x805 , 131430829643.jpg )
215452
>>215426

Thanks! The Tumblr's in my e-mail field if any of you guys would be interested in submitting.

The critique isn't just for character design, it's also for the character itself, which is why I figured I'd ask here.
>> No. 215481
File 134152306878.png - (30.49KB , 346x402 , thinking and adjusting glasses.png )
215481
So this is where were we rate pony OC's?

How about something a little less black and emo and such?

You know, something more show-like in color scheme? Something that actually fits.
>> No. 216061
File 134154911133.png - (32.89KB , 830x650 , ella 2.png )
216061
Wabbam! Huhahaha, I'm hyper tonight!

Not sure if anyone cares about background info, but just puttin it up to see what peeps think. Cause I get bored and it's interesting to see if other people like what I like.


Name: Ella

Age: Round twenty or so

Little bit of background info:

Ella was very young when she was struck by a crippling disease. She managed to survive through it, but lost her sight in the process, making her completely blind. From that day on, she spent her entire life working on a spell to help her regain her sight. She eventually accomplished her goal, but not how she had intended.

After countless trial and error, she discovered that it was much easier to look through the eyes of another pony, then trying to force her own sight to work. Now, after over ten years of practice, she is able to freely use her magic to look through a single ponies, or small animal, such as dogs and cats, eyes.

Often a wonderer, and having a bit of a gypsy spirit, Ella spent much of her life training with the sword and pistol. She was no fool, and knew that a blind mare could be seen as an easy target for any who might try to take advantage.

Often seen wandering with her canine, a german shepherd, she makes her way from town to town, traveling wherever the wind and circumstance take her.
>> No. 216065
>>214691
Hey, I've seen you on art a few times! Freakin love your oc man. Or at least his pics XD
>> No. 216204
File 134155900542.gif - (492.75KB , 500x212 , 53.gif )
216204
>>216061

Excellent background story, wonderful concept, bad design overall.

>Overused color scheme
>Nose coloring, plot coloring, stallion facial shape, hooves showing.

I have no idea what to call any of those specific things, but the hooves-fur thing is really a stallion thing. Same thing for the facial structure. Mares don't have those. Nopony has that butt thing. You might be able to get away with the nose thing, though, if that was the singular design quirk. If you're really attached to that color scheme, I'd still change the coat color.

>>215481

I like this one very muchly. Everypony take a lesson from thisun'.
>> No. 216444
File 134159801132.jpg - (23.85KB , 317x317 , solar when not djing.jpg )
216444
>>215452
Not sure what else you want... soo, I guess some stuff for the oc

Name: Solar Flare
Career: Thunder Cloud kicker by day, DJ by night
Alias: DJ-Sol
Personality: Strong, silent type. Stallion of few words.
Age: mid twenties
Background info:

Came from a family of well known Thunder cloud makers and kickers, usually starting up the scheduled storms. Mother was a pegasus, as well as his father. Has rather large wings for a pegasus from his father’s side of the family, as they give good and sturdy support for kicking large thunderheads. Usually wears a jacket so he isn’t to recognizable.

He DJ’s by a very rare way, his feathers. Pegusi can control each feather individually, but it takes a lot of practice, and he has done so. He mainly lives in Cloudsdale and occasionally Manehatten depending on his weather job. He has only one ambition, to become famous in both of his careers, After that, who knows.


not a lot, lol. I don't want to put anything to depressing down. This is before a major plot point in a fic I’m writing for him.
>> No. 216482
File 134160095224.png - (144.85KB , 901x839 , happysix.png )
216482
>>216065
I do tend to lurk /art/ and sometimes /pic/.

I'm glad Six is getting recognized :D
>> No. 216489
File 134160169354.png - (445.89KB , 2500x2500 , ella christmas_png.png )
216489
>>216204
Heh, thank ya! That was the old pony creator version pic that I have, I've done a lot of recolors since then but I tend to like those light colors a lot. But I'm also one that loves the whole black and red, everyones going to scream at you for being a mary sue, colors as well lol. But hey, that's just me. Dark colors are my thing. And light lol, especially with blues.
>> No. 216811
>>216489

That looks very nice. I'm still kind of iffy about the coat color, but it doesn't ruin it.

>>216482

I see you everywhere in /art/. Seriously.
>> No. 216876
File 134161633127.png - (0.98MB , 2716x2024 , Nathaniel Nocturnus.png )
216876
Well, I could use a little feedback on my OC that I recently completed, especially name-wise. I always have trouble there.

I know Nathaniel Nocturnus sounds iffy and not pony enough; it bothers the heck out of me, so it's basically a placeholder until I figure something better out. How does Canto Nocturnus sound? Also, I know that the fedora thing has been done to death, but I figure if I did it well enough it'd be alright.

He's between 16 and 18, male, and earth pony. His cutie mark is a crescent moon and a quill, which represents his fascination with the night time and his talent for creating varying forms of artwork (from music, to literature, to drawings) which are inspired off of such. He is in no way shape or form a master of these crafts (And probably never will be) but he loves being able to capture the night in his works and wouldn't have it any other way.

I know that when it comes to OCs, accessories are a touchy subject, so I want to know if these sound alright. The pendent around his neck is a gift that his father sent to him in a letter from his travels. Nocturnus doesn't know what it is, and his father didn't say, but he wears it 24/7 to feel closer to his father.

He often wears a fedora (And yes, I know that the fedora thing is as overdone as the black-red color scheme, but I figure that if I did it well enough, it can work) with a quill tucked into the band. The quill was made from a feather that his sister gave to him from among her own when he earned his Cutie Mark.

Sooo, thoughts? Ways I can improve him?
>> No. 216907
File 134161862920.png - (90.38KB , 1861x3026 , VioletHeart.png )
216907
>>216876

I think he looks quite nice. The purple may be a smidgen too dark, however. He's got a nice design overall, I'm not a fan of the obviously magical artifact necklace thing.

>Nocturnus doesn't know what it is, and his father didn't say...

Why not just leave it at the sentence beforehand? It's a pendant. Nothing special about it. That's because it's magic, or a key of some sort, or I 'unno. It's an old trope. If I were you, I'd leave it at a pendant.

As for the fedora, I rarely see those, so I think you're fine with that. Just don't add any more accessories and you'll probably be fine.
>> No. 216916
>>216907
Well I wasn't planning for it to be magical in the first place actually.

What I meant by that sentence was that it didn't look like anything in particular, like a piece of abstract art would, but I suppose the wording made it sound that way. Sorry about that.

I was gonna keep the accessories as they were anyway, so I'm glad that they don't seem to overbearing. What about the name though? Like I said, I was considering Canto Nocturnus, but I'm still not sure.
>> No. 216950
>>216916

Names are the bane of my existence, but lessee here.

He likes writing, so we could use things like:

Saga
Epic
Novella - I like that one.
Inky - A fairly popular one.
Cipher
Forms of "Stenography" (Steno, Stenog, etc.)
Screed
Forms of "Graphology".

For the last name, although you seem rather attached to it, we have the night, and thus we can use things like:

Dusk
Forms of "nox" (Nocturne, Nocturnal, etc.)
Nocti-x (Noctiflorous, etc.)
Twilight

Not a whole lot to work with there.

Remember, names are usually made up of a noun, or a noun and a verb. In other cases, singular adjectives.

E.g. "Rarity"
E.g. "Rainbow Dash"
E.g. "Twilight"
E.g. "Twilight Sparkle"
E.g. "Minty"
>> No. 216973
>>216950
I'm liking the Novella one. I'll be keeping the Nocturnus, which would give it a rather attractive bit of alliteration.

Thanks for the input though, really. I worked hard to try and make him a sensible and realistic character, so I'm glad that he was met well.
>> No. 217040
File 134162633099.png - (99.98KB , 987x810 , ella rolling cute_png.png )
217040
>>216811
*squees happily and rolls around*
>> No. 217813
File 134164351456.png - (141.74KB , 1090x675 , 131329360971.png )
217813
>>216811

I hang out in /art/, /pic/ and /chat/. Not surprised I'm all over.
>> No. 219989
File 134175315885.png - (370.78KB , 3320x2600 , hiResPony.png )
219989
Okay, here is the fial version of my OC.

I'm going to call him Clover Skull or Cloverskull, because his cutie mark is clover wih a skull in it.
I know that skull in ponys name isnt propably the best idea, but so what. He also isnt very good using magic, but is extremely lucky.

His past is a bit open, but heres what I'm planning:

He is son of earth pony and a unicorn. His father owned a brewery with special brew, called Red Cider, that would make it's drinker luckier for a couple of hours. The Red Cider was very popular in Manehattan for its effect, and thus it was brewed alot, but since Red Cider needs many ingredients from Everfree forest it was not easy to make. One unlucky day Clover Skull and his father ran out of ingredients again and had to go to Everfree forest to gather more. Everything went well untill Clover Skull heard howling of Timberwolves. His father did not believe him and said its just his imagination. They continued their search for ingredients, when the Timberwolves attacked. Clover Skull was able to get away with just a torn ear, but his father was ripped to pieces. That sad moment had one good thing in it... Clover Skull gained his cutie mark that represents his incredible luck and ability to cheat death, an ability that has proven to be useful many times. Clover Skull lived almost normal life, except for his horrible nightmares that would eventually drive him to the edge of insanity. After his mothers death Clover Skull decided to travel around Equestria, since he was not interested in staying one place for long nor starting a family. His travels eventually led him into ponyville. He wanted to see the Summer Sun Celebration, and Princess Celestia whom he had seen last when he was just a filly. Upon arrival he met a pin pony who started screaming and ran away. He decided to stay in Ponyvilles tavern when he heard that pink pony scream again behind him. He saw a violet pony with a small dragon but didnt pay any more attention to them. He walked to the tavern and paid for the room. He took a little nap, and after waking up decided to visit local library to borrow a book to read while waiting for the celebration to start. When he got to the library he heard alot of noise coming from inside the library. It seemed like to him that there was a party. Clover Skull didnt want to socialise with ponies he might not see tomorrow. He then went to the Summer Sun Celebration area and waited. After a few hours ponies started to arrive to the celebration. After mayors introduction for Celestia, he got a little bit exited. He was dissappointed when Celestia didnt arrive, but then he saw an evil clone on Celestia. Evil clone started nagging about her being imprisoned for thousand years and her being not royal enough. Then that violet pony with dragon shouted evil clones name, and it was somewhat familiar to Clover Skull. he knew he had heard or read it somewhere. Then he remembered the ruin in Everfree Forest. He wasn't able to go there since the death of his father, but he knew that this was important. Clover Skull hen went to Everfree Forest, and after a small while he came across to a manicore. The manticore was not going to let him pass, and so Clover Skull started throwing branches and rocks at the manticore to make it angry. It worked and the manticore jumped at him trying to crush his pony skull. Clover Skull dodged the manticore easily, and the manticore hit a very splintery log of wood. It roared like it was in great pain, but Clover Skull just passed it and continued his way to the ruin. He found some herbs and then remembered the recipe for his fathers Red Cider, and thought that some extra luck wouldn do any harm. While collecting those ingredient he heard singing from far away, and the singing voice sounded like that pink pony from ponyville. He thought it was just one of his shattered minds tricks, and kept on gathering the herbs. Soon only ingredient that he was missing was water. The singing had stopped and now he saw that a litle distance from him was walking six ponies, including the pink pony and the violet pony, now dragonless. He decided to follow them for a litle while, and soon they got to a river. He used what little magic he could and carved a cup from a rock. He then crushed the ingredients and mixed them with water in the rock cup. He then fermented the brew with a spell that his father taught him. After the brew was ready he waded across the river without minding the serpent that had calmed down for some reason. After a samll walk he arrived to the ruin, and noticed that the six ponies were already there. But htere was also that black mare with a helmet. She casted some sort of magic and made the violet pony and rock balls disappear. Rest of the ponies went to the other part of the castle and Clover Skull drank his brew, since thigs were definately going ugly. He followed the five ponies to the other part of castle, and heard the violet pony speak something about Elements of Harmony. Soon the ponies sarted floating and glowing, what made Clover Skull think that his mind was tricking him again. When the balck mare was distracted with glowing floating ponies he walked to a small room with a statue that looked like Celestia. He somehow knew that thsi was Celesia turned into stone. He didnt have a clue about turning Celestia back from her stony prison. He decided to trust blindy in his luck and just kicked the statue as hard as he could. On exactly the same moment his kick landed on the statue, and cracked it, happened a big flash of light and blinded him. After he had regained his sight he noticed that the staue was gone. He looked trough the door and saw Celestia talking to Violet pony that She called Twilight Sparkle. Clover Skull wanted to go to meet the princess right away, but decided to wait untill he got to Ponyville. He left when Princess was speaking to little dark bluish pony that was called luna or something like that. When he got to Ponyville there was already a party of some sort going on, celebrating princesses and the six ponies. He decided to go to get a book from library and then returned to his room in tavern.

If somepony read this far I would be happy to get some comments and suggestions and, well, anything you wish to say about this.
>> No. 219991
>>219989
And if someone wants me to write something about his travels, since they propably will play a big part of his past, please say so.
>> No. 220029
File 134176112387.png - (409.67KB , 1000x914 , Luna Abacus.png )
220029
>>219989
Well, firstly: holy bujeesus you need to let your text breath! It's never fun reading a gigantic wall of text, at least from my experience, so try and break it up into paragraphs.

Anyway, your OC itself, in my humble opinion, is far from anywhere near "finalized". I really hate to kind of attack you on this, but chiefly, having your OC's story tie in so strongly with established canonical events (even to the point of claiming to have caused one of them) will frankly not be met well by anyone at all from my understanding. Having your OC present for an event like the Summer Sun Celebration? Totally plausible because that's a big event and a lot of ponies were there. Being present for a private event between the Mane 6? That's pushing it. Blatantly claiming to have caused an event surrounding the Mane 6? That's not gonna go well at all, especially if it breaks canon.

Now that that's done, I think your OCs backstory is pretty cliche in the "lost father; epiphany due to loss; nightmares due to loss; generally sad backstory" thing that you have going on. I really liked the idea of his father working a brewery, and with him being brought up under a father like that. That's pretty interesting, different, and can work. However, everything else from how he lost his father, to how he got his cutie mark, to his alleged "edge of insanity" all seems very forced in for the sake of having tragedy take place where it's just extremely out of place.

If you want my serious advice, then I would suggest literally trashing everything about the story down to his origins of a "brewster's son" and build up from there, but this time try and abandon romanticism for realism; think about the kind of life you want him to lead that would make him a believable character in the Ponyverse, like somebody you can legitimately see as an actual person, with a few caricature-esque traits and quirks here and there (He is an MLP OC after all) and just don't try too hard to make him so overplayed; make him live in his own little microcosm of a life as a believable pony.

Oh yeah, and in terms of physical design, I would suggest desaturating the colors a TEENY TINY bit more and keeping the purple (If you must keep the purple) as something small like a singular highlight.

That's my honest opinion; I'm not used to critiquing and trying to help out with Pony OCs specifically, but as a writer I've helped a lot of people with their characters in the past, so I truly hope that my advice helped.
>> No. 220031
>>219989
And I of course forgot to tell something about Clover Skulls personality. He is somewhat egoistic and has very high self-confidence. He is, like said in story, almost insane because of his fathers bloody death and many times that he had survived from death just because of his luck. On his travels he met almost everything from Cerberus and Changelings to Usras and Minotaurs. He had also seen Queen Chrysalis from a distance in a place where she was with her minions last before episode Cantrelot Wedding. Also like said he is extremely lucky, but he relays on his luck as seldom as he can, since he likes to do things himself and not geting everything without giving anything in return. He is also very strong and fast runner and as an unicorn he has magical abilities. But unfortunately he is very bad at magic and knows only few spells that work with him. Someponies say that he sucks at magic to balance his luck. He doesnt have any long term friends since he spends most of his time travelling.
>> No. 220033
File 134176222923.png - (149.96KB , 804x994 , Just Like AJ.png )
220033
>>220029
Basically this.

When you make a character, it should never be about making them a hero or what you see as super cool, it should be about making them a character others will be genuinely interested to interact with and not be put off by. Roleplaying isn't your story, it's everyone's story, and doing things like claiming your character noticed an evil clone of Celestia is not only sort of sue-ish, it also screws over the person who plays Celestia.

What if you start playing with them, and then something you claim to have happened is forced onto them? How are you supposed to play a character who was so heavily shaped by an event like that when Celestia's player isn't willing to acknowledge that as canon? Should they be forced to accept what you've said is true? If so, shouldn't they have to acknowledge all of the people who've written their characters as her lover? Or having fought her? Or having proven her to be evil? Should they really be forced to change how she plays because of something you wrote?

When you write a story for your character, you should do just that, write a story for your character. This is their story, not the mane six or Celestia's.
>> No. 220035
>>220029
Thanks. I appreciate critique, especially good one. Like said characters background story isn't final, and is ghoing to propably change alot, but the character desing inst going to change much. Mostly mane and tail. And I must keep the purple. its something I wont allow myself to change.

I know that sory was clicheick and many parts of it are changeable, but the luck briging Red Cider, characters incredible luck, and him travelling alot are something I personally found too good to trash. And I wanted to make my character a bit insane and nightmares caused by traumas were easiest thing to do it. I'm going to make it so that the fumes from brewery of Red Cider made him insane or even more clicheish that he fell to the Red Cider.

I'm also pretty attached to the cutiemark wich is a four leaved clover with a skull, and easiest way (yes i'm lazy) to explain it was to make him survive a terrible death, and thus making himget a cutiemark with a reference to death and luck.

And I meant that he didnt free Celestia, just brke the statue, and just because of his luck the explosion happened, and the statue wasnt destroyed wich could, and propably would have killed Celestia. The blast thing of mane six was the thing that set Celestia free before my char could accidentaly destroy the statue and propably kill her.

And for the huge wall of text... I suck at writing a story.

And like I said, thanks for the critique, I will start planning a better story.
>> No. 220059
File 134176492556.png - (327.50KB , 3320x2600 , hiResPony.png )
220059
Okay. I found older version of my OC that i havent uploaded here yet. I think it's better as it has less purple.

And i want to add to my comment before that i didnt want to make him have any part in the original story, just make him to be in right place in wrong time. Like he was going to the ruin, that mane six knew to be the location of the elements, just because he had a feeling that he had read about the "black mare" AKA Nightmare Moon, and it was a plain accident that mane six were headed there. I intended to keep the original story as it was and just throw my character between and under the events as I was too lazy to come up with more original stuff.

But. I will propably trash everything except a few major bones of my story.
>> No. 220065
File 134176523108.png - (340.35KB , 3320x2600 , hiResPony.png )
220065
NOW fixed the glasses being ugly and bulky.
>> No. 220442
File 134177800393.png - (564.50KB , 2500x2123 , Luna Vector 2.png )
220442
>>220035
You're welcome, I try.

Well, I can understand wanted to keep the "luck" attribute, but when it comes to writing and having something so vastly different from your character's established upbringing make a large impact on his life, it has to be very well and cleverly written for it to seem natural rather than forced. I'm glad that you're willing to keep the backstory loose and change what needs to be changed.

Having him me mentally unsound due to another source other than something so awkwardly tragic would make his character seem much more believable. Believe me when I say that tragic backstories, while fun to do (I know this; I used to do them all the time) are abundantly overdone and insanity or a mentally unstable state can be obtained through the most peculiar of circumstances other than pure trauma.

As for how he earned his cutie mark, you have to remember that canonically speaking, ponies tend to get very strong hintings at what their special talent is up to the point where they actually earn it. For instance, Pinkie Pie experienced smiling itself before she discovered how much she loved making other ponies smile, Twist mentioned always liking making sweets before she had discovered it was her special talent, and Twilight had studied magic for who knows how long before the events at the academy?

My point is that when you write a backstory, just try your best to make everything blend together and feel more natural. Maybe your OCs special talent can be discovered when he and his father go out for ingredients and Clover Skull, by some outlandish luck, prevents his father from getting severely injured. Up until then, he could have some very lucky coincidences be happening at different points throughout his story up until now, which he'll realize just how lucky he is; being so lucky has a much more profound importance on his life than just nice little things happening to him here and there, it also saved his own father. That's just a humble suggestion to get the general idea. Backstories should seem natural, flowing, and believable.
>> No. 220506
>>220442
Thank you once again for giving me great ideas. Since my character is in a form I will propably keep him I can start planning the background story. If you could please help me in one decision that i've been struggling for a while...

When my character was still under heavy developement (damn, now he sounds like a car or a videogame) >>212199 I gave him a girlfriend. Should I make him a new one or keep him single?
>> No. 220524
File 134178160896.jpg - (34.04KB , 771x641 , Luna Resting.jpg )
220524
>>220506
Believe it or not, that's actually a very good thing if you start viewing your character like that. It shows that you've taken out a lot of time to develop and build your character, which is how it should be. The best kind of character is the kind that is so well-made and three dimensional that it feels like a real person.

Anyway, concerning your question, I would personally suggest leaving the girlfriend out. From a writing and roleplaying standpoint, filling out every part of the character's story and background to the point where they've already gotten a love interest leaves little room for actual development through the roleplaying or writing itself. If you plan on using him for this purpose, I would suggest leaving the girlfriend out and save love interests in general for later on in his story to allow more room for character development.

If you do decide to keep her, I would suggest using a color scheme that's not so similar to Clover Skull's. Romance is a hard part of writing because it requires the ability to make the characters seem different enough to be believable as characters themselves, but also connectable enough to make the romance and chemistry enjoyable. Making the potential love-birds so outwardly similar to the point where it almost screams "THESE TWO LOVE EACH OTHER" will make the romance seem more forced than natural, and frankly will not be enjoyed.
>> No. 221295
File 134180466816.jpg - (16.50KB , 360x371 , lovey dovey 2.jpg )
221295
Lovey Dovey, my newer oc....What do you guys think?
>> No. 221327
File 134180595303.jpg - (31.68KB , 333x385 , MY Hopper!.jpg )
221327
Normal pony with a normal life
>> No. 221428
File 134180954381.jpg - (48.53KB , 900x900 , Luna happy.jpg )
221428
>>221295
I remember that one. Looked just fine, the way I see it...at least in terms of design. The red still feels weird on the eyes, though.
>> No. 221486
File 134181207173.png - (16.23KB , 350x218 , 27.png )
221486
>>221295

I feel that your coat color is too dark compared to your mane and eye color.

>>221327
How incredibly boring.

However, if I were to provide CC for your design, I'd first suggest a change in coat color. Maybe pick one tone of blue instead of two, but you'll probably be fine with the two-tone you have now.
>> No. 221654
File 134181769774.jpg - (167.73KB , 841x1140 , 131131268579.jpg )
221654
>>220524
Your critique skills make me happy :D
>> No. 221684
File 134181901080.png - (311.30KB , 1023x573 , Luna Screencap.png )
221684
>>221654
Yayy, I made somebody happy!

....Why, though?
>> No. 221692
File 134181931435.png - (391.86KB , 944x768 , 38.png )
221692
>>220033
>>220029
>>220442
>>220524

GOD DANGIT. I miss the only time someone needs actual writing and story technique. D:
>> No. 221771
>>221692
You missed nothing. I'm still lurking around here while planning my characters background and I'm still open for suggestions.
>> No. 221884
File 134184878319.png - (53.11KB , 846x892 , HI!!!.png )
221884
>>221486
That's the idea.

The was meant to have just that, a normal ponies live, nothing over the top, just her live in cloudsdale.
>> No. 222120
File 134186155674.jpg - (16.95KB , 333x266 , its okay.jpg )
222120
Hello Oc Thread~
My name is SunnyChi and this is Push Broom~
>> No. 222126
>>221428
Okay yes, tahnk you, i want to keep red because of his name....should i change the color of the eyes?
>> No. 222160
File 134186288479.png - (324.74KB , 3320x2600 , hiResPony (3).png )
222160
Okay.

So I have a skeleton for the background story ready. I'm going to post it here so that you could help me improve it, because after the skeleton is ready and I start making up the full story it will be harder to change things.

Main events of the story would be:
1. Clover Skulls parents being an earth pony and an unicorn
2. His father would own the brewery with special brew called The Red Cider that would bring luck to its drinker
3.Clover Skull earns his cutie mark at the age of ten when alerting his father of the howling of timberwolves in the Everfree forest while they were collecting ingredients for the Red Cider, thus preventing his fathers death.
4. The fumes from Red Cider would drive Clover Skulls father insane, and he would have been put into pony asylum.
5. Clover Skull would work in the brewery for about ten years. The fumes would start to make him insane too.
6. Clover Skull loses the brewery to Flim and Flam, but doesnt tell the recipe for Red Cider. (Easiest way to make him lose the brewery and allow him to travel alot.)
7. Clover Skull travels for about ten years across Equestria. In his travels he ends up in many dangers, wich he survives mostly due to his amazing luck. He also visits a little town near the Everfree forest but that isnt shown in any map, that has been overrun by changelings, but he sneaks around it, geting only a slight look at the hideous bug-pony queen.
8. He arrives in Ponyville for Summer Sun Celebration to see Princess Celestia, whom he had last seen as he was a filly.

The rest is pretty much open and there will be alot more between the "bones", but please, tell me if somethings are too used, or just doesnt work.
>> No. 222217
File 134186442207.jpg - (53.68KB , 841x949 , philly pb.jpg )
222217
So....yeah whats up guys?
>> No. 222376
File 134186935751.png - (249.03KB , 1500x1250 , Luna Cloud.png )
222376
>>222160
Well, you've definitely fixed up the story of all its problems and added a more interesting one in its place. I think some people will be iffy about him getting a glimpse of this "bug-pony queen" but if you play it down, it can't hurt.

I like how you don't play up any specific part of his strengths other than his luck, so I think he seems more believable now. I think it would be interesting if he keeps himself supplied in his travels via money he gets from selling his Red Cider wherever he goes. Playing up this part of his life would make him seem more realistic and enjoyable as a character because it shows how that kind of thought-process would work.

-Loses brewery to competition
-Keeps special recipe
-Survives as a traveling seller of his special brew
-Knows he is safe in his travels not because of his own strengths, but because of his luck

I think that basis as a character would make him very enjoyable. In terms of character development, you can go into the points of having a father who isn't entirely lost, but still detached, and maybe go into the topic of his lack of actual strength in place of his amazing luck. What I'm saying is that what realistic points of his character, you should play up to make up the "foundation" of his character, and save the abstract and more 'out there' points (Father's insanity, for example) for opportunities of character development.

>>222217
Oh, not much. Just trying my best to be helpful. What's up with you?
>> No. 222381
File 134186959982.png - (36.16KB , 704x396 , 32.png )
222381
>>222160

I see no purpose in including "bone" 7. If you were to write a fic that was completely separate from your RP story, and that by seeing Chrysalis happened to influence the rest of said story, then it could be a viable "bone."

Unfortunately, the bad part is that Flim and Flam are canon characters. If someone is rping as Flim Flimflam or Flam Flimflam, it becomes the same problem you had with the Celestia thing earlier.
>>220033


>>222120
>>222217
She reminds me of my OC Violet, in terms of hair. I don't think that you'll be able to have a good chat here, considering the speed of /ooc/ and how often people actually check this thread, but I'll try anyway because you seem pretty cool. *Ahem*

I just had knee surgery and am now sitting on my couch although I should really probably be napping.
>> No. 222401
File 134187042080.png - (98.50KB , 563x800 , Luna Wat.png )
222401
>>222381
Hm, that's a pretty valid point concerning the Flim Flams, but in the end they're just placeholders. The brewery could be shut down for any number of reasons; Perhaps it was forced to shut down due to Clover Skull's dad going insane from the fumes? That sounds feasible. It would add more depth to his keeping the Red Cider recipe and selling it on the "down low".

Anywho, what did you need the knee surgery for? That sounds unpleasant.
>> No. 222412
File 134187139017.png - (97.21KB , 506x506 , Swag.png )
222412
Holy hay barrels, this thread is still alive? Well I'll be a mule's uncle, this is surprising. I thought this thread died long ago after it was (well I believe) wrongfully moved to this part of Ponychan.

Eh, guess I'll lurk around this thread again for a while, see what happens, check out the newer OCs.
>> No. 222414
File 134187191261.png - (31.74KB , 704x396 , 11.png )
222414
>>222401

I didn't say that the bar couldn't be shut down, I was just suggesting that he not use the Flimflam brothers. I think that's an excellent suggestion you have there, but I think he was using the part where he ran the bar as a timelapse so that he could feasibly travel the world of Equestria as an adult, and not a young child.

*Ahem*

I've been crippled since December, long story short, it was only early April that they decided that it was an osteochondritis dissecans lesion in my right knee. Got a third MRI of my knee late June, they decided it wasn't getting any better with conservative treatment, so they planned surgery for me. Basically, the surgery was just drilling a hole into the bone to stimulate it because it is "dead" and not healing itself. It hurts. And I'm even more tired now than I was before.

>>222412
Define "alive." Before, it was alive, but not because people were getting their OC's judged, but mostly because we kept getting into fights with those OC-hating idiots in /pic/. Anywhozle, welcome back.
>> No. 222444
>>222414
>those OC-hating idiots in /pic/
hey!
>> No. 222449
File 134187394946.jpg - (9.78KB , 185x185 , Luna S2.jpg )
222449
>>222414
That makes sense...But I suppose that it takes quite a while for any business to be shut down. I don't think it would be shut down immediately. If his father's cider was as well-liked as it should reasonably be when it was in regular production, then there would be plenty of paying customers ready to do what they can to support the brewery. If his father was a well-liked boss, then I'm sure plenty of the old employees would have stuck around until the very end. Basically, maybe the brewery could have gotten by bit by bit every year until it would get run out of business due to the fumes affecting too many of the employees, other employees quitting, bad PR, just things steadily working to take it down. By the time it finally crumbles, he would be old enough to travel.

And that sounds pretty bad; why did it take so long for them to realize what it was?

>>222412
I used to lurk this thread when it was in its earlier stages, I've seen how it just kind of ran off-and-on between actual discussion and parasprite-induced arguments. Didn't seem very fun.
>> No. 222454
File 134187416267.png - (797.74KB , 1000x1045 , Luna Whoa.png )
222454
>>222444
Them double trips get! Haha!
>> No. 222464
>>222414
The brewery almost has to be shutted down or be given/sold to somepony else. That way I could make my character be able to travel alot.

>>222381
And for FlimFlams... I thought that it would be funny that those company stealing salesmen would be the ones to get the brewery, since they were anaxious to get Sweet Apple Acres s why wouldnt they have done it before with other rivals? This time the little brewery didnt have a chance against the mass production of FlimFlams super machine.

If it's over the top, I will make the brewery burn or maybe it could collapse to sea if it would be built upon a sea on some sort of platform (is there a sea near manehattan?) or maybe it would jsut be sold.
>> No. 222470
>>222449
And I intended to make Clover Skulls fathers brewery only a small business, since the ingredients for the cider were hard to get, and only workers would be Clover Skull, his parents and possible siblings (if i decide to give him any), and after Clover Skulls father going to asylum the brewery would propably lost customers because they would think that the drink was that what made him go insane, so it would propably be easy for big companies to crush them.
>> No. 222506
>>222470
Well in that case, I suppose it would be a very different kind of story. However, depending on how long the Red Cider has been sold, I highly doubt that costumers whom have been buying and drinking it for a while would reach that conclusion; any sensible pony would realize that if it was the drink, then a lot more ponies would have had it affect them, regardless of how long the business had existed. It can't be due to overconsumption either because if the ingredient were as hard to get as they are made out to be, then it would not make sense to waste them on making more batches for oneself than for the business itself; the business would never have reached a steady point and would have crashed a long time ago.

Anyway, all that is basically obsolete considering that the loss of the brewery is still an open-ended topic, yes? If complication is to be avoided, I suppose that a stray fire would be an easy choice. Not everything in a story has to be too in-depth I suppose.
>> No. 222546
>>222449

Osteochondritis Dissecans is a very rare disease. The symptoms are very similar to Patella Femoral syndrome, and because I got an MRI before the OCD lesion was prominent, they dismissed OCD and were trying to treat me for Patella Femoral.

>>222464

You've still got that problem with using canon characters, though. A fire would probably be best, and everyone can believe that. Just like Swamp Gas.

>>222470
Small Business is good. People thinking that it was the cider is bad, unless a few others connected to it had been shipped off to the asylum as well.
>> No. 222565
File 134187764453.jpg - (73.59KB , 443x447 , Luna Hug.jpg )
222565
>>222546
Ohhh, I see. Well my wishes go with you; hope ya get better.
>> No. 222607
File 134187853285.png - (102.51KB , 1280x720 , 29.png )
222607
>>222565

Thanks!
>> No. 222746
File 134188462921.png - (96.83KB , 523x618 , Adult Applebloom Alone.png )
222746
>>222376
...I like you.
>> No. 222774
File 134188593887.png - (38.61KB , 704x396 , 4.png )
222774
>>222746

Okay...
>> No. 222816
File 134188742687.gif - (1.84MB , 853x480 , Luna Laugh.gif )
222816
>>222774
mfw that picture+reply combo
>> No. 222850
File 134188868409.png - (30.25KB , 704x396 , 7.png )
222850
>>222816

mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that picture+reply combo
>> No. 222879
File 134188964682.png - (3.66KB , 366x374 , DAID.png )
222879
Azure Crash

It's just easier for me to link to his info: http://blue-cup.deviantart.com/art/Azure-Crash-Profile-282440215
>> No. 222898
File 134189030479.png - (156.68KB , 403x427 , Ah\'m an Apple Filly.png )
222898
>>222774
Cool story, brony.
>> No. 222942
File 134189100067.png - (124.95KB , 500x410 , Luna Wat Angry.png )
222942
>>222850
mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance.

>>222879
Well now, this is a pleasant surprise. As a character, you have quite impressively fleshed him out into the full third dimension, something that some people seem to have a problem with. Not only that, but as a pony himself, he is very believable and realistically fits into the universe. I can see him as a real live person, and this is good.

The actual design is very nice too. It's got a lot of blue, but you've managed to adjust them into the right levels so that one part doesn't necessarily seem to overpower any of the others; basically the colors feels very balanced. The eyes stick out a tad bit, but it's really just a minor gripe.

Now for the bad news. Generally, people view any form of relationship with the canonically established cast of the show to be left untouched. For instance, if this character was used in a Roleplay, then somepony filling a role for Rainbow Dash would be put-off by your character's bio stating a predesignated relationship with her, even if it is just her harassing him.

As for Luna, it's very iffy, especially considering for him to have a crush on her at the age of a foal, he would have to have been born at the time that Twilight and Co. are in their pseudo-adulthood. Which would thus make create a tangent in the timeline for him to be harassed by Rainbow Dash as she would in the current timeline. Anyways, crushes on other ponies can possibly be left to slide, but only if the OC never pursues this affection or develops a relationship with them. You don't seem to have a problem with this, even for this Lunar Knight persona, whom he apparently only was when playing pretend. This is feasible.

Really though, that's all I've got. You have a good design in terms of appearance, personality, and backstory save for what few points I brought up. Well done.
>> No. 222950
File 134189125535.jpg - (110.80KB , 478x575 , Explanation.jpg )
222950
>>222414 I would define alive as in before that all happened. As in, OC pictures were being posted, people who wanted critiques asked and recieved nice ones, and that's why in was in /pic/. It was mainly just posting pictures of OCs. Then, the parasprites came in, either posting OC-hate comments or trying to turn the whole thread into a strict, harsh OC rating system where everything creative was deemed "wrong." Which of course, succeeded since the thread was deemed to be nothing but "OC Discussion" by a Mod and immediately moved without warning. By then, the thread only recieved a few more posts until all posting stopped for what seemed enough to deem it dead, to which I left. And that was a while ago.

And today, I came back to find it active. Anyways, I may not "exactly" be back. I may post every now and then, but I won't be as involved as I was before. After all, this is an OC discussion thread now, correct? So a pony that just wants to post pictures wouldn't be too welcomed.
>> No. 222968
File 134189171253.jpg - (9.78KB , 185x185 , Luna S2.jpg )
222968
>>222950
Well, I suppose that makes sense. I kind of enjoy it now that it's nice and slow, but that's just me. It's a shame that some people are so negative and hateful when concerning the mere mention of OCs. Anyway, I always thought your OC was pretty cool, so if there's a thread out there where I can check out pics of yours and other peoples', like how this thread originally was, couldja let me know?
>> No. 222991
File 134189235734.png - (138.12KB , 687x695 , Picture of Little Colt CT.png )
222991
>>222968 Mostly all pictures I have currently have were already posted in this thread at some point. Any newer ones I have are either Tumblr answers or story comics that are singled out for Tumblr posts. I was really active back when this thread was just about posting pics, and really defensive for this thread when the parasprites came in. So it's really a matter if you're willing to scroll through the entire thread and see them. I doubt you could miss 'em, no other pony has a mane like this, lol
>> No. 223001
File 134189255972.png - (19.29KB , 640x360 , 35.png )
223001
>>222879

Oh, I've reviewed and advised you and your OC tons of times. I'm sure you don't want to hear me do so again.

>>222950

I'd certainly enjoy you just posting pics, but I don't know anything about any sort of mods here. Just be lucky, okay?

>>222968

Go to url, remove "+50," use the great and powerful archiver.

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223012
File 134189310975.gif - (922.81KB , 633x356 , Luna Rage.gif )
223012
>>222991
Whelp, time to get scrollin'!

>>223001
Or...not? Huh...

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223097
>>222950
oh how I missed you~
you were pretty talkactive for someone who just wanted to post pictures. I mean did you look at other /pic/-threads? not a single word for thousands of posts.

I still don't see your problem, this thread is pretty much the same as before in /pic/ - where it just didn't belong
>> No. 223113
File 134189626158.png - (278.15KB , 2263x2666 , six mon flying by choco.png )
223113
>>223012

Your crit is amazing, hence it makes me happy.

I'd bother you for some crit of my OC, if you have time...

http://bronies.wikia.com/wiki/Six_Mon_Coin

If not, I'll just lurk your other reviews.
>> No. 223116
File 134189632028.png - (355.39KB , 960x763 , 39.png )
223116
>>223097

You're still just so cute with your devout board loyalty.
>> No. 223118
File 134189636219.png - (28.76KB , 220x224 , Concerned.png )
223118
Ya know, I actually don't remember seeing any actual posters on /rp/ contributing, so why not?

I've actually been using this character for several months now, and have never really had a chance to explain them...

Born as the youngest foal and only daughter to her parents, Dewdrop clung to her family like glue. Not due to any social ineptitude on her part, but simply because of the small size of Hoofston, her home town, the pegasus's circle of available friends was rather small, so where most fillies would have branched out, she grew inwards, becoming closer to her family and small cluster of friends. Her mother rather enjoyed gardening, and she enjoyed her mother, so she spent many an afternoon helping her with it. Every once and awhile, they would stumble across a hurt animal, and the filly would nurse it back to health. Eventually, this grew into a desire to help ponies, and she began to study medicine. After several years of study and school, the pegasus graduated and began to work Ponyville General.

That's it. Short, sweet, not too far-fetched.
>> No. 223121
>>223116
huh? what do you mean?
>> No. 223127
File 134189652868.png - (150.49KB , 550x414 , Why Would you Do That.png )
223127
>>223118
>work Ponyville General

>work Ponyville

>Not "work at"

...apparently that nap didn't help at all.
>> No. 223136
File 134189673924.png - (29.28KB , 704x396 , 8.png )
223136
>>223118

An excellent story. Short, sweet, completely believable. I only have one problem, and that is with the eye color. It seems a tad too light compared to your dark orange and salmon-ish red.

>>223012

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223145
File 134189693101.png - (21.39KB , 704x396 , 19.png )
223145
>>223127

At least you didn't get anesthesiated up like me. Also, is she wearing a ribbon tied in a bow on her back in that picture?
>> No. 223147
>>223116
no, seriously. I don't get it
>> No. 223151
File 134189723144.png - (35.37KB , 704x396 , 3.png )
223151
>>223147

Maybe I read that incorrectly. You are indeed
>>194397

And insulting Mr. Blademane, correct?
>> No. 223154
File 134189731728.jpg - (54.79KB , 900x506 , Luna Giggle.jpg )
223154
>>223118
Basically what >>223136 said. There's very little opportunity for your character's backstory to have any holes poked in it because of how concise and simple it is. The more that creators stretch out their characters' backstories, the harder they have to work in order to make it all work properly. You don't have this problem, which is good. While I didn't notice the eyes until they were mentioned, I kinda can't help but notice that they are a tad out of place. Frankly though, it's a very small nitpick in my opinion and something that can easily be let slide.

Oh yeah, and Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon my countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo

>>223113
I'm quite surprised that you see my critique in such a positive light. I just like to help other ponies and as a writer I've helped people with their characters a lot, so I guess it just shows.

And of course I'll do a critique of your OC, I have all night. Might take a tad bit so give me a second to finish my midnight dinner and I'll check it out.
>> No. 223155
>>223151
ah I see - that's different anon
>> No. 223167
File 134189768345.png - (30.76KB , 704x396 , 5.png )
223167
>>223155
Oh, do please forgive me. I didn't mean to sensitize you into an old argument. Forget I said anything.

>>223154
See, this is what happens when you beat me to writing critiques. (mumble grumble mumble complain grumble mumble)

How long can we keep this up? I only have like 40 reaction pictures for Raito, and one of them is a gif.

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223186
>>223167
's okay, can happen. as far as I could tell there were 3 anons in this thread.

but just to clear things up a bit more: threads get moved out of /pic/ regulary even if I'd like them to stay because I find them interesting. some just don't belong, that's how it is - this thread was one of them. big deal.
I followed here from /pic/ (and put it on my threadwatch) to find out more about OCs and how they're judged.
I'm not going to comment on any OC anymore because apparently that makes me a parasprite if my explanation for it isn't long or detailed enough, or something, I dunno... really, I've come to the conclusion that you have to be a member of the OC-clan* or at least have a name/trip to get your voice heard

*working title, call it what you want ^^
>> No. 223201
>>223136
Most others aren't that light, and are usually more gray.

>>223154
And I've always thought that it's better to let them develop naturally and due to their environment, rather than write long, complex, hard to keep track of stories for them.

Plus, I like to focus on making my characters realistic to the point where you can imagine them being real people. Makes them much more likeable.

For instance, Dewey isn't stupid or childish, but she's still pretty naive. Not because that's just who she is, but because for the most part, she still has a lot of growing up to do. She wants to rush into a relationship for... Really no good reason other than the fact that her view of love is highly romanticized, which was caused by her love of stories about princesses and the like when she was a filly.

In short, she isn't a perfect character. She has faults, but they're real faults. They aren't there just for drama or to make her tragic, but to give her depth, make her interesting.
>> No. 223205
File 134190272530.png - (120.82KB , 680x800 , Luna Fiddlesticks.png )
223205
>>223167
I haven't counted how much Luna I have; I'm trying to use them in proper order in response to the actual reaction pic you use. Haha!

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon my countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo


From what I've seen of your critiques, you're very good as well.

>>223113
Alright lets do this!

Personality-wise, you have a very firm build of the "selfless introvert" archetype of character, which as it is a common trope, leaves little room for anything to be done wrong. This is good. The interesting spin that you have on this character archetype is that his "inner strength", which appears when defending or standing up for others, is his special talent and representation of his cutie mark (We'll get tot he cutie mark later).

When it comes it OCs, it always hard to find something that'll make them unique and different; this is often in the shape of making something about them a "first" or "current only one" amongst the OC community. This is not bad at all, this is actually what breeds creativity when one looks to think of doing something that somepony else hasn't yet (Within reason, of course). This was done well with Six Mon in the way that you had him be given the first prosthetic wings. I like this because I have never seen it within the community before and is feasible considering prosthetics do exist and the ponies have an extensive amount of intelligence in the show which would probably allow for prosthetics to exist. What I also like about them is that as they are the first, they are realistically not at all on par with real wings. It says he can fly for short distances (Notice the specified 'short') and is not as agile, this makes sense, as the wings are for all intents and purposes a prototype. It is also admirable because I am sure that in this extensive community, somepony has thought of prosthetic wings before and was perhaps too nervous to do them; your ability to make an OC and put him out there with them is likeable in and of itself.

Now for the rest of the design. His coat and mane coloration are seamless in my honest opinion; they do not contrast with one another and don't try to stand out as much as the wings do. The coat is simple so that the wings can do their job and be the "eye attraction" of the character (Basically what draws the eye).

Now here's where it starts getting kinda iffy. Of course we all know heterochromia is real, so it can be done on a pony OC. Typically eyes aren't always scrutinized too much when it comes to the character, but these ones on Six Mon can be viewed in one of two ways.

A positive way, in which the strange eyes compliment the prosthetic wings in "eye attraction" and balance out the simple coat color with a proper saturation of uniqueness.

In a negative way though, they can be seen as overbearing in that they clash with the wings in being "that one thing" that sticks out about your character, causing it all to be a tad forced.

Take it for what it is. Now the cutie mark suffers a form of this as well, but not entirely. The one nitpick about the cutie mark is its connection to a culture that has no presence in ponyverse canon. However, It can easily be argued that it's just six yellow dots, and that it can through some indirect fashion be a part of a fanon culture not mentioned in the actual show. In the end, it's just a nitpick. It really wouldn't be a problem if the OC's name wasn't the name OF the cutie mark; that's an even smaller nitpick though.

Overall? Six Mon Coin is a well-written OC that is based around a classic character Archetype with unique quirks and designs thrown in to make him different, and it works quite fine in the end. Personality-wise, he's seamless. Appearance, there are nitpicks here and there, but those only matter to those who are looking for problems. On a personal note, I have to give you credit for doing something ballsy and different with your OC which I'm sure a few have thought of before but dismissed as qualities of a bad character. Yours shows that they aren't bad at all.

Sorry about the delayed response...it would seem that Ponychan suddenly decided to stop working for me...
>> No. 223206
File 134190288613.gif - (444.53KB , 470x413 , Bob_Your_Head_-CT.gif )
223206
Oh Anons...one moment they're spewing hate...the next they're all friendly...

I'm just one of those people that can't look at Anons seriously anymore. Because I never know who I'm talking to, I never know who's replying to me. It could be the nicest guy or girl in the world. Then again, it could be a parasprite trying to start trouble. I don't know, and can never 100% know. Without some indication (namely, a name), I'm looking at the same person every time, who just happens to have split personalities. Call it my odd logic.

Anyways, it's like 1:45 in the morning. I need sleep.
>> No. 223210
>>223201
Wow, that's very admirable of you as a writer.

I usually have the same mindset with the characters I make specifically for roleplaying; the characterization and development gained through actually roleplaying as them makes whatever traits that are developed through the process much more natural and believable. Why, I have a character outside the ponyverse that I've been roleplaying with for maybe four years; literally an approximate 80% of his backstory is all made up of previous roleplaying sessions.

Anyway, Just your aim to make your character like that, which is to say believable and realistic, definitely sets to apart as a good writer in more than one way.
>> No. 223213
File 134190343734.png - (38.05KB , 704x400 , 21.png )
223213
>>223201

Most of your other eyes? She can switch out her eyes at will? That's crazy, man.

Well, all that depends on whether you're making a character for RPing or just a character to use for everything, or a character for a fic.

>>223205
Thank you. I appreciate that.

I'm trying to do the same, but I'm just warning you that I don't have a whole lot to work with.

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223221
File 134190373723.png - (507.69KB , 830x650 , tumblr_m6igkcAKBq1rncbeqo1_1280.png )
223221
this is buttercream, she is a decedent of the royal canterlot family who was blessed by the gods with eternal youth, she was adopted by trixie where she was taught how to use magic, she later decide to join the wonderbolts where she became an expert flyer, she has surpassed spitfire in speed and skill, she then settled down in ponyville and became close friends with the apple family, she is now in ponyville and tries to find her cutie mark by being a member of the cutie mark crusaders

/OCs in a nutshell
>> No. 223224
File 134190383092.png - (72.33KB , 603x554 , CoolStory.png )
223224
>>223221
>> No. 223230
File 134190395090.png - (235.59KB , 1131x707 , Luna Bedroom Eyes.png )
223230
>>223213

I'll worry not; this is far too fun for me to.

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223238
File 134190416978.png - (292.78KB , 676x768 , 37.png )
223238
>>223230
I agree. It's too bad we're attracting the attention of several unsavory parties by keeping the thread alive.

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223240
File 134190433347.jpg - (103.13KB , 836x956 , Luna Says Hi.jpg )
223240
>>223238
True enough, I just pretend they don't exist. Easier that way, I think. How long do you suppose this will continue before we are asked to stop?

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223252
File 134190471366.png - (102.51KB , 1280x720 , 29.png )
223252
>>223240
I try to do that sometimes. I am not very good at it all the time though.

I assume we'll be asked to stop withing the next four or five replies.

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo.
>> No. 223258
File 134190488454.jpg - (200.58KB , 850x1100 , Luna in a Hotel.jpg )
223258
>>223252
I'll match that bet and raise you 7 replies.

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223263
File 134190500528.png - (34.50KB , 704x396 , 10.png )
223263
>>223258

Augh, Imma run out of pictures before then.

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223264
>>223258
*raise you TO 7 replies
>> No. 223271
File 134190517786.png - (797.74KB , 1000x1045 , Luna Whoa.png )
223271
>>223263

Muahahaha! Victory is within my grasp...

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo

My goodness, this is becoming like a silent movie by this point...
>> No. 223280
File 134190549390.png - (345.74KB , 895x768 , 40.png )
223280
>>223271

Fine then. I RAISE YOU TO 8 REPLIES!

Silent movies are the best movies.

Mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon mine countenance whereupon your countenance whereupon that pic+reply combo
>> No. 223285
File 134190562451.png - (3.68KB , 195x65 , stop it.png )
223285
>> No. 223288
File 134190573865.png - (68.25KB , 304x336 , Applebloom - 3.png )
223288
>>223213
RPing.

>>223221
trul pls go
>> No. 223292
File 134190581420.gif - (73.03KB , 182x119 , Luna Sad in Rain.gif )
223292
>>223280
>>223285

It would appear that we were both wrong...All right, I'll stop now. T'was fun, though I hope I don't receive too bad a kind of consequence; now I kinda feel bad for derailing this poor thread, albeit momentarily.

There's something I can agree on. Have you ever seen Faust? That was a good one
>> No. 223296
File 134190604689.png - (107.31KB , 592x392 , 9.png )
223296
>>223285
>Mine countenance whereupon-

>>223292

I have a feeling that if !!Scootaloo was actually here, and actually wanted us to stop, they'd actually post as !!Scootaloo instead of using a picture of themselves saying something. But I guess we're done anyways. It was fun while it lasted.

I have not. Remind me to netflix that later.
>> No. 223302
File 134190631561.png - (162.64KB , 600x507 , Luna Vector.png )
223302
>>223296
I'm sure, but frankly I'd just like to play it safe. I try my best to be an upstanding member of this community, you know?

Anyway, I'm pretty sure that it is on netflix, which is where I saw it last. It's a German film, actually. Still really good though, I always liked the story of Faust.
>> No. 223317
File 134190703046.png - (31.56KB , 704x396 , 12.png )
223317
>>223302

Oh, model citizen you. Longpost critiques and luna fan. You're like me, but better.
>> No. 223326
File 134190727732.jpg - (71.98KB , 800x651 , Luna on a Cloud.jpg )
223326
>>223317
Heh, well I dunno about the "better" part. I'm just putting myself out there and helping people out where I can.

I am a big Luna fan, however I do mean to start posting as my OC soon enough. Lack of access to a tablet has made the creation of reaction pictures difficult, though.
>> No. 223382
File 134190886160.jpg - (71.88KB , 685x700 , Luna Good Morning.jpg )
223382
Well anyway, I need to get some shut-eye. I promised myself I'd get to bed before 5 tonight.

Thanks for talking and keeping me company during my late-night escapade. It can sometimes be lobotomizingly difficult to find somepony to talk to this late.

Good night to you, friend!
>> No. 223394
File 134190915792.gif - (2.66MB , 225x127 , 2.gif )
223394
>>223382

Good morning to you as well.
>> No. 224368
trying to fix this thread
>> No. 224371
IT'S ALIVE!

...at last.
>> No. 224698
File 134203543230.png - (348.97KB , 3320x2600 , hiResPony (2).png )
224698
It doesn't seem as alive as I had wished....

Just to bring this thread up and running again.

As some of you already knew, my characters name is Clover Skull (skull in the name of a pony is a horrible thing, I know, but whatever). His special talent is his incredible luck, wich I will explain more later on. He is pretty strong and fast due to his long travels across Equestria. He is also pretty smart, being able to design and build a respirator, that would look like sunglasses. This respirator would in the end be the thing keeping him sane(but more about that later). He is also very bad at magic, being only able to cast the most simpliest spells, like standard unicorn telekinesis, lighting a fire into a fireplace or an oven, and his mother designed spell, that would allow the caster to ferment brewerages at extreme speeds. Someponeis say that this lack of magical skills was balancing his luck. Yhis disability was also that lead to the failure of his respirator(like I said, more about this later). His main color is green, and his manes colors are black and dark purple. His cutie mark is a skull inside a four leaved clover, that represents his luck that have saved his life in many dangers.

His father was an earth pony and his mother was an unicorn. They lived in Manehattan, where they had a brewery, where they made a special kind of cider, called The Red cider, wich brings luck to its drinker. The brewery was a small business, selling small amounts of cider with a medium price since the infredients fr the brew were hard to come by. Only place where most of them could be found was the Everfree Forest.

So one day, when Clover Skull was 6, they ran out of ingredients once again, and Clover Skull and his father went to the forest to get more. They were used in camping in the forest, since collecting the needed ingredients took almost always more than one day. So when the night fell they decided to find a suitable place their camp. During the night Clover Skull woke up. He had a feeling that something terrible was going to happen. He went to wake up his father, and since Clover Skull was often calm, but was now almost paniking, his father knew that Clover Skull was deadly serious. They hid in a cave nearby, and waited. After a few seconds a pack of timberwolves attacked the camp. They tore up the tents to find that their food had gotten away. Clover Skull and his father spent the rest of the night in the cave. When the sun rose at morning Clover Skulls father noticed that a cutie mark had appeared to young Clover Skull.

They returned safely with ingredients for the brew, and for a while everything was alright. Few years passed, but something was wrong with Clover Skulls father. He had nightmares, he saw things that wasn't there, he walked against walls, and even tried to jump of the brewerys roof, thinking he was a bird. He was then taken to Manehattans Pony Asylum. In his last sane moments, few days after he was brought to the asylum, he told Clover Skull, that it was the fumes that formed while making the Red Cider that made him insane.

Clover Skull took over the family brewery at age of 15, and started Designing a fumigator that would allow him to brew Red Cider, without going insane. After a few years of developement, and spells that he didnt fully understand, but that were required for the device to work, he had developed a respirator that looked exactly like sunglasses, that would filter the fumes. Few years passed again, and he was well. But when he took off his respirator glasses he started having hallusinations and nightmares. He went to a powerful unicorn, and asked for help. The unicorn examined the glasses, and told Clover Skull that they didnt filter the fumes, they just prevented it from working. He said that Clover Skull couldnt remove the glasses for longer than couple of hours, since the glasses also prevented the fumes from disappearing from his body. That meant that he actually had larger dose of the fumes in his body than when his father went insane. The unicorn told also that Clover was lucky to have even that effect, since the fumes from Red Cider were unfilterable, because of the fume particles being the same size as air, and filter that would be able to filter them would be airproof. Clover Skull returned home, but kept on working with the Red Cider, since he needed money for him and his mother.

When he was 27 years old his mother passed away. His father was too deep in insanity to be able to talk about anything else than how he would build stairs to the heaven. Couple of weeks passed, and while Clover Skull was buying groceries, he saw smoke coming from the direction of the brewery. He ran back to the brewery to see that it was in flames. The fireponies got there, but it was too late, and most of the brewery was burt almsot to ashes. But even this dark cloud had silver lining, since Clover Skull had just a while ago gotten an insurance for fire damages and he recieved a good amount of bits. He bought new saddle bags, dried apples and other stuff needed for a long trip, and started living his dream. Free from responcibilities, free from past and free from anything that would keep him tied in one place. He started his travels, that would take him across Equestria.

Soooo... What do you think? Something over the top? Something too cliche? every critique is appreciated, adn many parts of story are still changeable. And when I have time, i will write about his adventures that would eventually lead him to Ponyville to see the Summer Sun Celebration.
>> No. 224816
>>224698
And like always i forgot something. I forgot to tell about his personality.

Clover Skull is strong willed, bit egoistic and speaks with accent that sounds like slighty scottish. Like said before he sucks at magic. He was bullied for this during his first days of school, but luckily for him the fillies that bullied him were transfered to far away land callled Metwurstia. He soon got friends, but he still remembers the bullies, and is constantly practising magic, without mych succes.

He is mentally pretty stable as long as he keeps his glasses on, and if he removes them he will slowly fade into meaningless madness, that usually comes in three stages, first comes agression, where he is mad at everything and may start rampage. This usually lasts for a ten to twenty minutes, and mostly he is able to put his sunglasses back on. If he doesnt, comes the second stage, depression. In this stage he usualy jsut sits still and doesnt say a word. If somepony is around they can put him his sunglasses on a ease at this point. Ths stage lasts about 30 minutes. If he isnt wearing his sunglasses after the depression, comes the hallucinations, in wich he will mostly run in fear for about ten minutes, then falling to eternal madness, wich happened to his father.
>> No. 224847
File 134203926436.png - (360.88KB , 3320x2600 , hiResPony.png )
224847
And why isn't this thread on the first page anymore? Nopony can find their way here since it is in dark area of ponychan.

Just kidding, but trying to bump this thread back to first page

I'm just lonely...
>> No. 225996
>>224816
>>224698
Goddamn those typos. Well, now i know that I should not try to write anything when I'm tired.

...yes I'm still trying to bump this to the front page of /OOC

... and I noticed the name thingy, no more subjecting my name.
>> No. 226130
File 134212001101.png - (61.21KB , 442x706 , tiniest six.png )
226130
>>223205

Sorry it took so long for me to respond! Ponychan wasn't working for me.

And thank you SO MUCH for the critique! I never get decent feedback on him, and I'm glad someone can see that his wings aren't just "to be different".
>> No. 226139
File 134212057738.png - (57.80KB , 897x851 , hiResPony.png )
226139
Maybe this thread isn't doomed after all...
>> No. 227263
File 134217403374.png - (26.66KB , 704x396 , 6.png )
227263
Well, I'll be. I made a new thread a couple o' days ago, because this un' dun 404'd. If ya'll want a clean slate, you can head over there.

>>224260

Of course, you don't have to. This thread is probably fine to use if you want. While I'm here,

>>224698

I don't think science works the way you think it does, with the respirator and sunglasses and such, but okay. I mean, I was just fine with the sunglasses being sunglasses. And if they're like sunglasses and cover the eyes, how in the world would they manage to block fumes from his airways? (Mouth and nose, which apparently they don't do anyway)

Numbers below one-hundred should be spelled out. Exact ages aren't that great. You could probably say that he was fifteen when he took over, but it might be better to be vague when describing the childhood timberwolf event.

Why in the world does every OC have to be insane? I mean, seriously. If you can pull it off well during stories or RPs, that's great, but it's mostly become a forced 'cool' trait with the Pinkamena stuff and I don't want to get into that.

Anyway, it's five A.M. and I haven't slept yet. G'morning, whoever reads this.
>> No. 227267
>>227263
I made the sunglasses to be the respirators so that i wouldnt have to remove them from my character in any time. And as explained they werent just scientifical invention, as he used magic to create them. So the thing that would be filtering stuff would be the spell, not exactly the glasses.

Ages were just to explain the timelapse and i didnt mean them to be anything important.

And for the insanity, I can add many sort of things to the character later on. Since insanity is more unlogical than sanity, I would be able to create many sort of twists in upcoming events, adn even create stuff that had happened just inside his head.
>> No. 227268
>>227263
And hey, did you get here trough my "ad" on the front page of /OOC?
>> No. 227360
>>227263
Okay, no. Nononnononononononnonononono. No Pinkie Pie madness. Not anything like when Pinkie Pie snapped. I dont make his insanity have anything common with Pinkie Pie styled funny insanity. No. I'm going to make his insanity more like Jokers from Batman. No fun or nice. Dark, scary and a bit sad. Sorry that this isn't included in original answer, but because I was tired when posting it I didnt realize that you thought that he would snap like Pinkie.

Like I said insanity adds a whole new level of additional materials for character. For example I'm going to give him some sort of a genie companion during his travels. It would not be real genie, since it would be his twisted minds creation to represent his luck, that saves his life, and keeps him fed.

I also could make some sort of a Dream land or Wonderland, that would exist only inside his head. I would be him a place to assemble his broken psyche, under terrible danger or horror.

Nothing like Pinkie Pie, no talking to rocks, no funny snap sounds and twists, If he would do something that kind of stuff, it would be speaking to himself.

And I didnt want it to bee a "cool trait". Insanity is interesting but definately not cool. I would have ditched it a while ago, but I have ideas, that would not work on a sane pony without breaking lore.
>> No. 227365
>>227360
Goddamit these typos.
>Nothing like Pinkie Pie, no talking to rocks, no funny snap sounds and twists, If he would do something that kind of stuff, it would be speaking to himself.

I meant to say that he wont be doing Pinkie Pie stuff. Only "funny" insanity effect would be talking to himself, nothing more.


Delete post []
Password  
Report post
Reason