Discussion of the show, its universe, and its canon

Search /pony/ threads

Password  (for post and file deletion)

Apr 24Site maintenance in progress; posts made right now may be lost to the annals of time
Apr 24Site maintenance in progress; posts made right now may be lost
Mar 31With the Merger coming up soon, we have created an official steam group for the combined sites. It can be found at http://steamcommunity.com/groups/PonychanSteam

File 142796639883.gif - (405.49KB , 650x720 , mlfw4495-1335176681756.gif )
36792931 No. 36792931 [View]
Okay folks up next we have Season 2 Episode 25 and 26, A Canterlot Wedding, Written by: Meghan McCarthy.

The link to the episode:(Combined episode) http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xwr2rv_mlp-fim-s2-e25-e26-a-canterlot-wedding-hd-no-watermarks_shortfilms

Watch this episode again, comment as you do. What did you like/dislike, anything you missed before? Or just general discussion about every little aspect of this episode.


P.S. So this is it for the Re-Visit Threads till a full week after the finally of Season 5. I'll give it a full week so that all the discussion can die down then start these back up for the next between season gap with S3 E1-2 The Crystal Empire. See you guys in the Episode Discussion Threads.
33 posts omitted. (View thread)
>> No. 36794389
File 142893209200.png - (117.25KB , 255x368 , cilan 2 29 1.png )
Does this re-visit thread still need to stay stickied?
>> No. 36794397
yes, forever.
>> No. 36794591

File 142892433560.png - (371.22KB , 1280x720 , Spike_checking_his_claws_S2E10.png )
36794370 No. 36794370 [View]
one thing I like about the new episode is that Spike mentions getting his claws done, which I assume is like a manicure and it's treated like a normal thing for him to do.
2 posts omitted. (Expand)
>> No. 36794406
Oh yeah, aprons, hoofball, manicures, etc.

He's going to grow up sexually confused.

>Rarity: Spike you're so sweet!
>Darling, I like having my mane pulled, I can't love you if you don't!
>> No. 36794437
File 142895509733.gif - (95.63KB , 500x350 , 869176__safe_rarity_animated_cute_upvotes+galore_eyes+closed_bipedal_adorable_transparent+backgr.gif )
he can borrow Rarity's
>> No. 36794557
File 142911031619.jpg - (32.73KB , 403x403 , 9pwtliz75izayki1wqtc.jpg )
Dragons are pretty much oversized cats is what I tend to hear. So he needs to go to the groomer sometimes. He wants to look nice for Rarity.

File 142817321612.jpg - (23.84KB , 526x297 , 526x297-3rV.jpg )
36793118 No. 36793118 [View]
Well, with a dawn of a new season, it's time to bring this back! For those of you who don't remember my old threads, the schtick is that we look at the same numbered episodes from each season and compare them across the board. It's a fun little way to see which seasons really stand out from the rest. Sometimes the choices are easy. Other times doing a proper ranking is really hard and which episode falls where just comes down to how I feel that day.

So, the season premiers. Every single one of them have been a two-parter, so we can compare episodes one and two as a whole. Now, I've only seen the fifth season's premiere once thus far at the time of writing, but I feel like I can accurately rank my thoughts thus far based on my own emotional scale.

The Return of Harmony > Cutie Markless > Princess Twilight Sparkle > Friendship is Magic > The Crystal Empire

The Return of Harmony still stands as my favorite start to a season. Discord's introduction is still possibly his strongest showing, and the drama of corrupting the mane six made the first episode cliffhanger the most effective of the entire series. The ending, however, is very much rushed as it would have been nice to get more out of fixing the characters other than Applejack. Still, in a way it feels more than an actual conclusion to Season 1 than Best Night Ever, if I may be so honest.

You know, for a new episode whose opinion I'm still formulating, placing Cutie Markless at number two is a pretty bold statement, especially since isn't nearly as investing to me as much of its competition. However, apart from some repetitive dialogue in the beginning, it is hugely refreshing for what we've come to expect from a two-parter. The plot itself was well written and well paced, there's some great additional new lore, the promise of a returning villain, new and intriguing characters (even if they could use more screen time), and the fact that TWILIGHT wasn't the crux of saving the day for once! I just feel like out of all the premiers, this one has the least I can complain about.

Princess Twilight Sparkle, by my own admission, is more
18 posts omitted. (View thread)
>> No. 36794417
well let's get some stuff out of the way
>season 1 opening
>twilight is asocial and we establish mythology (manticores, sea serpents most obvious)

>season 2
>lol fuck everybody

>season 3
>forgettable, other than claustrophobic pone
>Rarity is bitch more than generosity

>season 4
>> No. 36794422

It may not technically be as good as the others, but I still like the series premiere for a lot of the things it established, and making the best use of its time. Something that most of the other season openers struggle with.

Cutie Markless has a lot of interesting ideas. Probably more then other episodes, but I don't particularly care for how it was executed. It needed a bit more complexity and development for the Town and Starlight Glimmer for the things it was trying to do to really shine. Without it it kind of feels lacking.

Return of Harmony I think is the most overrated of the premieres. I actually found Discord to be simultaneously overpowered, and unthreatening. Contradictory sounding I know, but that's just how I feel.

Princess Twilight Sparkle did not need to be two episodes and overall just felt unecessary.

The Crystal Empire is just plain not good.
>> No. 36794512
File 142904354268.jpg - (35.66KB , 640x482 , looncel.jpg )
Friendship is magic is the ONE episode that I would want to see remade and done again.

It had so much potential, and failed to live up to everything it could have been. Not to say that its BAD. I like it. Its just it could have been done so much better.

Make the Mane six exemplifying their elements be done better and less hokey (AJ's for example is really bad since she didn't really DO anything that a normal person wouldn't have done. there was zero incentive to life in such a situation).

Show us more of Nightmare moon and Celestia, maybe some flashbacks. Hell, maybe have Celestia imprisoned by Luna with Luna preparing a spell to send Celestia to the moon, with it being stopped by the mane six arriving. Give us some more insight to the two.

No. 36793751 [View]
Youtube embed play button
  Twilight Sparkle and Starlight Glimmer Discussion


1. Similar Names: A sparkling twilight and a glimmering starlight are very similar scenes

2. Same talents: Both ponies studied magic for years, and appear to have similar cutiemarks

3. Same mission: Twilight Sparkle wants to spread friendship and harmony all across Equestria. Starlight Glimmer wanted to spread friendship and harmony all across Equestria

36 posts omitted. (View thread)
>> No. 36794288
this is the reason Sunset Shimmer is my favorite character as good as the mane six are THIS! This is a character I can get behind! considering Phoenixes are my favorite mythological creature and Sunset's redemption is just one big ass Phoenix Metaphor there is ABSOLUTELY no fucking reason why I can dislike Sunset
>> No. 36794289
File 142886008216.png - (145.53KB , 303x391 , 5b1fd63b5cb6049ccd2b4ed3978298ef-d7p1neb.png )
what about she being a shallow tool which arc is faster than sanic
>> No. 36794462
File 142899032500.png - (120.18KB , 630x630 , i.png )

File 142894311922.png - (260.87KB , 1170x1024 , 1428942559348.png )
36794412 No. 36794412 [View]
why do their episodes suck so much
>> No. 36794414
No, you
>> No. 36794438
File 142895662302.jpg - (72.59KB , 960x539 , is this supposed to be bait.jpg )
>> No. 36794461
Which ones?

And do you mean just the ones where they are in a group? Or do you mean their individual focussed episodes as well?

File 142876311592.png - (295.86KB , 900x638 , csc.png )
36794017 No. 36794017 Autosaged [View] [Last 50 posts]
This thread is meant for discussing impressions on episode 503, Castle Sweet Castle, written by Joanna Lewis & Kristine Songco, during and after it airs.

Be mindful of saying spoilers before they show up on TV. Until then, keep that sort of stuff in the Anticipation Thread.
346 posts omitted. (View thread)
>> No. 36794701
File 142925626648.gif - (44.96KB , 500x500 , eyebrows.gif )
"I'm Princess Twilight Sparkle, and this is my favorite store in Canterlot."
>> No. 36794704
File 142927380278.png - (371.80KB , 538x556 , Is it really.png )
In general, just about all songs in S3 and beyond have been kinda "meh" to me.

Not bad, just nowhere near as good as S1/S2.
>> No. 36794707
File 142927889859.jpg - (133.17KB , 720x576 , Mr_Horse_blue_peek.jpg )

File 142894457336.jpg - (219.54KB , 1920x1080 , thing.jpg )
36794418 No. 36794418 [View]
Is this what I think it is? Collapsing toy/push puppet? They're little old toy things with internal strings, and if you compress the base, the model goes limp. Once you release it goes back to being taut.

I've been thinking of seeing if there was a market for these kind of pone toys, especially one for Pinkie Pie since the models behave most like pronking.

Last edited at Mon, Apr 13th, 2015 10:03

>> No. 36794425
Youtube embed play button
I had one of these when I was a kid -- a Disney Pluto. Their possibilities are limited.
>> No. 36794436
File 142895500845.png - (599.10KB , 850x975 , 2.png )

No. 36794359 [View]
Youtube embed play button
  German translations make pinkie's smile song sound extra "you will have a good day because it pleases me".
10 posts omitted. (Expand)
>> No. 36794402
Youtube embed play button
I shot my mouth off without thinking. "Smile, Smile, Smile" has perfectly okay (if blah) rhymes until the last verse and the wind-up at the end. As MLP lyrics go, it's practically Cole Porter.
>> No. 36794413
Is German significantly less varied than English? It didn't sound like there was as many different sounds, though they do have a faster pace for them. A lot more esh/echt, etc, of course.
>> No. 36794419
Naah, German's about like English when it comes to number of rhymes per word. French-speakers think German, Dutch, and English all sound very similar.

Last edited at Mon, Apr 13th, 2015 10:09

File 142822289867.png - (344.09KB , 431x1024 , large (49).png )
36793384 No. 36793384 [View]
If you consider episodes Magical Mystery cure and Cutie Markless, what have you learned about the powers of a cutie mark?
21 posts omitted. (View thread)
>> No. 36794343
>that pic
I was expecting the villain to do that at the climax...
>> No. 36794348
File 142889586750.jpg - (53.00KB , 736x1086 , d.jpg )

I don't think that would turn out well for her.
>> No. 36794355
File 142889752687.jpg - (740.86KB , 806x4096 , tall.jpg )
Applebloom just isn't pony enough to handle cutie mark magic.

File 142816732996.jpg - (7.87KB , 295x171 , images.jpg )
36793087 No. 36793087 [View]
Well...That premiere was amazing!
56 posts omitted. (View thread)
>> No. 36794323
Well, they're no better than anypony else at finding stuff.

I don't like the looks that Double Diamond is giving Twilight's booty, though...
>> No. 36794324
And with equal mark, she'd give TERRIBLE sex.

Think it over diamond, its not worth it.
>> No. 36794349
File 142889608452.png - (113.23KB , 900x625 , tv.png )

I missed this. time to rewatch the episode i suppose

Last edited at Sun, Apr 12th, 2015 20:34

File 142832700264.gif - (863.04KB , 511x289 , 854337__safe_solo_pinkie+pie_animated_screencap_spoiler-colon-s05_whipped+cream.gif )
36793519 No. 36793519 [View] [Last 50 posts]
This episode's title is Castle Sweet Castle, written by Joanna Lewis & Kristine Songco.

>Princess Twilight's friends are surprised to discover that she has not been spending much time at all at her new castle, and once they learn the reason why, they all join together to try and make it a more comfortable place for her.

This episode airs Saturday, April 11th at 11:30 AM EST/ 8:30 AM PST.
80 posts omitted. (View thread)
>> No. 36794051
File 142876813233.png - (113.77KB , 1599x673 , Book of the book.png )
0/10, needed more books.
>> No. 36794313
The song is supposed to sound weird, I'd say. It was clear RIGHT at the beginning: AJ starts grabbing her stuff and it's like "OH BOY HERE WE GO."
>> No. 36794318
File 142887547991.png - (920.25KB , 879x1024 , spike_doll.png )

Okay, get off your meds dude; it wasn't bad, but its not THAT good. I'd say 8/10, but its nowhere near Exceptional tier :/


Alright, that IS a good touch, I will agree.

File 142819451454.jpg - (399.97KB , 1207x731 , science.jpg )
36793273 No. 36793273 [View]
Why do some people hate CMC episodes so much?

I find them to all have likable personalities and their shtick has them always doing something new
15 posts omitted. (Expand)
>> No. 36793813
File 142860881754.png - (0.97MB , 1363x737 , Balloons_deflating_S03E04.png )
I love the CMC episodes.
>> No. 36793823
I want Faust's show. :P
>> No. 36794297
People hate character driven stuff. It doesn't help they play the CMC straight: they're children. Enthusiastic, oblivious children.

File 142860789817.png - (287.29KB , 3293x2028 , trixie and glimmers marks.png )
36793808 No. 36793808 [View]
I'm predicting Trixie and Glimmer are estranged sisters. It just fits too well - Glimmer's attitude stemming from Trixie being an insufferable braggart, both leaving home on their opposing missions. It's even likely that Glimmer discovered her talent for manipulating other ponies by playing on her friends' dislike of Trixie.
7 posts omitted. (Expand)
>> No. 36794271

Why not? I could see Discord creating his own element team if he gets fed up with the mane six not trusting him.
>> No. 36794272

They could have three with each pone as powerful as the two of them - return of the Sirens perhaps?
>> No. 36794295
I was honestly hoping Glimmer's cutie mark was the equal sign. Somehow it just would've fit better.

File 142846063549.jpg - (65.55KB , 597x640 , MLP Google Trends 15-04-07.jpg )
36793728 No. 36793728 [View]
Well, I had figured that internet interest in P0ni had peaked, but Google Trends (pic) shows a new high reached after the S5 opener.

Can anyone explain why interest is centered in Mongolia?
7 posts omitted. (Expand)
>> No. 36793942
Youtube embed play button
>> No. 36794119
Youtube embed play button
  So basically, pony interest has decreased since season 4 everywhere except for

the mongols
>> No. 36794266
File 142882382905.jpg - (523.37KB , 1280x720 , tumblr_mg9u43Vusi1rlo1q2o1_1280.jpg )

File 142672628289.jpg - (174.48KB , 619x1600 , 142672487468.jpg )
36792102 No. 36792102 [View]
The Greeks had four solid concepts for what Love is. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_words_for_love

Agape, Eros, Philia, and Storge.

If Cadance embodies Love, does she embody all of these, just one or something else?
7 posts omitted. (Expand)
>> No. 36794013
What do the two blue lines at the left mean?
>> No. 36794110
File 142878475921.gif - (572.09KB , 650x450 , 02402.gif )
Yes, Cadence covers all four quadrants.
>> No. 36794164
Well, Cadance sure doesn't cover Philia, that's Twilight's job now.

We've only seen her handle romantic love so far, so I'm guessing that's her department.

So does this mean she has her own Cutie Map and she and Shining travel Equestria helping ponies get married or something?

Delete post []
Report post

[0] [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11]